New York 194: Guns N' Roses Mafia! (Day 8)

[Titus]

I will give them 48 hours to object. Normally I just release but scum would be under the impression of Aero's pt release rules.

Thanks to NM for the vote counts. Sorry for total lack of flavor. I know nothing about the band.

[Killthestory]

Atleast I get to laugh at KTS for thinking Slan was town

In LyLo, I pick Slandaar.

I don't know why you would laugh at me anyways though.

[Killthestory]

Nero, it doesn't matter my reasoning for lynching you lol. Reasoning is nothing when it comes to finding scum.

[Something_Smart]

I will give them 48 hours to object. Normally I just release but scum would be under the impression of Aero's pt release rules.

Thanks to NM for the vote counts. Sorry for total lack of flavor. I know nothing about the band.

I object to any objections to releasing the scum PT.

[Nero Cain]

Nero, it doesn't matter my reasoning for lynching you lol. Reasoning is nothing when it comes to finding scum.

In away you are correct as "caught for the wrong reasons" is a thing but your reasons were still technically wrong as it was S on S and not the S on T you thought it was.

[Killthestory]

In a LyLo situation with either Rach or Hebi, it's always Slandaar. Especially if he preemptively votes like that, confirming himself as scum.

Still, I was wrong on Slandaar a day earlier, but that's because I thought Performer had confirmed him.

[Something_Smart]

I'm still not sure why people thought Slandaar was confirmed not-SK after he was tracked on a night with only one kill and a scum roleblocker, who seemed determined to lynch Slandaar no less, already flipped.

[Killthestory]

I didn't understand it at the time, btu I just went with Performer

[Creature]

I regret replacing out.

[RachMarie]

yeah I guess I was wrong on that I figured since Perf tracked him, and cleared him that it was a full clear, I figured he would have gotten a "no result" instead of slan going nowhere.

It did bother me he was still alive in LYLO though he was not nearly as active as I am used to. My gut was saying slan but I could not ignore the tracker report. Obviously I was right on the investigation immune, I just did not expect it to completely ignore the result instead of coming back as no result.

@ Nero at that point I was not really paying attention to if it was you or your pred at the time, the fact you were pushing the sk had to be BP told me maf had shot at me and failed. I figure that Slan did too at some point. He did the suspicion well. Of course that told me you were scum lol.

Heb I am always suspicious of someone who town reads me too much save a very few people like Nacho cause I know if Nacho is scum he will focus on busing his scum buds, plus he is good at town reading me not always as good at scum reading me, and I always feel guilty when he is town and I am scum and we win the game because of it. It comes from my first game onsite when I cost us the game for trusting the person who was so town reading me.

[RachMarie]

uggh I wish I had replaced into tracker instead of bp I would have made that slot WORK That slot being a series of inactives really cost town a LOT

[Equinox]

I have a confession to make.

Reverie is my alternate account. I had intended to read the game, except I managed to forget about this game entirely. I realized my mistake on Day 5, but it was too late by then. While the slot had other inactives, I was definitely responsible for this outcome. The tracker had only ever sent one Night action on Night 1, if I remember correctly, and after that it was either an unfilled replacement or me on Night 4 being stupid.

Firebringer, you're not blacklisting Reverie; you're blacklisting me. You are absolutely right to do so.

I'm also no longer playing Mafia.

Good game, Slandaar. I am sorry, town.

[Titus]

I'm sorry Equinox. If I had been watching closer, I would have prodded you. I basically agreed to backup mod do Aero could host and forgot about this. By the time I stepped in, that had happened. I am sorry. I was a crappy back up mod in that regard.

[Equinox]

I'm sorry Equinox. If I had been watching closer, I would have prodded you. I basically agreed to backup mod do Aero could host and forgot about this. By the time I stepped in, that had happened. I am sorry. I was a crappy back up mod in that regard.

It wouldn't have done much good. I haven't received email notifications on any of my accounts for a while now. This is still my fault in the end. Thank you for taking over the game when you did.

[Killthestory]

bah Equinox you aren't playing mafia anymore? : (

[Not_Mafia]

Congrats Slandaar, third party wins are rare, so consider nomming Slandaarfor a scummie, I would but tbh I didn't really read the game.

I don't think Titus or I anticipated fully taking over the game, so sorry for some lacklustre modding

[RachMarie]

Now wait a minute Way and I were a weird 3rd party alternating kill SK and we won

Equinox I am so sorry all that happened. I think I replaced in a game on your reverie account.

[hebichan]

yeah I guess I was wrong on that I figured since Perf tracked him, and cleared him that it was a full clear, I figured he would have gotten a "no result" instead of slan going nowhere.

It did bother me he was still alive in LYLO though he was not nearly as active as I am used to. My gut was saying slan but I could not ignore the tracker report. Obviously I was right on the investigation immune, I just did not expect it to completely ignore the result instead of coming back as no result.

@ Nero at that point I was not really paying attention to if it was you or your pred at the time, the fact you were pushing the sk had to be BP told me maf had shot at me and failed. I figure that Slan did too at some point. He did the suspicion well. Of course that told me you were scum lol.

Heb I am always suspicious of someone who town reads me too much save a very few people like Nacho cause I know if Nacho is scum he will focus on busing his scum buds, plus he is good at town reading me not always as good at scum reading me, and I always feel guilty when he is town and I am scum and we win the game because of it. It comes from my first game onsite when I cost us the game for trusting the person who was so town reading me.

Well my reads were just really good all game for some reason. I just needed to push harder.

[Firebringer]

hebichan I don't remember your reads being really good and you were always in my idea of being scum, but also "lynchbait"

My reads sucked this game, and I was highly demotivated each time I got into it, my only good reads were town reads, and Something_Smart.

It was a meh game completely to be honest.

I am not really blacklisting any plyaers.


Also I think a fitting title for me that Drixx called me "Serial Fluff" was pretty funny.

[RachMarie]

LOL I thought that was funny, too

[RachMarie]

heb hang in there girl, you will get there. Overall you have good instincts, just have more confidence in your reads, even if they are wrong, you will still get further in the long run and you have more chance of convincing others you are right when you are.

[Firebringer]

FB is a serial fluff poster. I find almost nothing in his posts I can get a firm read from.

Serial Fluff poster sounds like a hot title.

Lol for the days

[Equinox]

bah Equinox you aren't playing mafia anymore? : (

I've been retired, more or less, since 2014. Sometimes, a game would catch my eye, and I'd delude myself into thinking that Mafia would be fun to play again. Mafia has its moments, and it's those moments that everyone celebrates and for which people keep returning. Otherwise, it's not a fun pastime, at least for me.

Equinox :( I am so sorry all that happened. I think I replaced in a game on your reverie account.

Yes, you did.

[Firebringer]

Lets be honest, if Equinox played she would break the game.
Nobody wants that.

[Firebringer]

I feel like that might be interpreted as mean.
But it was meant as a "you are a good player even though I don't like your methods". Meh.

I said waht i meant.