Greatest Idea VIII - Game Over

[NotMySpamAccount]

This is gonna be fun. I agree that we shouldn't lynch either calimd Judas though, nks should take care of that.

[NotMySpamAccount]

This is gonna be fun. I agree that we shouldn't lynch either calimd Judas though, nks should take care of that.

Question. What happens if it wont be/cant be? With either Elsa telling the truth & being roleblocked/Irrelephant being protected or Elsa lying and Elsa being protected?

idk I have like three games under my belt bu t I agree with this:

You're talking as if within 21 players we wont have a way to sort them regardless.

[NotMySpamAccount]

Not funny at all tho but I laughed my ass off writting it

I did too reading it.

[NotMySpamAccount]

Now that you talked about someone not posting yet, Sakura, you reminded me that there are a lot of players who haven't contributed a lot on this dayphase even if we have discussed like one or two relevant things. ofrhz gets a pass 'cause if Elsa flips scum, ofrhz is never her partner because of calling him out on the Judas thing. But where are Blooper, DT and Gamma? I could be forgetting other people too.

The fact that even when talking about the people who aren't posting I can slip by unnoticed is not good. Scum could be lurking. Occam's Razor says Elsa is scum and needs dayvigging, not rope. More to follow maybe.

[NotMySpamAccount]

Having finished catching up, I'm kinda worried about staying that way, large games are tough. As it is, VOTE: ElsaJay

[NotMySpamAccount]

Why TTTT day vig shot no work? Trekkie think TTTT liar.

Does he always post like this?

[NotMySpamAccount]

off topic: trekkie - my fave star trek version is star trek voyager...tuvok, 7 of 9, the doctor...such a great show

I like the original series and loved the 09 Star Trek film. The Star Trek Discovery TV show is interesting. I liked how they harkened back to The Menagerie from the original tv show in the last episode.

No

Hi NMSA who do you want lynched today

Gun to my head TL, not sure yet.

[NotMySpamAccount]

NMSA might be lone scum

lol so could TTTT

[NotMySpamAccount]

NMSA might be lone scum

lol so could TTTT

Not really? The play with drawing attention to himself by fakeclaiming day vig would be bad as a solo scum.

tru ignore me pls I'm tired

[NotMySpamAccount]

also VOTE: TL for being scummy

[NotMySpamAccount]

@mod v/la til Monday

[NotMySpamAccount]

I'm fine massclaiming. Do you want mine?

[NotMySpamAccount]

Vanilla Townie.

[NotMySpamAccount]

want a fullclaim?

[NotMySpamAccount]

why would you discard parrot role over vt

because I felt like trolling by being an actual vanilla townie

[NotMySpamAccount]

sounds fake

then lynch me

[NotMySpamAccount]

I'm a troll, but I'm a lazy troll. Not a madly anti-town troll.

[NotMySpamAccount]

I'm a troll, but I'm a lazy troll. Not a madly anti-town troll.

full claim cards plz

watcher, VT, parrot role. watcher for alignment, vt for role, discard parrot role. before you ask why I didn't take watcher, it was because I'm both lazy and a troll.

[NotMySpamAccount]

I want trekkie to claim.

[NotMySpamAccount]

Do it Trekkie, please.

Also NMSA claim compared to what he did in the previous GM game could make him town actually, or someone advised him to say what he claimed.

this guy gets it

[NotMySpamAccount]

I'd kill to be able to see your faces irl when I flip town, they'll be priceless.

[NotMySpamAccount]

I stand corrected
NMSA you should die for...
a) being scum
b) being town who chose VT over a PR

Wisdom's point about scum watcher is pretty good, and your point of NMSA being town who chose VT over PR is right, but I think the best course of action is looking more players in depth for now. I think the big mistake we have commited since D1 is focusing in only one or two players instead of looking at the rest of the playerlist, and maybe that's because we got cocky for lynching Elsa D1.

I'm like, 80% not believing NMSA's claim with Wisdom's point, but that's not enough. I have counterpoints: NMSA's play on the previous GM was different and he chose a 3p that game; he was the first wagon and the first shot of the game by our vig, so discarding parrot to then claim VT is like calling attention all over again and not learning from his discards' mistakes from the previous game.

yeah, I payed attention to discards this time, that's why I didn't discard watcher, it would look too scummy.

[NotMySpamAccount]

TTTT - 1-shot dayvig (used up)
Trekkie - Kevin Costner
NMSA - VT (lol)
Irrelephant - VT
Vedith - Supersaint
pinturicchio - Doc Mason
------------------------------
ofrhz
davesaz
DoubtingThomas
Gamma Emerald
Shadowlesscloud
Wisdom

we start voting below the line
until there is nobody below the line
VOTE: davesaz

I’m on board with this
VOTE: davesaz

screw it, works for me, I'm bored, VOTE: davesaz

[NotMySpamAccount]

THey're fucking morons.
Claiming is anti-town.
Fuck off.

I'm sorry, Dave, I'm afraid I can't do that.

Pedit: DANGIT MY CLEVER COMMENTS ALWAYS COME TOO LATE

[NotMySpamAccount]

yay we got another claim stop complaining about our strategy dave and join us VOTE: ofrhz sry if I seem like a hyper 12 year old, I just won a game that was the most exhausting I'll ever play.

[NotMySpamAccount]

idk if you guys realized or not, but dave said his pgo claim was a lie, so he effectively hasnt claimed

oh ok VOTE: davesaz

[NotMySpamAccount]

VOTE: Pinturicchio

(((: well played I like the it he's claimed ww now and VOTE: pintu for the REAL hammer cause if I counted right that was a beautifully executed fake

[NotMySpamAccount]

also youre not hammered yet, silly.

yay I'm not the only one who realized

[NotMySpamAccount]

my vote may be my only weapon but it's still a good one

[NotMySpamAccount]

Claims
Player	Role Card	Alignment Card	Discard
Irrelephant11	Judas	Vanilla Townie	Lover
Shadowlesscloud	Tracker	Hero	Werewolf FBI Agent
TTTT	One-Shot Dayvig	Vanilla Townie	Private Investigator
Vedith	Supersaint	Vanilla Townie	Alpha Werewolf
pinturicchio	Mason Doctor	Compulsive Childkiller	Alien Silencer
Trekkie99	Black Goo	Cult One-shot Goomaker	Mafia Godfather
DoubtingThomas	Werewolf Cop	Bodyguard	Werewolf Gravedigger
davesaz	One-shot Paranoid Gun Owner	Doctor	Alien Mass Redirector
NotMySpamAccount	Vanilla Townie	Watcher	Parrot Role
ofrhz	Serial Killer (2 shot bulletproof)	Hirsute Townie	Vanilla Townie
Gamma Emerald	Psychiatrist	Tourist	Mason Lover
Wisdom	Bulletproof Townie	Compulsive Childkiller	Conspiracy Theorist

reposting to compare with nks... intereting. VOTE: trekkie

[NotMySpamAccount]

NotMySpamAccount probably killed Wisdom.
So Insomnia, TTTT, Irrel And Dave as town.

Lynching Trekkie is always the right play here.
8 players 5 town(?)

Lynch 7 players 5 town (?)

2 night kills
5 players possible 3 town left at worst.

Being a VT, I'm interested to know what alignment you think I am. Obvisously not mafia, and the odds of SK are fairly low given that ofrhz has taken two of the SK cards out of circulation, so that leaves WW and Alien iirc. I hammered pintu, who was WW, when I easily could have claimed I was fooled by the fakehammer and kept a teammate alive. That leaves Alien. Is that your thought process? If not, why am I something else besides VT?

[NotMySpamAccount]

Votecount 4.01

Trekkie99 (1) -

NotMySpamAccount

Not Voting (7) -

TTTT, ofrhz, davesaz, insomnia, Trekkie99, Vedith, Irrelephant11

With 8 players alive it takes 5 votes to lynch.

The deadline for Day 4 is in (expired on 2019-04-13 20:00:00).

wait why did we stop voting trekkie? is there a good reason?

[NotMySpamAccount]

I've come to the conclusion that my reads are shit so that makes me confirmed scum

and

useless.

I guess ther isn't

[NotMySpamAccount]

So how is everyone?

Annoyed with how slow the game has been, but otherwise fine. You?

Seriously, the lurking is Bad News (tm) and needs to stop.

[NotMySpamAccount]

The day Vig can't visit as town.
You can.

Point being?

He “dayvigged” Elsa and she didn’t die.

What does this visiting thing have to do with anything?

You’re saying nobody can confirm him?

His shot could’ve been his alibi, except that shit was fake

So how does anyone trust his claim right now lmao

???

Explain what you meant with “TTT can’t visit, you can”

TTTT faked a dayvig shot D1, then used "Kill:" D2 so that the shot actually worked. He confirmed himself as dayvig, so he can't visit at night.

[NotMySpamAccount]

VOTE: Trekkie
I was mafia with TTTT, Dave and NMSA.

bold of you.

[NotMySpamAccount]

thought my dave push was a bit heavy handed
but other than that scum played great

I

hope

this isn't scum

[NotMySpamAccount]

Someone tell me it’s a jokeeeee

I'm not scum, so I hope their part is

[NotMySpamAccount]

Someone tell me it’s a jokeeeee

I'm not scum, so I hope their part is

is a joke

[NotMySpamAccount]

I kind of think I'm being trolled

same

[NotMySpamAccount]

ok I'm not risking this any longer
any town PR shouldn't be WIFOM'ed going into tonight
sorry for anyone having heart attacks
I blame Vedith for starting it

unless this is wifom. I'm inclined to believe it was all a joke bc I was included but...

[NotMySpamAccount]

ok I'm not risking this any longer
any town PR shouldn't be WIFOM'ed going into tonight
sorry for anyone having heart attacks
I blame Vedith for starting it

This is my least favorite April Fools joke

oh yeah I forgot it was April Fools hmm

[NotMySpamAccount]

Umm whether you’re SK or psych you should probably target NMSA

agree

I want pics of all of your faces when I flip VT so I can gloat and laugh

[NotMySpamAccount]

inb4 "it was all happening so fast"

it was all happening so fast

it was all happening SO fast

It WaS aLl HaPpEnNnInG sO fAsT

[NotMySpamAccount]

I honestly think people fucked up and now they back peddle just to make sure

Lol NMSA doing half his posting of the entire game post hammer sure does make me believe it was all a joke

I'd apologize for lurking but everyone else did too

[NotMySpamAccount]

I have no clue what happened but this is the worst april fools ever if it was a joke

[NotMySpamAccount]

Vedith and TTTT are most likely both town

[NotMySpamAccount]

It gave some excitement to end of day.

I suppose so

[NotMySpamAccount]

I’m the SK, just as a reminder

I believe someone can change that? I've kinda lost track of who and if they're still alive

[NotMySpamAccount]

If Vedith is scum, TTTT is prob!town

[NotMySpamAccount]

Vedith and TTTT are most likely both town

Ew

Yeah NMSA why did you say this?
UNVOTE:

If Vedith is scum, TTTT is prob!town

And why did you say this

first waas a gut read based on the probable jokee. second was the assumption that if scum!vedith is fine saying I'm scum when he knows I'm town, he's likely (I guess) to do the same to TTTT. not certain though

[NotMySpamAccount]

I'd love to see dave dead tonight. If he's not, I want to lynch him tomorrow.

pedit: badum tsh

[NotMySpamAccount]

I'm not sure how else I can say this.
The following players in this game are not SK

TTTT
ofrhz
davesaz
NotMySpamAccount
Irrelephant11

There is guaranteed an SK in the following (100% sure that SK is here)
Insomnia

Vedith

Trekie
Micc

I think this is enough evidence for vedith to be sk

[NotMySpamAccount]

that was unexpected. but hey, we got the win. I even survived as a VT. gg all, solid modding micc. a truly impressive game, can't wait for the next round (hopefully there is another).

[NotMySpamAccount]

Werewolves also would’ve won if Pintu claimed differently
But I have to hand it to that impressive psychiatrist play, well done.

yeah insomnia did great