Pirates Mafia - GAME OVER

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

random vote IS

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Now that you mention it Cad,

PB does seem to be a little jumpy and trigger happy today .

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

unvote IS

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

His point is that you are more suscipicious then the other 2 people on PB's list becuse you have posted(i.e. you had the oppurtunity to unvote yet you chose not to)

I think that this logic as well as PB's original logic for voting you is somewhat bad.

There are some people who are intent on getting a lynch done as fast as possible and some bandwagons started up, I find PB's seemingly constant shifty position on who to vote a little bit scummy, though I can see why he might go along with this path.

My 2 cents are, it's day 1, we have no information, we could wait until some1 is dumb enough to suggest a nolynch and then we lynch him, but I doubt that's going to happen. Let's just pick some1 to lynch and get it over with.

There are some people who haven't contributed much and probably will not contribute much, lynching them on the basis of lurking/nontalkitiveness leading to harder to read them is a plan that will lead to lots of people talking a lot and then we'll have to lynch some1 who talks alot because every1 will talk lots and day 1 will be over after 15 pages of text.

I don't really have the energy to plow through something like that, this day is silly, there is no info, let's get it over with and pray we get lucky and hit some scum?

vote Yoko Kurama

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

How much experience have you had in playing with me coolbot?
This is my second game since the server crash messed up my earlier games,
my 5th game overall and I've only finished one game total, the other 3 were cancelled due to host abandoments.

I don't really see where you get the idea that I don't pay attention, I have been checking this thread 3 times daily.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

When I say I check the threat, I imply that I actually read it.
I said I didn't have the energy to plow through ridiculously long day ones, that in no way implies that I'm going to not pay attention to this thread.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Maybe dutchman got confused from all the talk of us making some1 walk the plank that we were all pirates and there were just a few megapirates among us lol.

FD made a stupid mistake in saying pirates are the good guys....

I'm more concerned about the people who aren't participating....

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Shape up or ship out?

What is that supposed to mean?

Do you want me to post more often? say more stuff? or jump on your bandwagon against peacebringer?

I don't see the point of that since Peacebringer's role sounds like he could bring information to help us later or to verify his role with as well as setting him up as the target for the pirates if it doesn't work out.

I think it's better to target Yoko because he hasn't said anything for a while,
I think it's better to have some1 who participates alot like pb in the game rather than some1 who talks very little like yoko in the game.

All the reasons for this have been explained before, that's why I'm keeping my vote on Yoko.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I also find Sycko's roleclaim highly suscipicious.

If he is telling the truth, the only benefit he gives to the town is if the mafia try to attack him in the night and he luckily gets to shoot them(he certainly has a better chance of doing that than any of the rest of us)

So if he was playing protown as he claims, he would've claimed a useful protown role like doc or something that the mafia would want to go after at night, so that he might get to shoot them at night when they try to kill them. Sort of like an ambush.

unvote yoko

vote sycko

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Is it just me or did someone accuse the person who has his arm in a sling of being probably SK in a desperate attempt to draw attention off Fishbulb without mentioning the Fishbulb situation, almost making it seem like something to be ignored?

Or maybe Quailman just likes going after people with their arms in a sling rather than suscipicous roleclaims?

Only time will tell! Find out on the next exciting episode of....
Pirate Mafia Z!

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

oh and

vote fishbulb

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Wierd first page only list 14 players alive, and says there are 15, plus Mneme is listed in both dead and alive, unless there's a meneme and a mneme?

I is confused =(

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Going from 2 to 4 kills could be because of the pirate hunter going after quailman because of his suscipicious activity day 2, and because a pirate killing group was probably roleblocked by Cadmium, which is how he knew fishbulb was a pirate day 2.

Which makes this probably,

1 pirate group
2 Vigilantes
1 Serial Killer,

There is some serious idling in this game going on in this game,

I think we need some hardcore modprodding to get this game on track again

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

i think he's just trying to get the game moving, because right now we seem to be stuck again.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Yes Phoebus! This means Inshall must be related to IS in some insidious fashion!

Perhaps they are Pirates!

Let's Lynch Them!!!!!


::In a slightly less sarcastic tone::

Well If he voted for IS, you'd be asking him the same thing except it would be why not coolbot? Why IS?

Quite frankly I don't see what the point of your question, he felt he needed to vote for one of them to get this game moving again, and that's what he did except this game still isn't moving,

since we're both on you want to engage an online game of Go via forum? it would make this thread look more lively!

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

As to your question earlier,

Quailman was the only one seen that day to try to take away from the momentum of the bandwagon on Fishbulb,

as a result he was probably targetted by a Vigilante, probably the pirate hunter PB,

I say 2 Vigilantes are shooting in this game because we had a total of 4 night kill actions last night, while the night before that we had only 2,

Why the 2 missing kill actions?

one of them can be attributed to Peacebringer not using his vigi powers,

The other can be attributed in one of 2 ways,

I believe the other can be attributed to Cadmium's probable roleblock of Fishbulb seeing as how Cadmium was the one who pointed him out as a pirate, while Fishbulb claimed he was roleblocked.(this blocks the scum kill night 1)

while they then were able to go after the "pirate hunter" who would be hunting them down night 2.

This means either there are 3 evil kill groups and one dead vigi, or 2 evil kill groups and 2 vigis(one of which are deaD)

I do not see there being 3 bad kill groups in a 21 member mafia game, though my experience is somewhat limited.

The other option is that the roleblock of fishbulb did not block the Mafia kill and the mafia did kill night 1, meaning we had 2 vigis make attacks night 2,
they used guns/rope to kill their victims.

since guns/rope were not used night 1 meaning the stabbing might be from baddie kill groups while the guns/rope are from the good Vigis, Maybe a hangman and a constable?

meaning we still might have 2 more vigilantes as the deathscene said that Peacebringer was a great swordmaster.

I would like to ask the Doctors to PLEASE pay more attention,
IMO there is absolutely no reason Cadmium shouldn't have been protected last night after he came out and fingered fishbulb.

More ModProdding please?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

fishbulb is part of a mafia group, the pirates

him being roleblocked n1 by Cadmium(probable) might have led to the mafia being stopped from nightkilling

When I said 2 kill groups,

I meant one mafia group and one SK

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I think it is fairly obvious that Cadmium roleblocked fishbulb from Cadmium's role description and his quickly leading the bandwagon on fishbulb

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

info from an information role is good enough for me

vote olio

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

oops!

When I said info from an info role is good enough for me I was refering to FD's info on coolbot,

no idea how i read coolbot as olio

my bad

unvote olio

vote coolbot

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

since Cadmium went all out after Fishbulb I think Cadmium blocked fishbulb the night before he died.

I thought Nanook kill demensiablader? how could he do this if he was roleblocked last nite?(as he said he is)

Also I think the missing shooting can be attributed to Captain Hook being lynched.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

PB said he believed there was 1 mafia in the off voter segment and 2 mafia in the remaining onvoter segment,

those on that onvoter segment who have not roleclaimed r Mole/Olio

that is why the pressure is being put on them.

I'm not quite sure why we are listenning to PB so much?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

so you are saying basically that you think IS is scummy, but when he says something you suddenly lose your cojones and back off and wait to see if you can get any public support before diving in after IS against for comments that you believe are scummish?

If you think he's scummy back that up with a vote and be ready to take it in the stomach if it turns out later that he isn't scum, don't look for public support or people to hide behind before you go after someone because that's not just a scummy play, it's a wimpy play as well.

If you're going after someone, you better have it in you to follow through or abandon entirely, half assed crap like " i'm going to wait to see what everyone else has to say" smells like pure steaming trash to me, and frankly Mr.Pink didn't contribute much to this thread I wouldn't have any idea what your history is like. I got a nice choice between mole and you and I'm going to

vote mole

because he needs to wake up, and I know how sucky it is to read up as a replacement only to get lynched right away.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

bah!

fine

unvote mole

vote olio

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Wow Master, I guess my scolding of your wimpy methods caused you to get really mad at me enh? "Man Pooky! You vote with the majority alot! You must be Scummy!"

Nice argument there chief, we should get all the people in the majority lynched for the horrible job they've done at catching scum no?

Also you say I am scum because I managed to draw little attention to myself....
Well MOS/MrPink, how many posts did you have before today? I think I have more... which means you're lurking even MORE than I am, so by your logic you are more likely to be scum then I am....

Genius, Pure Genius

As far as I'm concerned, PB's logic that either mole or olio is scum is pretty convincing to me, so i could care less which of the 2 we lynch today because the Vigilante just kills the other one at night. This is why I voted mole to start with, and it is also the reason why i switched my vote to olio later.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Hmm so you bothered to stand up for yourself this time!

I'm not really mad at you. In fact, I'd forgotten all about your "scolding" as you put it until you mentioned it yourself. I didn't really realize how scummy you were until PB put up that summary for us to look at.

Yes, though I had posted it less than 2 days before you posted your post, so you forget messages pertaining yourself in less than 2 days yet feel qualified to look thru the other 17 pages of game info to decide that I had posted nothing of significance or considerable length yet. Basically at this point you are lying for no considerable reason since it's doubtful you would forget so quickly and my comment had no real significance earlier so there would be no need for you to rebuke it. Habitual lying enh?

No, just you, for jumping on the bandwagon every time there was a lynch nearing. You've only caught one "pirate" so far, and it looked pretty hopeless for him anyways, so why not jump on and vote for him? It makes you look less suspicious, after all. But all the rest were either innocent people or the SK, any of which were fine for you to lynch when it became clear it might happen, because they weren't "pirates".

It's nice how you focus on the fact that I've only managed to help lynch one mafia, and only one SK(which clearly can't count as good since he could is neutral towards the mafia)
Completely skipping out on the fact that I've only helped lynch one innocent, this is a very common technique for making the situation look worse than it actually is.

The fact is the lynches that I've been a part of have been quite successful, 2 out of 3 on hitting baddies, in fact the only time we've missed is on a informationless day 1, I guess you blame me for that enh?

So what you are saying is "Because you've ONLY hit 2/3 on baddies and missed ONLY the informationless day 1, you must be mafia!"

I can't speak for Mr. Pink/La_PaRCa's playing styles, although it seems likely that they just forgot this game existed, which I why they've both had to be replaced. I, on the other hand, have been active since I got here, so calling me a lurker is total BS. You, though, have been lurking, but appeared enough to show that you didn't forget about this game, just that you didn't want to say much of substance. You'd been doing this all game until I pointed this out to everyone.

I so hate the replacement part of this game just for that,
What you're saying is that regardless of how scummy or lurky your predecessor behaved, you're different and you'll stop doing that so all should be forgiven and overlooked.....
I honestly have a difficult time overlooking your predeccessor's behavior because you are willing to act different, when it comes down to it, the only real information we know about each other are the in game histories, the activity and the things we've done in this game that are either scummish, or good or whatever, putting a whole new player in and saying that because of this all bad things should be overlooked just feels wrong to me.
Would you unvote me if the mod replaced me with some1 who said he'll be different from what I do?

This is just pure flamebait. You're just trying to make me embarrassed to get me to back down off you. On the contrary, I am even more convinced of your scumminess, and there is no way you will convince me toback off just because of a stupid remark intend to make fun of me.

I don't see why you even bothered to respond to that comment, it was something I made because I felt fustrated at your terrible logic and since we obviously disagree, needed no response to, I damn well don't want you to back down or run away, would make for a pretty boring game that way.

I agree that PB's logic is fairly sound. You, however, also fit into the main group he pointed out, and I'm more convinced of your guilt than I am of theirs. So, my vote stays.

Wow you managed to make a whole series of posts criticizing me without any decent logic or explanations at all.... Bravo Master, Bravo!
I guess any1 who votes on a majority at the later moments when the record for lynching bad guys is 2 out of 3 must be a baddie enh?
I must be perfect or scum!

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

unvote olio

vote mole

we should also vote a target for Nanook's vigilante attack... rite?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

um how is 4 pooky?

I count me as 9.....

Three issues,

1) Is mole right? Should we begin the claim game after lynching 2 meaning probably 3 baddies left in 12 people, since the setup is probly 4 mafia 1 SK?

2) We really need to vote on Nanook's target, I'm not very comfortable with him choosing some1 of his own choice every time...

3) Fuldu shows up as voting on the first bandwagon that hit the innocent, yet not voting on either the second or the third, which hit baddies.
Does this make him scummish at all? Does anyone care? Will anyone notice?

And since Mastermind of Sin was able to look deep enough into my voting record to see that getting 2/3 lynches right is scummy, yet Fuldu missing a nice flat .000 is completely innocent , surely he must be followed by a bandwagon too right?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

hmm we do have 10 left!
the front page said 12 but when i actually counted the names it only added up to 10 =(

I'd blame the mod for that one =)
I'm fine with roleclaiming,

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I am Lord Demensiablader's Butler

Our plan had been to lurk our way to the endgame in order to come out with the other masons and catch us some mafia, but nanook put an end to that .

and now,
I choose PB2 =)

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

He didn't give me a name,

I am just known as Lord DemensiaBlader's Butler


And counterclaim would be useless at this point? If some1 counters my claim by saying they are the true butler then it becomes very simple, vote one of us off by day and vigikill the other one at night unless the first one turns out to be not the butler.

We get a 50% shot at getting 1 mafia straight off and a 50% shot of getting 1 mafia and 1 townie.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

We are still short one kill from day 1.

If you remember correctly,

n1 there were 2 kills when Hook was blocked by Quailman talking about clocks.
So we could very well have a second SK that we are leaving out of the equation
I highly suspect Nanook in terms of being that second SK claiming a Vigi.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

so the claim game is up!

Pooky's Most Susciciousy people list-

#1 Fuldu, a cop who forgot to use his abilities night 1!
#2 PB2, an innocent vanilla townie, and according the claims, the only one in town!
#3 NanookTheVigilantewhosmellslike a serial killer!

so I'm going with my #1 choice, Fuldu

vote fuldu

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

unvote

vote Fuldu

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Or he could've made a terrible claim in hopes of confusing you since you would think why would scum make such an obviously bad claim?

Right now I believe Dutchman is 100% cleared as nonmafia and that's why I am willing to follow him in on this lynch thingy.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

the pacifist could've protected FD as well....

Is there anyone whom was roleblocked by IS who got a night message about it?

I find the townie claim at this point to be the most suscipcious one though we do need to choose a target for Nanook tonight as we are out of options otherwise

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

because next night inhim can protect the cop?

also the cop is more or less a guranteed innocent because of his identification of the pacifist and a highly probable mafia target.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Night one we had 2 kills

one can be attributed to the Mafia

however the other one must've come from a second SK as Captain Hook was blocked by Quailman's selling of watches/clocks.
(I highly doubt that a vigilante would act on N1)

However we've seen this second kill change in type from strangulation to claws to sword.

I believe what we have here is a second SK who can change weapons(Rope for strangling, Sword for stabbing)

I believe Nanook is this SK,
He used one type of kill mechanism earlier, then switched in order to back up his vigilante claim and now he has decided to stop killing in order to lie low.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

someone unvote before scum hijack this and send IS into dead dead place.

I think he deserves at least a chance to explain before we put him away completely,

huge FOS on PB

for putting IS at one vote away from lynch when this vote is so crucial.
I don't think the discussion on IS is over and we still have to choose a night target for nanook

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

oops!
PB's vote switching between IS and Nanook got me confused


NM on most of my last post.

I do want to see IS's explanation though.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

or there was no stabbing death that night because PB was blocked by mole and chosen by the mafia to make the kill?

After they realized some1 was blocking PB they could've changed killers,

I find it odd that you don't address that possibility and instead leap straight towards making me a mafia when I've been cleared as a mason.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

unvote

vote peacebringer

night 3 is either due to PB or me,
if PB turns up innocent, nanook can go ahead and strangle me tonight.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

Go Scum Go!

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Foolster,
If Mole had protected Nanook then Nanook could not have killed a Mafia member,
Also since my additional kill on Nanook would've been blocked, I wouldn't have died(Can't get exhausted if the ability is blocked right?)

In short that would've left us with Mole dead and at day the Mafia would still have the majority and we would've happily strung up Nanook.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Yes MOS, because my bloodthirsty style of play this game just screamed Mafia Godfather Mason