Brightest Day Mafia, Part 1 - GAME OVER

[PeregrineV]

Caught up.

Read everything through night with ooba/Toog flips, will go through with new flips. Until that's done,

Vote: CandleJack

@MrSub- Why claim? I don't feel like the game was broken, so not sure why you did it.

[PeregrineV]

@Kast- The Justice League did half-ass approve Vezok in the post following the one you linked to.
However, I see what your saying about Andrius, but it seems more of a normal CAPS-POSTY way instead of complaining about the fact.

p-edit: Wasn't feeling the WLC case, but your voting the White Lantern guy? You know they are the good guys, right?

Unvote.
Vote: WLC

So, more information on why we should lynch the White Lantern Entity feller.

[PeregrineV]

Lot of stuff to get through, here. Thoughts on the last ~10 pages:

[snipped]

In summary,

FoS: Muffin and Peregrine

.

Vote: CandleJack

for aforementioned reasons. Now that we know ooba was town, Tar's rage easily reads like Mafia frustrated at drawing suspicion for quickhammering without even getting the hammer in.

Votecount 2.1.2

Apokaylptika (3) - nopointinactingup, zMuffinMan, Candle Jack

@Apok- Yes, WLC needs to speak more. If he is cult-dude, then it would be interesting to hear his answer to my question. If he's not, it would be interesting to hear his answer to my question.

And aside from hilarious, what do you think of Nik fakeclaiming the cop result twice? And MrSub's disintegrating geniusplan?

[PeregrineV]

@Kast- I replaced in day2, so I will not have any posts the first 40+ pages. And the guy I replaced only confirmed, so my post count will not be as high as others.

Torn between Apok and WLC. So let's see where this takes us.

UNVOTE: WLC
VOTE: Apok

Making Apok at 5 and WLC at 3 votes.

For now, going with (mostly) town reads on
Friend & Co. (Nika, Hiplop, Nopoint, Muffin)
Kast
Toasty
Vezok
Mr. Sub

More suspicious of:
WLC
Apok
Tant
Andrius

With the rest falling in between either do to posts or nullness.

[PeregrineV]

Hey, subliminal. Do something to make me think you can't be CR. I'm getting paranoid here.

Do you not think what we're currently doing qualifies?

Look at it from a non-you point of view. In a game with custom mechanics where you contact players who "join" your group, I don;t see where his request is insane.

Also, as I am finding Kast largely townish, what is the cause for you putting him in your listing as possible cult-dude?

[PeregrineV]

---

FOS: Peregrine

You list you suspects here:

More suspicious of:
WLC
Apok
Tant
Andrius

But your first post in the game is this vote on us with no reasoning and you seem to abandon it all together. It reads like you're talking out of your ass when listing people you think are anti-town or not. Not to mention the fact you seem anti-MrSub who at that time was claiming to be able to break the game.

Caught up.

Read everything through night with ooba/Toog flips, will go through with new flips. Until that's done,

Vote: CandleJack

@MrSub- Why claim? I don't feel like the game was broken, so not sure why you did it

It was only the first readthrough, and my suspicions on you were great enough to vote you. Since then, more day has occurred, and more posts have been posted, so you're now more town to me than before.

As for MrSub, I'm not really anti-him yet, I just wanted to know why he claimed. Why would his claim help the town more than the mafia (or cult) at this point?

Also, as I am finding Kast largely townish,

Why?

Because I agree with ~85% of what he said so far. That obviously drops the more we play, but I find the thought processes to be familiar. Taking that in conjunction with my own alignment, I find him highly townish.

[PeregrineV]

I'll be out of town and posting/reading will be null/minimal during this time.

V/LA Friday Aug 12 to Mon Aug 15

[PeregrineV]

I want everyone to list their 3 favorite anti-town people.

WLC
Ghostwriter
CJ/Inhim

[PeregrineV]

Unvote.
Vote: Ghostwriter

And hell, since scum would be retarded not to take notes, I'm going to share mine.

- nopointinactingup-town via Friend
- Kast-
- Andrius- vig claim
- Candle Jack-
- WeyounsLastClone-
-

marco1610

Blackberry
- hiplop- town via Friend
- Mr. Subliminal- Claimed Entity-White lantern stuff
- GhostWriter
- ToastyToast-claimed town JK
- vezokpiraka-claim town vote-freezer
- tanstalas-claimed town powerstealer
-

Bogre

Friend-town via Friend
- Nikanor-town via Friend
- zMuffinMan- town via Friend
-

kondi2424

PeregrineV- town
- inHimshalibe- claimed Miller
- Oversoul-claimed one-shot something

So, it would also be super great if the 5-man Mason team can each and every one of you verify that you are indeed MASONS and not NEIGHBORS.

[PeregrineV]

Unvote.
Vote: Ghostwriter

And hell, since scum would be retarded not to take notes, I'm going to share mine.

- nopointinactingup-town via Friend
- Kast-
- Andrius- vig claim
- Candle Jack-
- WeyounsLastClone-
-

marco1610

Blackberry
- hiplop- town via Friend
- Mr. Subliminal- Claimed Entity-White lantern stuff
- GhostWriter
- ToastyToast-claimed town JK
- vezokpiraka-claim town vote-freezer
- tanstalas-claimed town powerstealer
-

Bogre

Friend-town via Friend
- Nikanor-town via Friend
- zMuffinMan- town via Friend
-

kondi2424

PeregrineV- town
- inHimshalibe- claimed Miller
- Oversoul-claimed one-shot something

So, it would also be super great if the 5-man Mason team can each and every one of you verify that you are indeed MASONS and not NEIGHBORS.

This is a really terrible post.
How about giving us some reads?

Well, based on playstyle, I think 99% of the town is scum (ok, maybe not 99, but way over 50).
I have not gelled into the whole "Gleebop is scum!! LOL LYNCHLYNCHLYNCHLYNCHLYNCH" thing, so I find it scummy, and oftentimes less than helpful.

Does my request to have the 5-man mason team actually confirm masons bug you, or is it my notes themselves?

[PeregrineV]

It's the notes. It's fluff, and half of them are wrong anyway.
AND I've already said that the masons are not actually masons. We're just all very, very likely to be town.

Ahh, that does change things. So the fab 5 are just fab town, but not confirmed masons. That's much better, because I was having a hard time squeezing all of the scum and CR into three people using PoE.

And they were notes for me when I read, so as to how much to weigh each post. And I'm glad I did, since you were able to clear up misconceptions.

[PeregrineV]

I'm OK with it as long as town isn't retarded about using the information.

[PeregrineV]

Already voting Ghostwriter, so nothing to add there.

Also, is the best way to add to the conversation by throwing out random accusations, or should I spend the time to respond to Candle's "PeregrineV is scum" thing?

@Oversoul- please vote GW and end the day. Thank you.

Why would you put the miller as a possible scum pick, Peregrine? That doesn't make sense.

Vezok, why am I suspicious for being a lurker?

Anyway, Scumpicks would have to be:

WLC
GW
Peregrine