In post 46, Almost50 wrote: In post 23, Creature wrote:Well, no one seemed to make an interesting post, so I'll vote the one I think is scummiest.
VOTE: Almost50
Hello, Creature. Y'know, I would've scum read you if your RVS went on anyone else!
An early joke towards creature, a50 likes making these. There's some other nonsense there too. Early stuff like this is hard to make pairings with though.
In post 156, Almost50 wrote: In post 147, TheBrie wrote:Don't play when you're drunk.
But seriously even if Chick turns out to be scum. We've been playing for only a few days and she's at L-2 based on only a couple of things she said.
I'm calling a Chika/Brie/A50 scum team
This. A50 meta means whenever he calls scumteams he is on, or in general, he pretty much always includes at least one teammate. WIFOM but let's keep looking.
In post 214, Almost50 wrote: In post 213, Creature wrote:Right now explaining my scumread would mean telling scum what to do to get townread.
Like, I'm leaning Town on you, but let it go on the record that I'm giving up on trying to figure how your brain works. I will always read you (or try to) by whom you vote rather than why!!!!!
Creature favor. Not sure if buddying or pocketing but I feel maybe the latter.
In post 357, Almost50 wrote:I'd be interested in knowing:
a) Why do you TR java (I have him at null)
b) What do you have on GL (considering he is currently widely Town read).
c) I know Snarky is like this as either alignment, but will you be willing to vote there if we can't seem to find a better option? A compromise lynch, maybe?
Throwing me out there as a PL if they can't get something going. Not something a scum partner would draw attention to, more something they'd jump on if someone else brought attention to it.
In post 404, Almost50 wrote: In post 403, SnarkySnowman wrote:And a readlist:
massive: pretty townie overall. hasn't done a whole lot though.
Creature: Not a lot of big posts, but I get what he's going for and strong gut feel this is town.
Guilty: Was townposting pretty much all day, but was quick to give up on the desp wagon to split hairs over the chicka wagon. I'm wary, but this is a townread.
GD: Was very townie early on, but not having any scumreads and largely ignoring the desp wagon sits really badly with me.
Chickadee: Despite the bad / selfish play, I actually think this is town. I'm going to steal her color-coded read thing and do that here.
boring: has pinged both townie and scum. Null for now. Seems to have info about desp we don't. A good explanation for it could move this to a townread.
Rauth: I have noticed little to nothing from this one.
Javajoe: not a clue. needs more activity.
podo: leaning scum. Has had some good posts that make me think he could be town. Pretty sure he can't be the same alignment as desp.
a50: bad play, scumclaim jokes, overreacting, picking at the wrong things.. sounds like typical a50. Scumlean, but for a lot of other people this would be deathtunnel territory.
Brie: reads scum, but this will sort itself out with time given the ability.
desp: Scum as shit. The claim I guess is believable, and can be confirmed after used twice and people say "yea I got it" but I don't know. It's also not a wildly useful role I feel.
If I missed anyone they're null and I don't remember what they've said/done so far
This looks like the most fake read list that I have ever seen. Bonus town points for anyone who picks a reason or two this is the case.
VOTE: SS
And then he deathtunnels me once I start being active. That's some opportunistic shit. I said it then and I'm saying it again. If you call that bussing, man, that's some awfully aggressive and dangerous bussing.
There are lots more of his posts to corroborate that but I'll leave you with the first one.
In post 818, Almost50 wrote:I'm going to have to sit on this for a while and think things over. This is too complicated for me to grasp it all at once.
Points of interest:
1- TheBrie precisely said 9-3-1 yesterday, so there was only ONE GOO as of the end of D1.
2- podoboq did NOT have an ACTIVE ability to recruit. His was PASSIVE. He had to be VISITED by Town to convert them.
3- [deleted] I'm not sure of this one, so I'll just ask the mod below.
4- I believe podo was shot by scum for crumbing a TPR that had a "mechanical reason" to TR SS. They must've thought he was an informative (Tracker/Watcher/Follower..etc.)
5- GD could have granted one or two players BP vests already. The question is if he had given them to Town players (so as to make it harder for scum to win with their NKs).
6- I killed GD with my CPR (Sorry)
I thought he had been very manipulative while rereading after the day ended. He had SS as the scummiest player in the game at one point, but then decided he was voting between Chika and massive (and he did put massive @L-1) only to do a 180 on Rauther and push him to the lynch.
@Mod: Does the "recruited goo" have the ability to recruit too? And if not; do they die when the original recruiter die?
Blind trust in the roleclaims seems to be a generally scum idiosyncrasy for almost but could also be "my partner brie is fakeclaiming let's make sure I buy it"?? that may be a bit of a stretch....
In post 835, Almost50 wrote:I'm 100% sure TheBrie is not a goo. Her role had no "visiting" ability, so she could not have come in contact with podo on either night.
Also Chicka obviously used he ability on massive, and I'm assuming she didn't use it on N0 because she wasn't a double voter on D1.
So there's two players we know mechanically cannot be goo.
If the answer to my question in the previous post is yes, then I can clear myself and Desp by acting on the same target tonight, or even better .. Desp could be confirmed today by reaching someone and then I could be confirmed by night using the ability on the same target Desp will.
But this is all concerning the goo alone. And if we only look for that we would easily lose to Scum.
If we scum hunt though and it turns out we do have a goo alive then we will lose to that. Hmmmm
The only way to keep the goo contained is to limit the use of night action, but that is clearly sub-optimal, and I'm at a loss.
But to back up the last thing the math doesn't add up given we saw massive and chicka flip black goo.
In post 842, Almost50 wrote: In post 841, Creature wrote:I think we could make the Black Goos claim (if they have more than one) and we all target them.
Why do I feel like you're softing goo yourself?
OK, let me roll with this out-of-the-box idea: We eliminate ourselves as a TOWN faction and become a Goo faction. But then what? We will all be w/o night action. It's like we are all VTs (in that sense). Then what?
Hmm..
In post 851, Almost50 wrote:Good catch, Chicka.
VOTE: Creature
I think THIS is the goo guy. His play D2 is super strange.
This was the first thing he posted in response to the opening post by the mod.
Then we talk and lay ideas and some vote/unvote people, and all he has to say is:
He even was the one who had the answer to my question to the mod:
In post 838, Creature wrote: In post 1, Xylthixlm wrote:Black Goo (cult; super-rare; 4+ players): Whenever a player targets you with an action, they will join your cult as another black goo.
And he followed that up with the proposition:
In post 841, Creature wrote:I think we could make the Black Goos claim (if they have more than one) and we all target them.
This sequence of posts lead me to believe Creature is actually promoting the cult. He is neglecting everything else.
I could lynch this, or we could all agree NOT to target him tonight and try to lynch Mafia instead. What do you think?
Leaning more towards Creature is not a buddy here.
In post 856, Almost50 wrote:Town: Desperado, Chickadee, TheBrie
Goo: Creature
Lynch pool: Massive, Snarky, GL, Java
Does anyone thing GL+Massive could be scum together and ended up voting Chicka on their own by the end of D1? If yes, then one of Snarky/Java is scum. If no, then both Snarky & Java are scum. Take your pick.
Note the pools he offers.
In post 859, Almost50 wrote: In post 857, Javajoe24 wrote:Did you miss my soft claim A50? I had a question for my three main town reads including yourself I would like an answer to
Oh. I forgot. It's not a conclusive Town Role, but I don't see the scum!motive behind the claim.
OK.. that leaves me with massive, GL & SS.
And no.. I don't think you should out who got the BP. That would only help Scum plan their NK.
Same pool here. Makes no sense he puts both his partners in the 3-man lynchpool.
In post 1017, Almost50 wrote: In post 988, Creature wrote:Oh right, A50 probably shot one of podo/Gingham. Either he shot podo (aka he's goo) or he shot Gingham (and then I wonder why he thinks I'm town who killed podo and became goo).
You seriously need to read FOR COMPREHENSION.
1-If I'm SCUM I could not have been turned goo.
2-If I'm Town, the turning resolves before the kill, meaning I would have been turned BEFORE I could kill podo.
3-If I'm neither Scum nor goo, there's no need for me to lie.
4-I didn't say you KILLED podo. I said you TARGETED him, but SCUM also shot him.
More feelings of this can't be scum with Creature.