I must say, it is refreshing to be in day 2 and only on page 14, I am used to being on page 14 in about 2 hours
![Very Happy :D](./images/smilies/icon_biggrin.gif)
no need to replace me, haven't posted cause nothing really stands out to make me change my vote and have been busy irlooba wrote:You have a little under six days for the deadline.
Have prodded Robbnva, KageLord and CallMeLiam. Am searching for a pre-emptive Robbnva replacement.
The more I re-read it seemed less likely rc was scum, tasky and SF were on my radar all along. When I get to a pc I will read up the past couple of days. This site goes slower than I am used to so I forgot to check back indiginova wrote:Please explain why you're switching wagons.Robbnva wrote:unvote, vote sharkfin
In addition, RC, what is the point of doing setup speculation? What will we gain from this that makes this more worth your time than actually posting the second half of your analysis.
This vote stinks. This close to deadline why are we starting a digi wagon? Even if you were correct (which you aren't) why wouldn't you be voting my slot, which at least some other people seem to agree with you? Reads like trying to start a counter wagon to derail the SharkFinn wagon. You only placed this vote after some others who seem to agree with the Shark wagon showed some interest in a digi wagon.Robbnva wrote:ok reading back the entire thread I have come to the conclusion in my mind that Digi and Tasky are in it together.
now I have fos'd tasky all game and now reading digi'spost more carefully, the way he is playing is just off to me, he clearly doesn't seem town.
also the breadcrum left by RC is enough for now to think he is one of the good guys and those 2 think he is the bad guy.
vote digi
ReaperCharlie wrote:Fact #1: ReaperCharlie is SO FRESH AND SO CLEAN.
Fact #2: ITT Robbnva is trying his arse off to buddy up to me.
Fact #3: Dinner awaits. Later dudes
Yes well when somebody role claims a town role, I will unvote to see if there are any CCs or if some sort of investigative role has contradictory info. I would love to start a wagon on Digi or tasky but I got blasted for it. This late in the game getting people to leave one wagon for another is gonna take real proof, which I don't have. So in my mind I can stay on my lone vote or go with the other people I "think" are townRhinox wrote:Just wanted to point this out as the only potential reason rob has given for unvoting shark...Rob wrote:2. Not really trying hard at all, I just re-read the thread and got the vibe you [RC] are good andwe "know" shark is good now, unless he is lying if course
And the point of this was?ReaperCharlie wrote:*trips*ooba wrote:Bump
*glares at mod*
"thanks a lot"
*pouts*
Thank you sirReaperCharlie wrote:What is that software that DOES make it friendly? Is it Tapatalk? or something? They just had a topic like that come up on some other forum I'm a part of.
Yeah just looked it up. That's it. http://www.tapatalk.com/
I'll mention it to Flay.
Figures that app isn't freeRobbnva wrote:Thank you sirReaperCharlie wrote:What is that software that DOES make it friendly? Is it Tapatalk? or something? They just had a topic like that come up on some other forum I'm a part of.
Yeah just looked it up. That's it. http://www.tapatalk.com/
I'll mention it to Flay.
ok this is what happens when you use iphone most of the time, I never realized you were the new tasky, so I will help you out lik your name saysLynchMePls wrote:
This vote stinks. This close to deadline why are we starting a digi wagon? Even if you were correct (which you aren't) why wouldn't you be voting my slot, which at least some other people seem to agree with you? Reads like trying to start a counter wagon to derail the SharkFinn wagon. You only placed this vote after some others who seem to agree with the Shark wagon showed some interest in a digi wagon.
I'm pretty sure Robbnva is scum, likely with Shark.
My vote on digi was persuaded by RC, I'll admit that but I already suspected you both ad being scumLynchMePls wrote:And you do it pretty much non-stop apparently. Also, is it just me, or has every vote you've cast over the last few pages been specifically because another player suggested you should? Do you have an original thought?Robbnva wrote:and fwiw, I don't care what bandwagons have formed, I cast my votes how I see fit.
1. are you actually peacebringer indisguise, he calls me Robbnova alsoAnon wrote: Robbnova replaced Seraphim, a player Ive played tons of games with. I can read him very easily and I had a strong town read on him. Now, I have no experience with Robbnova but the fact that he is voting for everything that moves is a towntell for a player of his kind (its not worried about getting hate). Why would he as scum play the vote hoping card again when he knows its getting him hate?. Its more likely he is village agressive idiot townie.
There are more things than apparent scumminess. In my experience, the obvious targets arent most of the time scum, but scummy townies, the easy targets scum love to mislynch. Its logical. Inexperienced townies dont know how to look town and they do scummy things all the time since they dont have the pressure scum have to try to act as townie as possible. The experienced scumhunter doesnt look for scummy actions, he looks for scummy motives. Rhinox, for example, is full of scummy motives.
Now do you get it?
MS wrote:You thinkRobbnva wrote:probably those 2 were locked in a brickhouse, but that is just a hunchrw wrote:What the hell does this mean?BN wrote:
Scene
A loud clang noise is heard like a lock being unlocked and soon CG and DJ emerge from a brickhouse.
You and anon already had votes on him and you both revoted for him, I thought they were new votes.ReaperCharlie wrote:lol which hidden votes are YOU counting?Robbnva wrote:now If I counted right in my head, I think we have Rhinox at L-1
Just quoting in case rc is actually scum, of course he would want to know who she isReaperCharlie wrote:Unvote
I just went back and looked for the Rhinox claim.
Yes, I would like to know who the Time Traveler's Wife is. Do you also learn her role and abilities, or just her flavour?
Is there another rob here? I don't think I ever said that.Rhinox wrote:A claim 4 days before deadline is better than a claim 1 day before deadline - more time to discuss.Rob wrote:In the future, I think town power roles should wait until it's absolutely necessary to claim. L-3 with another L-3 wagon doesn't seem like great timing to me.
If Clare is pro town and not currently about to be lynched, yes I am hesitant about outing another person. Outing too many roles early is never a good move,KageLord wrote:So does this mean you are against the idea of Rhinox revealing Clare?Robbnva wrote:Just quoting in case rc is actually scum, of course he would want to know who she isReaperCharlie wrote:Unvote
I just went back and looked for the Rhinox claim.
Yes, I would like to know who the Time Traveler's Wife is. Do you also learn her role and abilities, or just her flavour?
good reason as to why you think I am scummy, i mean besides the fact that I called out you and your little buddy and voted for both of you.LynchMePls wrote:
Unvote
Vote: Rhinox
SharkFinn and Robbnva are still scummy, in fact, I'm starting to lean more scummy on Robbnva than SharkFinn.
so basically you don't have any info on him but you think he could still be scummy?SharkFinn wrote:Nothing concrete on LMP (in otherwards I did not redirect him to any now dead players), but the nature of TimeTraveler/Non-TimeTraveler + possible nonkilling mafia doesnt by anymeans clear or kill clear him.
commenting strictly about the top comment, I think that like RC said there could possibly be 2 mafia groups, it seems to be all the rage nowdiginova wrote:RC and Robbnva, what do you think of my LMP analysis in 676?
umm I did have an original thought, I had a thought that you and digi were suspicious and I voted you.LynchMePls wrote:As I said yesterday, there was plenty of scum in there, and pretty much not a single original thought. Just go with the flow.
lol, see if you answered my question that last part could have been left off, I realize you were commenting on the Goon under my nameReaperCharlie wrote:lol! what lie was that?Robbnva wrote:Damn my Internet crapped out right when I was typing this long post
vote ReaperCharlie
he has dodged people's questions, lurked a ton, posted random nonsense, and posted a 100% lie and ignored the question when called on it
I never got a pm from the mod at all, so if something happened to me I wasn't told about it.SharkFinn wrote:Bah, screw it. Mind Bend (redirected) LMP to Robbnva. Either player want to claim either success of what happened or counterclaim or claim role/action?
yeah he did mention not liking my play, but I am used to it. I always get accused of being scummy cause of the way I play so it doesn't bother me.LynchMePls wrote:I don't recall you mentioning any suspicions of Robbnva. Can you point to some from yesterday?SharkFinn wrote:I didn't like Robbnva's play before. If you were scum killer, then CML/Anon would be alive + we possibly lose another scum/not strong town player atm.LynchMePls wrote:@SF: Why did you redirect me to Robbnva? What did you expect that would accomplish?
This game needs more activity. I second RC's request for a mass prod.
this to me means, oh shit someone on my team is getting lynchedcuriouskarmadog wrote:wait, what is the catch on rhinox?
this - http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 8#p2348748curiouskarmadog wrote:one last thing.
I love love love when people say this.explain to me a.) what was the overreaction.Robbnva wrote:
2. seems to overreact a bit when gandalf pushes back
and .b) how is overreaction scummy.
overreaction is scummy cause usually when people overreact they turn out to be scummy, at least in my historycuriouskarmadog wrote:you didnt even answer the question (or really 90% of my questions)...lets say in pretend world I WAS overreacting...explain to me why YOU think overreacting is scummy...I constnatly find scum who use this as an excuse to vote someone, when I call them on it, like you, they avoid answering the question because they knew it was bullshit.
my knee jerk reaction right now is to vote you, but I have a feeling you are the VI in this game. (also I need to reread a bit)
anyway, answer my questions, "I might be incorrect, but that is how I feel" is not an answer. I am asking you to go back and explain yourself, did you just read me in ISO and not really dig to see what my posts were about? If you are really trying to scum hunt, why do you feel this is the best way to do it?
now answer my questions....
I would but you don't have access to where I playcuriouskarmadog wrote:will reponse to the bulk with time, most of your points against me you admit were wrong, but you still keep the vote on me..
can you please link a game (just one out of your "history") that scum overreacted...have you ever seen town overreact?
Welcome to my world of mafia, I am overly suspicious and easily distractedLynchMePls wrote:Robbnva, you seem really wishy washy to me. I can't decide if it is scummy or not though. You seem completely unwilling to stick to any of your convictions. I think you've had a vote on like every player in the game today.