NY 215: HMS Erebus - Game Over!

[Saudade]

Good Bye, my dear Hugo

[Purrcocet]

This is my last game on this site(not that anyone cares), bye! lol

Spoiler: ;-;

[Krazy]

Aww but Hugo your play this game was great!

Sad to see you go

Scum was aware there was a traitor as per normal guidelines.

[Krazy]

Mafia thread released -- viewtopic.php?f=90&t=77218

All PTs have now been released, thank you again to everyone for playing, mastina for backup moderating, radiantcowbells for setup design, and implosion for answering questions.

[Io]

I like how Purr was the mafioso desperately trying to defend me from the Mafia kills.

[Garmr]

ive never seen more open open wolfing in my life

garmr is a nk because hes more likely to lyncxh scum than anyone else
lapsa is too
but lapsa is so mislynchable

io townreads like 2 of us

I like this post.

[Performer]

just read the mafia pt - CT mvp for scum team
you did well and clearly have forum mafia experience

[Purrcocet]

despurrately

[Saudade]

get out
both of you

[Io]

You guys took this town from us therefore i have the right to haunt it.
Oooooooh!

[tictac]

kinda curious if 1355 was comprehensible to garm or anyone else.
i felt like i was leaving out loads of context in effort to compress and relying on reader having a good memory.
tying to be a less wall-heavy player lately.

[Krazy]

You must believe in the wall!

[Performer]

kinda curious if 1355 was comprehensible to garm or anyone else.
i felt like i was leaving out loads of context in effort to compress and relying on reader having a good memory.
tying to be a less wall-heavy player lately.

You play weirdly...for instance, you mentioned my wiki. That is very old so it's an unreliable source at best.
I did genuinely like that you made an effort to compress things though.
Many times I found myself wondering if English was your first language, because your posts were hard to comprehend sometimes...and anyone who comes across as difficult to understand, is sometimes scummy to me.

[Garmr]

kinda curious if 1355 was comprehensible to garm or anyone else.
i felt like i was leaving out loads of context in effort to compress and relying on reader having a good memory.
tying to be a less wall-heavy player lately.

I can get where you were coming from but it was totally wrong.

VOTE: Hugo
-didn't get voted at all day 1 which is weird 4 a nullslot.
-all the SK spec

about perf: 1213 is kinda hilariousness I don't really expect from scum. gonna give him a bit of space 4 now.

@garm here's the thing I promised on 1101:
1- all the straw about me supposedly thinking ya appeased dave and demanding consistency w that pow is weird, but eh.

could

be a misunderstand.
2- why didn't I ask ya first? Because I was confused about what ya agreed w dave on, and didn't know I was confused. That's how confusion works.
3- in fact I see now that ya explicitely

didn't

agree w 791 which I thought ya did. --> This thing didn't have the edge I thought it did.
4- kiinda granting 'readslists are made by pressure by default', nut makes me itch.
5- still weird that town!you goes digging for info he considers non-AI..
6- "flowed artificial or genuinely evolved" <-- precise thing I tried to figure out about ya. not all this extra stuff ya crammed in.
7- do like the observation about my thought being narrow. It's true and very intentional from me. caring about everything is caring about nothing.
8- I took the time to make this short. Ya welcome.

i.e. ya lean scum, but not a high read.
Thoughts on 1202?

1-Not really a point as you acknowledged it could be a misunderstanding. If you sat down and thought about it i didn't even notice "daves appeasement angle" point in fact I didn't even know about it's existence. So me responding that way to was obviously me confused.

2-I could tell you had a ulterior motive from tone, your diary shows you have a ulterior to see how I would react as well. you playing it off as confusion wasn't the best thing to do. As I thought it was scum trying to cover up instead of town flopping. You using the confused thing when you are slamming on me while I am confused is a bad look. You shouldn't of done.

3-You threw self doubt on your case if you show doubt then people won't take you as serious.

4-But it's true and it's not scummy.

5- That path of thought is wrong. it goes see daves post->look into what he might be posting about->make a judgement. Not looking for none alignment indicative stuff in general.

6-Not really helping your case at the time.Gives the image of not having confidence.

7-bad logic as if you are to narrow it back fires.

8-It did nothing to push the case. It shows no conclusion about my motivations or why they are even scummy. It won't hit hard.

[Performer]

kinda curious if 1355 was comprehensible to garm or anyone else.
i felt like i was leaving out loads of context in effort to compress and relying on reader having a good memory.
tying to be a less wall-heavy player lately.

also, that 1355 was understandable but different players sr different things. garm would sr one thing, me another thing, someone else yet another thing. Something to keep in mind.

Generally if you're clear in communicating, that's going to help you when you're town.

[tictac]

Many times I found myself wondering if English was your first language

It's not. I'm finnish.

@garm Thanks for the feedback
Looks like about the same level of clarity a wall would have had, which is nice.
didn't really push 4 the reaction. I just thought ya were scum until the read changed.
(doesn't mean I don't pay attention to how people react even if it's not my main goal)

I enjoyed writing this, but I'm kinda doubting myself already.

I get too invested when I spot cool things.

that's the gist of the thing.

by the time of 1355 I had decided you weren't a high-scumread, and was more explaining my thought-process than pushing.
it's fine if that post doesn't work optimally as a push. If I had faked certainty I didn't posess then I really would have had an agenda.

don't really subscribe to 'pushing is all' philosophy, i'm more about analysis if it's not nearing deadline, like with my day 1 interaction with gamma and the failed attempt to double-check that I'm not in a perf-tunnel at the beginning of day2.
the main reason i like to have an overflow-thread is so I end up pushing for fewer things future-me will regret pushing. If I didn't have one that wall would have ended up in the game, and that would have been bad.
Having doubt is not a bad thing and my main failing in this game was having too little of it.

[Gamma Emerald]

I think the doubt you did show, at least when pushing me, was towny

[implosion]

If you want to nominate this game or any people in it (moderator or players) for a scummy, please do!