NY129-Mafia on Werewolf Island! (Game Over)

[MrZepher]

UGH FUCK.

I seriously thought con was scum ):

Chrono you make me sad in the pants. I should have kept my suspicion on you for longer.

[Chronopie]

Seeing what Mastin wrote in the Mafia Qt reminds me just who much fun some of this was. Admitted I did ride his coattails, even though I was 70+% convinced he was the last mafioso. Then ofc, once I started, I realised I'd started defending him to the point where a 180 and revote would have been worse than trying to play the 'genuinely misguided' card.

Then considering Powerrox was pushing Mastin so strongly, it was a subtle form of distancing too IMO.

--

The Mafia Kill on the Seer was a nice thing for you guys to do for us too. I personally might not have gone after Nero until too late.

--

I did put out the hit on you. twice. for a reason.

[singersigner]

Mastin made this game suck.

Sorry. But it's true. I barely read any of it. I was pretty confident powerrox was scum, and really sad dram ended up voting Con instead of power when I had voiced my preference to vote power earlier in the day.

Mastion, I hate your wallposts and I hate you. Stop making the game suck for everyone to play. This is the second time you've done this, and the last. Go die.

[DemonHybrid]

Mortal Kombat Mafia, for those that liked my modding, Mortal Kombat, and especially those who like both. I'm still taking pre-ins, just as an aside.

The voting mechanic doesn't sound like a god one IMO. But that's just me, to each his own

I have my reasons. I expect it to be quite exciting during Mortal Kombat; more than many might think.

I'll stand over this.
BTW, didn't you say somewhere that you had a favorite fiction character mafia game?

Yeah, I'm still working out the kinks. Wont be for a while.

[Chronopie]

And One more point: dram was clear as town because a scum-dram would have killed Singer after her declaration, rite?

I could have wifomed the **** out of that, because I wouldn't have killed singer either. Bigger, less-susceptible-to-persuasion fish to fry.

[singersigner]

^oh believe me, I was being very careful of that.

But he wasn't ignoring the fact that I was town. If he was scum keeping me alive, it would've been in his best interest to just avoid the topic of me being scum until I asked him to confirm it. Instead he came right out with it...in a weird soft-claim sort of way.

[Chronopie]

I'm curious, would you have come around to my way of thinking, or would I have been one of your picks for the chopping block?

I did advocate other kills over yours for my suspicions that I probably could have. Would I have been sadly mistaken?

[singersigner]

Whatever. I just really hate players who make the game shit for everyone else.

[RayFrost]

Summary of why I quit the game:

I was co-modding a game that jindori tried to /in for and nikanor asked him about the details of his modkill and, through that, I found confirmation that jindori was telling some lies in what he'd said (already figured as much, but 100% confirmation etc) to us via his claim. As a result, I had to replace out despite

really, really

wanting to be in this game.

Aside from that, this game shows why you don't let people lurk to victory, which is pretty much what chrono / power did in the end days. They didn't even try to hide the fact they weren't posting. >.> I understand time issues, but their posts were mostly "don't have time to be useful, here's an easy to say thing"

[T-Bone]

Gosh that was painful to watch. Didn't I get lynched like 6 weeks ago? Holy shit mastin. I was able to get through a large theme start to finish from the time I was dead, and the beginning of this past day phase...

Anyway nice job for those who won. I wish I would have just had Chrono killed, but alas I wanted to lynch him, and then all my plans got ruined. Oh well.

[dramonic]

I got really worried that SS would out me after confirming herself to me since she knew I was lying about the whole PGO thing.
I'm also amused I never ended up claiming. I just said "not a PGO" during massclaim

[SnakePlissken]

Dying way back on Day 1 seems like an eternity ago now, it's been a fun read. Excellent game Mr.Mod. Well done to those Wolves dagnabit.

[ConSpiracy]

Too bad! Oh well, I was wrong almost all the time. I didn´t really enjoy the game, mostly because mastin was doing really stupid and there weren´t interesting things going on in the thread. Scum did well, though I wouldn´t like lurking to victory, but nevermind.

Well done DemonHybrid.

Going to read the QT this afternoon.

BTW dram, my reasoning why power confirmed himself as scum was true. If he were town both of us should be scum. He wouldn't matter choosing either of us.

[Nachomamma8]

People complained about mastin too much .

I played pretty shitty this game... A well-deserved win goes to the wolves.

[Pine]

Mastin's walls were epic. He had me almost convinced, and I knew from the mod that he was scum.

[ConSpiracy]

People complained about mastin too much .

I played pretty shitty this game... A well-deserved win goes to the wolves.

Lol I forgot who you were because of your old avvy

WE'RE MAKING A PACT RIGHT NOW THAT WE AVOID CONSPIRACY GAMES IF POSSIBLE AND WE POLICY LYNCH THE FUCK OUT OF HIM IF WE DO END UP IN A GAME WITH HIM. THERE ARE NO DEBATES HERE. SWEAR TO ME THAT CONSPIRACY GETS POLICY LYNCHED EVERY FUCKING TIME FROM NOW ON! HE JUST EARNED THE TITLE OF VILLAGE FUCKING IDIOT!

And I want to know where that unnecessary hate came from.

The reason why I said ending the day early thingie was because the first day that'd be done it was short, the second day it was long. It means that every one didn't have much to do the first day, but the second day there was most likely something that had to be done first, such as scum talking about something. It isn't much, but in my mind Dram became more scummy because of that.

And yes, I played bad. The last few games I played in I was bad. I really need some kind of support to help myself.

[Pine]

No offense, Con, but your Town play was horrible. I don't think you had a correct scumread until endgame, and you pushed Town mislynches really hard. Me, for example. You ignored good evidence and pursued bad ones.

Like I said, no offense intended. We've all been there and played in games where we were dead wrong about just about everything. But that's where the frustration came from. Particularly those of us who figured it all out and promptly died, then had our reads ignored even though we had flipped Town. I know that my top three when I died were stated to be Mastin, T-Bone, and Chrono, and I think Nacho was fifth behind Gorilla. And even though my stated reason for self-lynching was to get my reads taken seriously, no one reviewed them except C-Worl.

[ConSpiracy]

No offense, Con, but your Town play was horrible. I don't think you had a correct scumread until endgame, and you pushed Town mislynches really hard.

I had mastin, that counts for something.
And actually, I can see some players telling me I was horrible, but you weren't any good either.
As far as I know you have been lynched and didn't work out your reads enough to lynch. There are two things a townie has to do:
1. Getting good reads
2. Push those reads

I did #1 wrong, you did #2.

Like I said, no offense intended. We've all been there and played in games where we were dead wrong about just about everything. But that's where the frustration came from. Particularly those of us who figured it all out and promptly died, then had our reads ignored even though we had flipped Town.

Yeah well, this ignorance is something I started looking at in my last few games. People reject kills far too easily as being WIFOM. I regret not doing that in this game.

[T-Bone]

Geez guys, we all have bad games.

[Powerrox93]

Geez guys, we all have bad games.

QFT, I've played bad in ~half of the games I've played on MS

[Powerrox93]

And mod, I'm curious, what made you add a Vengeful Townie in the game

[DemonHybrid]

And mod, I'm curious, what made you add a Vengeful Townie in the game

I thought that the town was lacking on physical stopping power. Other than a Jailkeeper, there were informational roles. So I wanted some sort of scum trap, especially near endgame, as a kicker.

[Powerrox93]

/delayed reaction

... not someone newer like Powerrox93.

I have now played online mafia for about a year (Started offsite), and this is my 14 finished game (Offsite + MS), and you call me new

And mod, I'm curious, what made you add a Vengeful Townie in the game

I thought that the town was lacking on physical stopping power. Other than a Jailkeeper, there were informational roles. So I wanted some sort of scum trap, especially near endgame, as a kicker.

Ok, when you say it town has almost to many investigation roles

[DemonHybrid]

Also....ahhhh, symmetry =3

Cop/Seer
Roleblocker vs. Doctor vs. Jailkeeper
Two town Neighbors
Watcher vs Tracker
Voyeur, Vengeful and Friendly Neighbor to give it some flavor
And a Bulletproof SK

Can't get much more symmetrical than that. Did I mention that I'm slightly OCD?

[MrZepher]

Don't put a bruise on your back there DH