Bad Idea Mafia - Game Over

Monty · Post Post #95 (isolation #0) » Tue Dec 06, 2005 5:33 am

Finally, I check in when the thread isn't locked.

I need to review BabyJesus' posts and see if I can get any insight about his views.

If you want me to shoot someone I'll be glad to oblige.

Monty · Post Post #96 (isolation #1) » Tue Dec 06, 2005 5:35 am

BabyJesus wrote:just based on current postings, I think TINM and Yosarian2 are clean. I'd like to see Mutza be one of the two to shoot/be shot.

I would imagine these two are his investigations...

Monty · Post Post #97 (isolation #2) » Tue Dec 06, 2005 5:38 am

TSAGod wrote:
Beaker
Cogito Ergo Sum
Coron
darquiel
d_rouge
Monty
NanookTheWolf
Sineish
SinisterOverlord
the silent speaker
Thoth
TSAGod
WindSlicer

Fritzler
inHimshallibe
RangeroftheNorth

Yosarian2
This is not me

That's what we know, ripped of the page of Baby Jesus.

If we have somebody different kill each day, that's good.

...and WIFOM, Yosarian. WIFOM.

I put a space between the last two since that's just my assumption about BabyJesus' views.

Monty · Post Post #117 (isolation #3) » Fri Dec 09, 2005 2:18 am

so who's killing who here?

Monty · Post Post #119 (isolation #4) » Fri Dec 09, 2005 5:39 am

Beaker
Cogito Ergo Sum
Coron
darquiel
d_rouge
Monty
NanookTheWolf
Sineish
SinisterOverlord
the silent speaker
Thoth
TSAGod
WindSlicer

Fritzler
inHimshallibe
RangeroftheNorth

Yosarian2
This is not me

bump...

The urge is getting to me...

vote (kill) sinister overlord vote (killer) CES

Monty · Post Post #120 (isolation #5) » Fri Dec 09, 2005 5:41 am

After thinking about it more, BJ's post about yosarian and TINM totally clears them in my mind. If either of them were scum, they would never have bothered killing BJ.

Monty · Post Post #122 (isolation #6) » Fri Dec 09, 2005 9:39 am

Cogito Ergo Sum wrote:But that one post did state "just based on their current posting", which suggests that he did not investigate them.

I agree that it is very unlikely for them to both be mafia, but I could see one of the two as being mafia. After all BJ was a pretty obvious kill for the scum. Confirmed innocent, acting a lot like a cop. I'd have considered those two as real suspects if BJ hadn't been killed.

I've played with BJ enough to know that if he was a cop he wouldn't die without giving us some clue about who he investigated. That post appears to be the only indication of such.

If you dont' want to confirm those two, that's fine, but they're staying in my green list.

Monty · Post Post #127 (isolation #7) » Fri Dec 09, 2005 11:07 am

Kill: Windslicer

One problem solved...

Monty · Post Post #131 (isolation #8) » Mon Dec 12, 2005 4:33 am

the silent speaker wrote:The people I am most suspicious of: TSAGod, for first suggesting that Baby Jesus was a cop; Monty and WindSlicer, for not yet posting. I would be happiest if one of them were to kill TSAGod, but (as per my suggestion yesterday) we should get pseudo-votes from everybody and reach consensus before doing anything precipitate.

Vote (victim): TSAGod; vote (killer): either of Monty or WindSlicer.

bump

Monty · Post Post #132 (isolation #9) » Mon Dec 12, 2005 4:40 am

well, at least we know the scum won't be killing a cop tonight...

Beaker
Cogito Ergo Sum
Coron
darquiel
d_rouge
Monty
NanookTheWolf
Sineish
SinisterOverlord
Thoth
TSAGod

Killed Scum:

Monty
inHimshallibe

Killed Townies
Fritzler
RangeroftheNorth

BabyJesus views???
Yosarian2
This is not me

2 Scum down, probably 3 to go...

vote: target TSAGod - Killer Nanook

Hopefully our dead cop's last vote was for a viewed scum, or at least the scum thought that...

Monty · Post Post #141 (isolation #10) » Mon Dec 12, 2005 8:08 am

RangeroftheNorth wrote:sorry. That's supposed to say TSAgod. Don't know what I was thinking.

You had me scared for a moment there...

Monty · Post Post #147 (isolation #11) » Mon Dec 12, 2005 9:16 am

Fritzler wrote:Hmmm, why not just kill him sineish?

because a dead cop wanted TSA dead?

Monty · Post Post #152 (isolation #12) » Mon Dec 12, 2005 9:38 am

Fritzler wrote:
Monty wrote:
Fritzler wrote:Hmmm, why not just kill him sineish?
because a dead cop wanted TSA dead?
Right, why won't Sineish kill TSA?

DOH, I read that wrong, I thought you wanted to kill sineish...

Monty · Post Post #177 (isolation #13) » Thu Dec 15, 2005 5:48 am

Not killed anyone:

Beaker
Cogito Ergo Sum
Coron
Kerplunk
d_rouge
Stoofer
SinisterOverlord
Thoth

Killed Townies -
Fritzler
RangeroftheNorth
Sineish

BabyJesus views???
This is not me

Killed Scum:

Monty
inHimshallibe

Fixing Fritzler's list -

We should probably be moving roughly down the list.

vote CES killed, thoth killer

Monty · Post Post #180 (isolation #14) » Thu Dec 15, 2005 8:03 am

Mr Stoofer wrote:
d_rouge wrote:
Mr Stoofer wrote: Any objections to me blowing him away?
Go for it!
Right between the eyes!

Otherwise, I'll do it myself.
Yeah, I've got an ever so itchy trigger finger too.

But let's wait until a decent number of players have expressed a view on this. The quicker the days go by, the harder it will be to pick the GF.

I agree, but the "stalling" here just means that I will not be satisfied with an end to this day that doesn't have you on one end or the other of a shooting.

Monty · Post Post #199 (isolation #15) » Tue Dec 20, 2005 9:44 am

Well, now that we're down to the godfather, any hints from baby jesus investigations tell us nothing, and everyone alive can kill...
IMO, the only leads we have at this point are inhim and myself who have killed scum. I would put the two of us near the bottom of the kill list.
[color=greeninHimshallibe
Monty [/color]

Beaker
Kerplunk (replacing darquiel)
d_rouge
Fritzler
Sineish
SinisterOverlord
This is not me
Thoth

Monty · Post Post #200 (isolation #16) » Tue Dec 20, 2005 9:51 am

Promoted CES as killer/target before fritzler went trigger happy...

Fritzler
ROTN
Inhim
Sineish
Monty

leaving -
beaker
kerplunk
sinisteroverlord
tinm
thoth

I think the group promoting CES as either killer or target on that day are less likely to be scum.

Monty · Post Post #203 (isolation #17) » Wed Dec 21, 2005 2:47 am

Thoth wrote:Monty is pushing a little too hard in my opinion and putting too much emphasis on his own innocence, where all his actions came at a time where they were inevitable.

kill:Monty

good luck

Monty · Post Post #267 (isolation #18) » Thu Jan 26, 2006 5:55 am

So Thoth, why did you kill me?

As soon as I posted that the players who had shot scum were likely clean, you killed me, and the godfather killed the other living player who had shot one of them...

It seemed obvious that scum wouldn't execute their own during the day.