New York 131: Tricycle Mafia (Day 5)

[DarthYoshi]

To clarify:

Both ICENinja and I use our listed s/n's as our primaries for this site. SZS is only a two-headed hydra.

~DY

PS: Meant to say earlier, congratulations, jmurph. I get my master's degree in a couple of weeks myself. Graduation is pretty sweet.

[DarthYoshi]

Thus question,

Why are you rising

to defend max so quickly, and

to so quickly discredit/paint me as scum?

Okay, if you insist.

Attention, everyone... *rings champagne flute, clears throat, etc*

THIS IS SILVER:

Alright.. sub is town.

UNVOTE:

damn it mastin, i hate you for the things you do to my mind.

VOTE: Sub

*snip*

Two honestlys? Town is honest by default.. it's scum that needs to feign honesty and point it out.

-Sub whom I'm assuming is icey since he refuses to sign apparently
1. I've given you reasons why i'm voting you, PLEASE READ MY POSTS THIS IS NOT HARD.

Reasons that you were ready to abandon by unvoting us as soon as JokeMastin said we were town must not be very good reasons.

What the fuck does this have to do with anything other than you blatantly trying to be a dick?

Way to strawman.

And... this:

3. It would STRONGLY be appreciated if you would NOT respond to something that CLEARLY is not addressed to you UNTIL at the very least the person it was addressed to responds to it FIRST.

after just hours earlier posting this:

Uite lurking is typical town Uite

Flailing, AtE-ing scum who posts fluff is flailing AtE-ing scum who posts fluff.

I report, you decide. (Which also probably means he's a socialist who hates 'merica.)

Unvote. Vote: Silver.

[DarthYoshi]

It wasn't just cause it was tricycles?

Ice doesn't hate me? Or was that Darth... ?

ICE and I were both frustrated with you. Hate is a strong word, I try not to hate. Speaking only for myself, I'd be fine playing a game with you again. But it was irritating for both of us, I think. Also, I said this in the QT, but I take issue with how you treated Uite post-game. Yeah, Uite's play was a great big ball of suck, but that doesn't excuse calling him a c***.

Yes, I am aware. However, saying "oh, it's ok I outed them cause it woulda happened either way" is a bad, bad reason.

THIS, THIS, A THOUSAND TIMES THIS. Mastin, we (the mason crew) would NOT have been outed on D1 in THIS game before your ill-advised daycop gambit. Screw what happens in other games, in THIS game, it was not going to happen D1, and I maintain that Amor was scummy enough that he would have been lynched in the game anyways. I am with ICE on this one--I need to take a nice, long, break from playing Mafia with you.

MrZepher, on a similar note, I will swear by this rule 99 times out of 100--VTs should NEVER, EVER claim PRs. Your JOAT claim was colossally short-sighted and should never have happened. What the heck were you thinking?

You'll see this in the dead QT, but I was basically howling over how long Pine was allowed to live as a claimed PR. I am STUNNED that this town lynched NS after KoC's breadcrumb (though I also think NS played really, really poorly for being a one-shot BP).

I realize this reads like a rant from me, and I am honestly probably less irritated than I sound here, but this game was really painful to watch. Apathetic townies and ridiculous fakeclaims from town absolutely sunk our side. I honestly don't even think the scum played particularly well, except for Nhammen, who did a good job of avoiding sustained suspicion. Town lost this game for itself, plain and simple.

Quadz, you did a solid job modding. I also got a kick out of all the tricycle pictures.

PEdit: KoC, I actually think Thor deserves the most credit for the Amor lynch, not Mastin.

[DarthYoshi]

Scum played the hand that was dealt, DY. No way I'd have pulled some of the ballsy shit I did with other people.

That said, we took who we wanted into LyLo. None of our NKs were random.

I'll rephrase--your night game, yes, hats off, I can definitely see why you took the players you did to LyLo. Well done there, absolutely.

Your day game was shit. Amor and DK were scummy pretty quick on D1, and your fakeclaim meant that any competent town would have policy lynched you before LyLo. Sorry.

[DarthYoshi]

Yoshi, I think that if you re-read your statement, in light of the fact that I won in LyLo, my point may be made clear.

I'm not following, but then again, I'm pretty dumb. What I'm saying is that you winning LyLo is a moot point, I get that you brought who you wanted to LyLo. My point is that you should never have made it that far because a competent town would have policy lynched you well in advance of LyLo for being a claimed PR who was never targeted for a NK.

@Quadz: One comment I actually do have about your modding, having finally skimmed the scum QT--during N1, your "Hopefully, DK gets here soon..." comment, in light of his NK target, to me it seemed the appropriate fill-in-the-blank to that ellipsis was "...because you really shouldn't be using a NK on Mastin." I may well just be reading too much into this, with the benefit of hindsight and whatnot, but I do firmly believe, based partly on experience, that a mod's involvement in a QT during the game should be as neutral as humanly possible.

[DarthYoshi]

Hey, guys?

Guess what?

I investigated Silver as innocent during the day!
Yes this is a serious claim of using a daycop ability.

Now get off that wagon, 'kay?

Thor might have pushed the Amor lynch, but silverbullet was the primo lynch (at L-1, flailing for his life) D1 until Mastin claimed to have an innocent result on him.

Yeah, at which point Mastin pushed a SZS lynch HARD. Only after we claimed, with hours before the deadline, did Mastin settle for Amor, which Thor had been arguing for seemingly for ages. It takes a few somersaults to give Mastin that credit, IMO.