Let's see what Eek says - I hope he didn't target rogue...
He did. He already said he did. Furthermore that was the plan yesterday.
I've been rereading the whole thread trying to get a feel for all the players and the game as a whole. It's been interesting and I'm going to give my views on all the players and why.
1.) Phoebius -
Scum
. Not even scummy at this point. Rereading I do not like the vig claim at all and, based on the night actions, I really dont like how it went out. He is, 100%, my vote for scum for the day.
2.) Jenter -
Unhelpful Town / Mildly Scummy
9 whole posts, nothing really useful to be found in them. The reason I say mildly scummy was it was Jent who mentioned with a Recruiter 2 maf would make sense and, for some reason, that makes me question him being the secret third maf if we are wrong.
3.) Mr.Flay -
Highly Town
. Flay has actively been trying to help discussion and move the town forward. There's sure been a focus on lukers and questionable voting, both of which I approve of.
4.) Muffinhead / Korts -
Mildly Town
. Korts really felt like, although poorly, he was trying to scumhunt. Muffin's posts make my eyes hurt but, from what I can pull out he does seem to be trying to help the town albeit not what, to me, seems well.
5.) Flameaxe -
Lurker / Moderately Scummy
. Agressive without rationale out of the box and his one real post with a decent amount of content doesn't sit right. Partially OMGUS because he says he's hoping for more contribution from me by Day 4 posting. Definitely too low to get a read on and we're approaching the point where thats becoming scummy.
6.) Eek / Nitro -
Town?
Claiming cop could be a good scumroute but with tracker claims out it gets a little hairer. Nitro had 2 posts which could be luker-copdom. I think Eek, for now, is townish.
7.) Grimmy -
Highly Suspicious Town
. Not a whole lot of content but a decent amount of posts I guess (more than I thought, which says something for the content). Eluded to being able to clear Rogue if he didn't die and said he would claim today - haven't seen that claim and, honestly, would have forgot about it all together if I hadn't reread. Also, quasi-justifies Phoebius not just saying who he targeted. Blah.
8.) Farside22 -
Quasi-Confirmed Town
. If it wasn't for the fact the cop, whom I believe as of now, confirmed him I'd think he was scummy. It felt like he was defending ZZ and Rogue to a high degree and was 1-tracked on K7 aside from it.
9.) Spyre -
OMG TOWN
. I thought about not putting myself in at all, but sure. I've tried to be as scum-hunty as I can and, being able to read my PM, sure helps me clear myself.
10.) OGML -
Highly Town
. Right now, OGML would be the only one that if they were scum would make my jaw literally drop. Agressively scumhunting and trying to keep the game moving ahead. Also, as I'll point out below, smart enough not to be scum bussing a buddy day 1.
11.) Rogue -
Dead Scummy Town
. I still dont believe the flip on some level. After day 1 I was SURE he was going to be sucm.
12.) Killa 7 -
Dead Unhelpful Town
. Thats all I have to say.
13.) ZZ -
Town MVP!
. Of my reading, I think ZZ is going to give me the most help for this game. Here's my reasons (this is gonna get really meta gamey but).
a.) ZZ flipping
recruiter
scum, to me, clears both OGML and Flay. Flay wouldn't have been stupid enough to just let a scumbuddy try to policy lynch him (chances are high that one of the two would be dead for it - probably ZZ). OGML -might- have powerbussed a scumbuddy day 1 but he sure as hell wouldn't have done it to the damn recruiter. If it was only two and they were determined to bus, it would have been the other way around.
b.) ZZ tried to paint me as town to setup a town-lynch down the road if he was caught. It was subtle, but he did really try to say I, specifically, felt like town. Now, this sure doesn't clear me, but hopefully my actions will help show that I AM town and this was a, in my opinion, nice I've screwed up move by ZZ to try and get a town devoured later.
c.) Aside from the above, ZZ tried to push a bandwagon on Korts / Muffinhead. This, sadly, doesn't absolve Muffin in my mind since it could be the other side of the saying I'm town coin. Worth mentioning though. Esepcailly towards the end when he says korts is being obvious scum - this feels almost WIFOMY.
d.) The only two people he really mentions by names are Flame and Nitro for lurking votes. This, I think was just trying to sound "towny".
e.) He doesn't mention, ever, in any fashion Phoebius. Even though Pheebs put him at L-1. I know its partially because I think Phoebius is scum but this really doesn't sit right.
So, in general as it sits now I say:
Phoebius today
Lurkers need to post more
Jenter / Muffin tomorrow - depending on how things go (if there IS a tomorrow)