Large Normal 132: Desert Mafia (Over!)

[gorilla]

it's not that watching the claimed JK is suspicious, it's that not watching the claimed bodyguard n1 (mafia are going to shoot the bodyguard before the jailkeeper). overall claim is implausible.

Vote Count

• Scott Brosius - 1 (Pine)
  

With 5 players alive, it takes

3

to lynch.

[Scott Brosius]

I still don't understand why they would shoot the BG first. I outlined why JK is clearly more of a threat.

[gorilla]

...because how are they going to shoot the jailkeeper with the bodyguard around?

[Scott Brosius]

Doesn't BG die in place of target? Anyway this discussion is useless. As I said before. I figured Ran and DK were obviously set up as the next 2 nights kills. Instead of wasting my shot on what I saw as a 50/50 chance, I figured I would wait until the next night and watch the living player of the 2 assuming the NK would go there (barring any other PR claims which we did not have).

Anyway, I am comfortable enough with my case on Pine to vote. The fact that there has been no content from him since Khan died, until now when some suspicion is being cast on him also makes me more confident in my vote.

Vote: Pine

Going through all of KK's posts there isn't too much of note. He basically calls all of us scummy besides Hiraki in an early post, then gets a town read on gorilla. After D1, he pretty much doesn't address any of us. There is some back and forth with Pine about mastin but nothing else.

[Pine]

Yeah, the fact that Scott hasn't been vote-raped for the scumwin is pretty much confirmation that he's Mafia. Let's do this already.

[Hiraki]

Or you and Gorilla could be scum.

I don't feel that Gorilla is scum, and I feel that Scott is.

So, I'll take this gambit.

Unvote, Vote: Scott

[Scott Brosius]

Another point that it isn't LYLO...found this gem.

Spoiler: Cliff Notes for mastin2's tunnel

Scum-Khan is bussing one of his partners! Possibly both!

Notice he says both.

[gorilla]

So, You'd be okay if I hammered you right now, then? Because I'm very tempted to.

[Scott Brosius]

Well, at this point especially if there are 2 scum left, you are obvtown. Also we lose barring a Hiraki-Pine scumteam which makes no sense.

I'm still operating under the assumption especially based on Khan's comment that there is one assumedly very strong mafia member left based on the town power. I'm almost positive it is Pine which would explain why scum hasn't blitzed to hammer me.

[Scott Brosius]

I guess that doesn't answer your question. If there is a promise of lynching Pine (barring a town loss right now) tomorrow, I suppose I can slip in the noose.

[Skyquiem]

Alright, that makes it a lot easier, there are a few possible teams remaining being: Pine + Hiraki, leaning against this scum-team mainly because of their interactions and lack of blitz attempt on Scott earlier as well as both of their actions in pushing Khan. Scott + Gorilla, which is what H1 believes though he just did some ISO's and vanished again and I've considered for some time however it's not what I strongly believe. Scott + Pine, their interaction today makes me doubt it and Scott + Hiraki, honestly, this is what I believe the most likely pairing is though I still have a lot of reading to do.

Gorilla, I would appreciate if you didn't hammer or vote until I'm completely done with my read through and posting of my thoughts, give me 24 hours please.

[gorilla]

Time's up. I'll take my chances here, haven't seen anything that would change my mind.

VOTE: scott

If this is game over I sincerely apologize but I have put thought into this and I think most would make the same decision - but I'll feel like hell because I've already messed up a bunch.

[Scott Brosius]

I'll be expecting an apology.

[Untrod Tripod]

That's a lynch!

Scott Brosius was...

......

.......... a mafia goon!

Town wins.

[Scott Brosius]

You said you would apologize if the game was over .

We were pretty much screwed from the start.

[Untrod Tripod]

It didn't help that on day one the scum roleblocker basically walked out and said "hai guys I'm the scum power role and here are my partners"

[Slaxx]

owowhai

[xRECKONERx]

WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

It didn't help that on day one the scum roleblocker basically walked out and said "hai guys I'm the scum power role and here are my partners"

oh cmon now, I had to force him out like that

[Slaxx]

reck for mvp

setup was a bit townsided regardless

cake is omnomnom

[Scott Brosius]

Meh, with the night start I think it was fine. If we hadn't lost our only PR D1.....

[Untrod Tripod]

Here are the role PMs

________________________________________
Vanilla Townie

You are a vanilla townie. You have the following powers:

Active: Reading
Voting

Passive: Being town

_________________________________________
Jailkeeper

You are the town jailkeeper. You may target one person at night. If that person is targeted with an ability that night, the ability is blocked. If that person uses an ability that night, the ability is blocked.

__________________________________________
Bodyguard

You are the town bodyguard. You may target one person at night. If that person is targeted with an ability that night, the ability will be used on you instead.

___________________________________________
Tracker

You are the town tracker. You may target one person at night. If that person used an ability, you will receive a PM from me saying who the ability was used on.

____________________________________________
Delayed Action Vig

You are the town delayed action vigilante. You may target one person at night. That person will be killed the following night. You have two shots.

_____________________________________________
Mafia Goon

You are a mafia goon. Your partners are x and y. Your faction may choose one person to kill every night. You win when the mafia outnumbers the town (in the event of a daybreak where there are the same number of mafia and town players, the mafia will win).

You may talk here at night:
http://www.quicktopic.com/46/H/2XHQ75fs6Rt

___________________________________________
Mafia Roleblocker

You are the mafia roleblocker. Your partners are x and y. Your faction may choose one person to kill every night. In addition that, you may choose one person a night to nightkill. You cannot block and kill on the same night. You win when the mafia outnumbers the town (in the event of a daybreak where there are the same number of mafia and town players, the mafia will win).

You may talk here at night:
http://www.quicktopic.com/46/H/2XHQ75fs6Rt

[Untrod Tripod]

Dead QT

Think about it this way: Empking elected not to use his vig shot during night 0. Had he done so he PROBABLY would have hit town. Just saying. Scum was not that far away from winning even with the RP nonsense.

[gorilla]

oh my god what a relief

apologies for being so derp for most of this game

i definitely think reck pulling the d1 lynch onto scum helped steer the course of the game so that even with all the mislynches that were so terrible in hindsight we were able to win

[xRECKONERx]

Vote: KK

I am a broken record. Let's finally lynch him.

I'm glad you decided to bus, finally.

just sayin'

I agree this might've been slightly town biased, but losing the scum RB and basically confirming 3-5 people as town right off the bat was a bad, bad start.

[Slaxx]

yes

also I helped with that