NY 118 - BBM's Large Normal Mafia (Game!)

[Robbnva]

1. This makes no sense to me at all, how is me speculating what Dana is doing seem like him and I are buddy buddy?

2. This is an obvious following Xite instead of making your own case

3. Your entire vote history has lacked merit, not once do you make a case on anyone you vote for

1) Why is it that nothing makes sense to you?
2) No it's not, he added his own content, my case on you is based on your play throughout all of day2 and today.
3) I agree with this one here
Your whole set of points here looks a lot like bussing to me...

1. because he provided no evidence of me being buddy buddy with dana, and I doubt he would be able to since it never happened
2. he did not add anything of value, just a made up statement with nothing to support it
3. meh, your opinion means dick to me
last i checked townie can't buss mafia, unless there is some new rule I missed.

[Robbnva]

game with PM - http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... &start=600

game with QT - http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 54&t=15042

site where I play normally on a 3 different mafia private forums - http://goallineblitz.com/game/home.pl

on the last one, send a PM to papa zito if you want him to verify there are mafia forums on this site

[Robbnva]

@xite that first game, go to the end, somebody asks for a qt and I tell him it was PM only

oh but now I think of it, it was only at night. My mistake

[Robbnva]

I'll give you benefit of the doubt X for now cause I guess I could see that happen(although unlikely)

vote hip hop

votes no reason
laying low and active lurking

[Robbnva]

Kise I think lynching Dana can be postponed one day, I do like the fact you are looking for the godfather. What is your opinion on hip hop?

Who besides Dana would you personally try and lynch?

[Robbnva]

@antihero - I have never been in a large game without a GF so thinking that it's possible isn't a stretch. Tbh I am sort of suprised to see there is not a SK and even more shocked to see somebody is 2 for 2 on mafia kills yet we can't seem to lynch any

[Robbnva]

I don't like the whole WIFOM by dana and sadly wraith is still making the most sense out of the 2 of them

vote dana

[Robbnva]

Ah! I misunderstood.

He didn't post for the majority of D2, and all his defensive D3 posts are him speculating on obscure, rare roles. Admittedly this is a BBM game and I'd be far from surprised to see one of those role, but I doubt that's his train of thought.

That second part...
Who? I don't really recall that from dana, but I can go back and look.

Also, are we all forgetting how scummy robbie really is?

seeming scummy =/= actually being scummy. I am not scum and will keep saying that til I do eventually die and when I flip town you will be like holy shit he was telling the truth.

2nd. whoever said I was scummy for putting mysterio at L-1. first I did not realize that was L-1, 2nd I had already showed my suspicion on him, 3rd the person who hammers without allowing the person to claim, especially when that person was the doctor is the one we should actually be lynching today. Even if he turns out to be town there is NO EXCUSE to not let a person claim before the hammer. It has happened to me twice on this site already and it is fucking lame. On my other site I have seen a cop,watcher, doctor, and vigilante all hammered without claims.

Hammering without allowing a claim is the most NON-TOWN action a person can do and so with that

Vote bunnylover

there is no valid reason why you don't allow someone to claim, deadline wasn't that close that he could not wait for mysterio to claim

@ Hiphop, I still think you are scum, my reasons are still valid. you fly under the radar and you vote for no reason or for ridiculous reasons and that adds up to scum in my book but there are bigger fish to fry.

[Robbnva]

Whatever, I'm done with your shit for real

I won't be back til I'm prodded, Xite I'd you are town you fail

[Robbnva]

I don't care how scummy you think I played early in the game, that's really not the issue at all. I have claimed cop, and unless you can prove beyond a shadow of a doubt that I am NOT cop, you should think VERY seriously indeed about trying to lynch me.
I agree with Xite, though, and I'm not going to talk anymore about people targetting me during the night, since I really don't know what happens during the night anyway, except who I choose to investigate.

K I know I wasn't going to say anything else but this post is a big fucking pile of horseshit. He doesn't say he is cop, he doesn't sound like a cop defending himself

he says I claimed cop and you can't prove I'm lying so until somebody else can don't lynch me

not sure where my vote was but to clarify

vote Dana

real cop would not word it like he has

[Robbnva]

Okay, so anyone not voting for Robbie, I would like a reason as to why that does not have ANYTHING to do with WIFOM. (AKA claimed cop discussion)

quoting for when I flip town you guys have something to go back on and look at who started the wagon on me.

Xite i have 1 question for you.

How sure are you I am scum? Will you stake your own life in this game on it?

Let's see how big of a man you really are, When (was going to say If but basically you are making sure that I get lynched) I die and I flip town i think you should agree to be the next lynch regardless of what your role is or your alliance (town or mafia)

THAT is how sure I am that I am pro-town and I will be so bold as to make that bet because I know you are a pussy and won't accept it.

oh and inb4 flailing scum comments cause this is flailing town right here.

you guys really need to ask yourself these questions before you lynch somebody.

1. Is this person playing like how you would play if you were mafia?
2. Have you ever been mafia with somebody who has played like that?
3. How would mafia get far in a game if they played like that.

You say my logic is crap logic but I play HARDCORE mafia and this site is so tame compared to where I play and SMART mafia does one the following

1. Lay low - (hip Hop)
2. act super pro-town (Xite)
3. deflects when is accused of something
4. is most against a day one lynch of a townie or avoid the wagon of a townie all together.

now if this bandwagon continues (BAD FUCKING IDEA) I would like the mod to PM me when I am L-2 or L-1 because I seriously refuse to post in this game anymore if town is going to fail like they are if they lynch me.

[Robbnva]

now if this bandwagon continues (BAD FUCKING IDEA) I would like the mod to PM me when I am L-2 or L-1 because I seriously refuse to post in this game anymore if town is going to fail like they are if they lynch me.

So...you JUST implied you were good at mafia...

oh I am the fucking rockstar of playing mafia, I am the 2nd coming of christ when it comes to mafia. I play so good I am considered a threat because all the morons think because somebody speaks their mind they are scum.

yes I have an inflated ego but I am a GREAT scum hunter, this game is kind of hard becuase the first 2 mafia who have dieD have done exactly what I said mafia does.

STAY UNDER THE FUCKING RADAR

But Xite calls my logic flawed, yet I have proven it 2 times in this game already. Now the remaining mafia (if it is just one group) will fall under the other criteria.

make a list of the 3 people in this game you think are the most pro-town and I am willing to bet one of them is mafia. Right now Xite is my biggest candidate, especially if dana flips scum.

anyone who thinks that statement by dana was a pro-town cop comment, seriously you shoudl just walk away from mafia and never play again, his post basically DARED you to not lynch him, you need to call his fucking bluff.

[Robbnva]

and I changed my mind, I am not going to stay away, that is too easy. I am going to go full on extreme in your face for the rest of today. if you guys are gonna fail at town and lynch me than I am gonna call BS on every BS post that I see.

and when I die i don't want to hear any "well he failed the town with his play style' cause that is fucking moronic craplogic. I am pro-town, I can't help anyone out other than pointing out true scum, but i am pro-town regardless and lynching me is failtown for not realizing I am speaking the truth.

USE YOUR BRAINS PEOPLE.

[Robbnva]

I've NEVER IN MY LIFE seen someone so fantastically amazing at mafia resort to AtE. That's something I've only ever seen with n00bs and scum.

[Robbnva]

We want to talk about some scummy behavior

Will be voting dana as soon as I see the votecount (don't want to get anywhere near L-1/hammer without a LOT more conversation)

but than his VERY NEXT POST (cut out his wall of text quotes of other people and his fluff responses and just posting the meat of his post)

First, Frank is also scum
Dana could just be really bad town, but depending on other flips could be scum too.

changing your mind so soon?

Or we could just skip the mislynch and lynch you now?

Unvote, Vote Frank

WAY TO GO, you skipped the mislynch

Okay, so my scum list

Frank
Wraith
Bunny

My not-so-sure but still suspicious of them being scum list

Dana

oh wait so the post RIGHT BEFORE THIS ONE, you say you are going to vote dana but now he isn't on your scum list?

Jdodge
Hiphop

So, yeah

so if this isn't an attempt to distance himself from the dana wagon after origially saying he would join the dana wagon, than I don't know what is

NOW

Dana is getting quite a large wagon again and we get this post

Okay, so anyone not voting for Robbie, I would like a reason as to why that does not have ANYTHING to do with WIFOM. (AKA claimed cop discussion)

Umm excuse me when did you become the leader of the game? my interpretation of this is if you are not voting robbnva you need to explain why.

really this isn't scummy to anyone? (notice he wants everyone to ignore the fake cop claim because he doesn't think that is a valid reason to not vote me when his reasoning on why a role blocker would not block a cop doesn't make any logical sense)

Scum team = Dana and Xite it is so damn obvious.

[Robbnva]

now what better way to "earn town cred" than to stay away from the wagon of the fake claim cop and lynch the person who was attacking the fake cop.

looking back I went against my own theories and agreed to the frank wagon when I knew damn well he wasn't scummy, I fucking listened to Xite who did a great job at trying to convince people he was scum, we all got sucked in.

look back, Xite was all over that wagon trying to make him look scummy so when he flpped town he could be "oh shit I was so sure he was scum you guys agreed so don't blame me"

[Robbnva]

let's test the cop

Vote Xite

Xite comes up scum than lynch dana

[Robbnva]

and remember pro-town result =/= actual pro town. If he is GF

[Robbnva]

Okay, so anyone not voting for Robbie, I would like a reason as to why that does not have ANYTHING to do with WIFOM. (AKA claimed cop discussion)

quoting for when I flip town you guys have something to go back on and look at who started the wagon on me.

Xite i have 1 question for you.

How sure are you I am scum? Will you stake your own life in this game on it?

Uhm, it should be pretty damn sure who started the wagon, I've only been trying for 2 days.

And, I would be willing to stake my life on it,

if I were town

, but that's just not a pro-town thing to do.
However, I will stake my avatar on it.

did you guys miss where Xite admits he is not town?

scumslip? if he isn't town he is 3rd party or scum. I am 100% fucking town and when you lynch me you will have egg on your damn faces.

and my vote on Xite isn't OMGUS cause day 2 I made a LEGIT case on him that he still has not been able to refute with logical responses. The case he made on me day 2 is a horrible case to lynch somebody.

[Robbnva]

@Xite - your on for the avatar bet. when I flip town you wear whatever avatar I pick out for you.

[Robbnva]

UA, you know your vote's still on you?

I am. I'm waiting for a vote count, which I've been promised is coming soon. Expect my vote to switch after it happens

You shouldn't need a vote count for a vote. You vote on whoever you think ought to be killed the most, needing a vote count to decide for you means you're probably gonna hop on a wagon with no reason why, which is lazy or scummy.

Or he's trying to avoid the same situation we had yesterday, with a lynch before a claim.

Speaking of which! Robb, as soon as that VC confirms my count (you being at L-3, I believe), I expect a claim.

I am not claiming at L-3 so suck it homie

[Robbnva]

unvote, vote poro

You know what? Rob's too scummy to be scum. There I said it.

So Xite says he isn't town and you still vote poro?

[Robbnva]

Didn't someone say Benmage coached Xite at one point?

Benmage asked xite if Xite had implied that he(Ben) was coaching him(xite)

[Robbnva]

unvote, vote poro

You know what? Rob's too scummy to be scum. There I said it.

So Xite says he isn't town and you still vote poro?

I guess I missed that. Where did that happen?

Scroll up, I quoted, bolded, and underlined it

[Robbnva]

Stop nitpicking. It just makes you look even worse.

I already said that putting the blame on me is fail logic

I make more sense this game and my logic has already been proven correct twice

the comment by Dana is CLEARLY a throw down laughing in your face cause he knows you won't lynch him

the real cop needs to end this charade before another pro-town player gets lynched

and I am reckless, as proven in the Sudo newbie game, I'll self hammer as a townie just to spite the town idiots who can't see the writing on the wall

I have provided you better evidence at why Xite and Dana is scum than the evidence Xite has provided that I am scum yet you follow him like sheep.

[Robbnva]

Wow

[Robbnva]

Boy got awfully quiet in here

[Robbnva]

God dammit Lowell

Unvote
Vote: Robb

Claim and stop grasping at straws, good sir

Only flailing mafia needs to grasp at straws, the fact that you people are so tunnel visioned you let Xite poison your mind is what is failing the town. You don't know Xite is clear and the only one who cleared him is the cop who many suspect is fake claiming, yet you let him lead you down to the pit of despair

1. I'm not claiming til I see a vote count and I am close enought to warrant it
2. You won't beleive me when I claim anyway although I did drop a clue a couple of times
3. Won't matter if I claim or don't claim cause if I don't get lynched, I'll surely be NK'd

[Robbnva]

I am super backup, when mysterio died I assumed role of doctor

thanks for failing cause even if I'm not lynched I'm dead tonight.

Now listen to me and vote Xite or Dana

atleast twice i threw the word super in my post

think I said super confused once and super excited the other time.

[Robbnva]

@ evil

I am not playing anti town, don't blame me for town's fail

xite made a weak case against me and my rebuttle was valid

I made a case vs him and his rebuttle was crap

I have pointed out his contradictions and scum behavior
I pointed out where he said he wasn't town
I pointed out where Dana laughed in your face saying you won't lynch him

you guys get tunnel visioned and you listened to Xite's garbage logic

so don't fucking blame me for your mistakes

man up and say "damn I made the mistake not robbnva"

bunch of idiots you are

[Robbnva]

I don't care what Xite's case against you is today, I made my own case Day 2 on why I thought you were scum. Extreme flailing, an unusual claim, and almost downright flaming really don't help you in my eyes.

Only reason I haven't voted yet is because I'm waiting for the count.

Wow if you are town you are gonna have a bigger target on your back if you hammer me and if your mafia you would be dumb to hammer me

[Robbnva]

This is what I want to do: Lynch Rob. If Dana doesn't come through with better play, lynch him tomorrow. THEN lynch Xite. If both dana and Robb somehow flip town Xite will be my top suspect.

have said it all game, I'm gonna flip town

tonight I'll be looking for a new avatar for xite

[Robbnva]

Super Backup! You take the role of the first pro-town power role to die. You win when all threats to the town are eliminated.

[Robbnva]

Best paraphrae from my role pm bitches

TOWN FAILS BLAME YOURSELF NOT ME!

[Robbnva]

Mad at people who blame the victim? Yes bro I'm mad

everything I have said this game has been ignored because people beleive Xite, even when I show how he is wrong, nobody listens

don't blame me for this, blame the person who pushed it and the people who blindly followed