On reading through then, the most striking thing is mnowax's daykilling role. I think he's unlikely to be mafia or a day SK because of the seemingly unlimited number of kills he can make per day. The fact that he killed mafia and a few of his other comments reinforce that impression in my mind. I'm thinking we should use his ability as our lynch for the time being, because it gives us multiple lynches per day. Also second Dasquian's comments about mnowax not just shooting whenever he feels like it. I'm not utterely ruling out that mnowax could be scum, since this is an unpredictable game, but town or scum, we can use his power to our advantage.
To move onto looking scum, the two people who've pinged my scumdar so far are Nightson and populartajo.
Nightson has 4 posts so far, all of them about trying to kill mnowax. Whilst I can understand initial shock, I'm rarely very keen on arguments such as, "he's behaving in an anti-town manner so we should kill him" without showing much indication that he thinks mnowax is scum.
Populartajo seems to be making alot of assumptions about scum roles. This:
Doesn't entirely reassure me. The part where you said, "scum have nice roles" looked more like a statement than a hypothesis, and as lord hur pointed out, there's no evidence for it, since the only dead scum was a goon. And also, the assumption that people early on the list are more likely to be scum doesn't make sense (why assume that the order he announced us in correlates to the order he sent PMs?)populartajo wrote:Im trying to outguess the mod. Those were just hypothesis that could be tur or be developed as long the game progresses.
I think scum can communicate during day since we know we have new players (new scum included) and that they should have a way to catch up with each other.
And yes Alabaska was a Goon (so did he lie about his powers, fakeclaim given by the mod?) but I think that the Mod has preferences for scum roles (you usually have to check them first to send them to the right persons). So I assume he sent them first.
And yes Im crazy.
I won't bother with voting since I think using mnowax's kill as our lynch is better than a traditional lynch right now, but those are my suspicions.