Secret Society Mafia - Game Over

[TheJakalope]

confirm

[TheJakalope]

Just a little preface to my reads throughout this game. I give a group of people and a percentage of either town or scum.

My first one.

Between Magister, Magna, and David X, 1 is anti-town.

[TheJakalope]

Well DY, The way these 3 interacted earlier, there is little chance that they are all town. The reason I don't put a vote out is because if I am right, but I guess the first 2 people that aren't scum, we'd have lynched 2 Town. I need to be a lot more confident then "He's got a 33% chance at being scum!" to put down a vote.

[TheJakalope]

Just a little preface to my reads throughout this game. I give a group of people and a percentage of either town or scum.

My first one.

Between Magister, Magna, and David X, 1 is anti-town.

This is utter tripe.

Vote:TheJakalope

Care to expand on that?

[TheJakalope]

/derp.

Where did I claim it was my best tool. It's just something I do for my playstyle, and I like to share my group reads.

[TheJakalope]

What is this nonsense? How does he even know one of them is anti-town to start with?

I don't know with 100% certainty, sure, but it's called a read. Would it have been better if I said,"Between the 3 of them,

I think

one is scum." ?

[TheJakalope]

What is this nonsense? How does he even know one of them is anti-town to start with?

I don't know with 100% certainty, sure, but it's called a read. Would it have been better if I said,"Between the 3 of them,

I think

one is scum." ?

It feels like you're just repeating yourself without explaining here. Why do you think one of them is scum, based on their interactions?

It's not a "Well, David said THIS, and that means one of them is scum!" Just look through the 2nd(?) page and look at how they interacted.

[TheJakalope]

Just a little preface to my reads throughout this game. I give a group of people and a percentage of either town or scum.

My first one.

Between Magister, Magna, and David X, 1 is anti-town.

It's just something I do for my playstyle, and I like to share my group reads.

Don’t ever recall seeing you do this before. How about providing some completed game links that demonstrate it is 'part of your playstyle' …

It's not a "Well, David said THIS, and that means one of them is scum!" Just look through the 2nd(?) page and look at how they interacted.

The problem I have is not that you’ve called out a group (3 players) it’s that you can’t elucidate any reasons more than vauge “Look at them interact”.

I’ve certainly been known to call out a particular group of players and say “1 on these must be scum” in the past. But it is always based on something specific – in Amrun’s Death of Reaper Charlie it was the quick wagon on Meran for role-fishing.

Well I only started playing Mafia again about 8 games ago. 5 of those games are still going.

From Lost Mafia - UK and Ironhead are tied right now.. I think it's likely that one is scum, but definitely not both. Unfortunately they both lie at about the same scummy levels for me right now.

The other 2 games that are finished, I hadn't done it, as I replaced in later in the game, and it's normally an early game read.

However, I've done it in one of the games I'm currently in with you. Not going to say which one, but I have.

[TheJakalope]

I feel at least one or two of the votes on me are antitown..

In particular EtheralCookie's vote seemed especially opportunistic. Looking at his ISO shows that he has a grand total of 4 posts.

1 to confirm.
1 to RVS
And 2 to sheep what other people said about me before him.

VOTE: EtherealCookie

[TheJakalope]

@muffin, I elaborated with my vote on Ethereal.

[TheJakalope]

Muffin is leaning town.

IceGuy is scum.

VOTE: IceGuy

Still strongly suspicious of EtherealCookie.

[TheJakalope]

Muffin has had plenty of explanation, and it was quite enough for me.

[TheJakalope]

Ice Guy
-

Explain how zMuffinman has been opportunistic if you don't mind.

Anyway, my vote on whisper going nowhere fast.

unvote

VOTE: IceGuy

Why are you defending zMuffinMan?

Scum. You avoided answering the question and asked other irrelevant questions. Great flailing there.

[TheJakalope]

It's time for your favorite type of read guys.

EtherealCookie, Iceguy, one is scum. Not both.

[TheJakalope]

Prodge.

Ghostlin is town.
Oversoul is likely town.
DavidX is leaning scum, but Iceguy or Otolia is today's lynch.

[TheJakalope]

All of Jak's reads have been like this; one of this person and this person is scum. It's not really scumhunting.

It's like I'm saying I have scum reads on both of them. but, I don't see them being scum together.

[TheJakalope]

This weekend will be busy for me. Will pop in every now and then, but nothing big.

[TheJakalope]

Sorry about the inactivity and my "approach" to this game. I understand it's worse than usual.

That being said.

VOTE: Dry-Fit

[TheJakalope]

Hmmm..

Unvote

VOTE: Alabaska J

[TheJakalope]

Information Instead of Analysis

http://mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?tit ... reviations

[TheJakalope]

And that, is fluff.

[TheJakalope]

Will Be V/LA until Late Sunday Night or Monday.