Pirates Mafia - GAME OVER

[mole]

I'll second that. I don't like starting the game knowing nothing at all.

Vote: Quailman

. I think those watches he's selling are fake.

[mole]

Unvote: Quailman

Clearly he cannot have pirated his watches. Rollexes come from Switzerland, which is extremely difficult to loot with ships. Not that I've tried or anything.

[mole]

That's interesting. I always thought the 'Flying Dutchman' was the name of the ship.

I also think Phoebus has a point, and in fact it's one I agree with. Are we really achieving anything by voting for the lurkers? Sure, they're not participating in the discussion, but a whole string of "let's vote for the lurker!" posts isn't going to generate any leads either.

[mole]

You know, I can't help but feeling that PeaceBringer is some sort of prototype mafia AI jeep is getting us to test - sorry jeep, but I think mith's "Vote: IS" bot beats you hands-down.

Seriously, though, when your reasons for voting range from "vote the lurkers" to "vote the people who didn't unvote the former lurkers quickly enough" I'm left wondering if you'll ever get around to something that has a better than random chance of catching a mafia.

Vote: PeaceBringer

[mole]

Unvote: PeaceBringer

. Umm, nice vote count you have there...?

[mole]

Vote: sycko

Have to agree with IS here--improbable and almost useless town role plus vaguely scummy behaviour (defending PB for playing the same way he always does but attacking IS for doing the same?) makes you a good candidate.

[mole]

I have to agree with the other nine people up there--all this just seems way too unlikely, especially compounded like that.

Vote: Fishbulb

[mole]

I doubt CoolBot is scum, he was pushing for the Fishbulb lynch.

[mole]

Well, I'm not convinced there is one--I mean, sure there have been multiple kills on both nights, but the opening post said the scum around here were pirates, and we haven't seen any way of distinguishing between different kinds of pirates. No "they're Blackbeard's pirates, and they're Cap'n Blicero's pirates over there", Fishbulb was just "Pirate".

[mole]

While we're waiting for answers to the vigilante questions,

Vote: Flying Dutchman

.

[mole]

You're most welcome.

[mole]

Now FD has given his results I'm slightly more confident:

Unvote: FD, Vote: CoolBot

[mole]

Interesting turn of events here. I'm willing to test PB's theory some:

Vote: olio

[mole]

On second thoughts, there is something odd about Nanook's kills. Would a vigilante strangle people?

[mole]

Mastermind: The "six people" that PB think might be scum are just everyone who hasn't claimed a role yet. And I remember he did single out olio yesterday before FD came forward.

[mole]

Unvote: olio

It's not me either. I think there's someone who can back me up with my claim of innocence...

[mole]

So we have:

Mastermind of Sin
mole
Fuldu
NanooktheWolf - vigilante
PeaceBringer
Flying Dutchman - cop
Internet Stranger - roleblocker
inHimshallibe
PookytheMagicBear
olio - mason

I think that between the third Vegetable mason and Lord Dementia Blader's butler we have enough confirmed innocents to play the Claim Game!

Original Roll String: 1d4

1 4-Sided Dice: (1) = 1

[mole]

4 is... Pooky.

vote: Pooky

[mole]

Well, first of all there are only 10 people left. We have four claimed roles, plus me, plus olio's mason buddy (I'm 75% sure I know who it is) leaves only four suspects and one of those has a role (the butler) that's confirmed to be in the game, so we're looking pretty good.

[mole]

Sure.

I am the

Pacifist

, and I'm yet another roleblocker. The player I target is blocked, and anyone who targets that player as well is also blocked.

Unlikely to have three roleblockers in one game, yes, but I think that FD, based on his comments on what he found last night, should be able to confirm me.

Next up... Fuldu! I don't think it's you, but if it is I'd rather not give you the advantage of going last.

[mole]

You're also the only player who hasn't voted for olio at some point. :) That's what gave it away for me...

[mole]

Unvote: Pooky

if he is indeed the butler.

[mole]

FD was scum?

[mole]

I'm most suspicious of inHim, for claiming doctor and then revealing his previous choices, giving the mafia a big "hey!! FD won't be protected tonight!" tip.

I blocked PeaceBringer last night, so he didn't make either of the kills...

[mole]

What's the point of me protecting the cop if it means he's blocked as well?

[mole]

Does your role have a name?

[mole]

mole's blocks:

Night 1: IS
Night 2: Fuldu
Night 3: PeaceBringer
Night 4: PeaceBringer

So I'm inclined to believe him for now. If he's scum then he hasn't been making the kills.

[mole]

Well, the trouble with PB being mafia is that he was blocked last night, so he didn't make a kill last night, so now we're looking two mafia, a scratcher-to-death, and our strangler Nanook. Where are all these killers in a game with only seven people left?

olio: mason (confirmed by mason MoS)
Pooky: butler (confirmed by Lord Dementia's role description)
IS: gypsy (confirmed by mod, he does have an ability based on what he posts)
Nanook: strangler (confirmed by his strangling people)
mole: pacifist (investigated by both cops)
PB: townie
inHim: innkeeper [doc]

Is there room there for four scum?

[mole]

whatever

Vote: PeaceBringer