taylor and I kinda concur here.In post 240, The Pelican Brief wrote:I think Tsunami is scum. Too much fluff, not enough solving. Not 100% because it is Noraa.
ellitell is being active elsewhere on this site and not posting here.In post 244, The Pelican Brief wrote:I don't think asking about ratios is townslippy. It's busiwork. We won't know the ratio unless we know the roles. Not sure what ellitetelling is.
over in elsewhere its evening...
can anyone put forward a decent case for town!gamma PLEASEIn post 1065, Ydrasse wrote:gamma + hbb + et feel a good start for town and i want to make this pool larger
they confirmed my commuter slip?In post 1346, Shoshin wrote:Gypyx hasn't shown any sign of town. Their reads aren't great. They're a plausible team with all likely scum.
can you explain hub for meIn post 1671, TheGoldenParadox wrote:so hub is town
gypyx is town
ydrasse is town
...and that's it. i'm not sure why it's been so difficult to establish a solid townblock this game but i'll read back over and give a readslist in a bit.
which backs up the point that scum are informed of the commutersIn post 1688, Gamma Emerald wrote:Noraa also struggles with basic setup info, no offense, that’s just how she is.
yes but its not very townie to blatantly sheep/whiteknight isn't itIn post 1705, samantha97 wrote:aren't you saying they gained credibility in your eyes instead of lost it then?
its a CW because it countered the vax wagon which became prevalent.In post 1811, Ydrasse wrote:so i know i've just twirled your hair and all, very cutely, but didn't the samantha wagon come first? how is it a counter-wagon?
why did you scumread sam in the first place?In post 1815, Ydrasse wrote:also @shoshin i wanna clarify why i said that about my samantha vote: it felt like a useless vote at the time because the wagon was gone but i still thought that it was a good vote and it was frustrating that all the pressure on samantha sort of just.. vanished? which like, it went to a better place but i still hold strong to it being a good vote
"weird vibes"In post 395, Ydrasse wrote:but i don't find it as gross as the way that samantha interacted with bef in 251, 257, and 259. the last post especially has these like... weird vibes
yeah, but votes on Samantha Happened when vax was a thing, so arguably samantha is countering vax wagon (and vax pushed sam to stop him from dying as well)In post 1821, Ydrasse wrote:counterwagons spring up to combat something though right? samantha’s was well established before the vax one, so the intent of it wasn’t to stop the vax one..
also i’m on mobile but i’ve laid out the reasons prior in my iso, just a lot of not great posts d1 and d2 doesn’t give much either. i think the one thing that would maybe make me reconsider is a red bef flip
also, also, she has a very narrow minded stance fmpov regarding scum pools which like... yeah i guess in this situation it ~works~ but the sort of focuses on low posting slots more than anything is a safe range for scum to rest in
uh i want specific posts when you are able to quote things.In post 1825, Ydrasse wrote:maybe i just don’t get the defenses of samantha but like i feel like i’m staring straight into a void of evil whenever i see her posts
this is a sorta countertheory to everything I think has happenedIn post 1829, Ydrasse wrote:i think that in that position you’re going to push for survival regardless if it is scum right? like, your partner might come out of it looking better if nothing else, and from memory im like almost positive the samantha votes were first but i can check again
samantha’s pushes these games fall on low-quantity posts and then like. bef. she spelled it out why she does it recently + yeah i can get behind that theory because i’ve literally been saying that i think that scum might not have had good control of the game state before
we are a plain old town comm not an enchantress/whateverIn post 1857, samantha97 wrote:ok hi good morning
I was gonna wait until 24 hours were left or someone was e-1 to post this, but now that the game has livened up and it's close to 24 hours anyway, I'm gonna roleclaim
*drumroll*
enchantress
yes, that is the 3rd commuter claim
what's even more interesting than there supposedly being 3 commuters in this game is that I targeted pelican last night and they died anyway
I've been conflicted since the gypyx/shelly interaction today as to which is most likely mafia (I mean I guess it's possible there are 3 town commuters but?)
for gypyx: he claimed first and was the first to claim commuter
for shelly: I found taylor's posts outside of the roleclaims to be extremely town
@gypyx and shelly, who did you both target last night?
yeah.In post 2099, Bell wrote:Fucking seriously Shelly?
There are both VTs and commuters