TV Upick - Scum win

[redFF]

VOTE: ghostwriter
terrible movie

[redFF]

Actually,

UNVOTE: PiggyGal15
VOTE: plenty

Get an avatar.

this
not having an avatar just makes the thread more confusing and harder to read. Refusing to get an avatar is scummy and will be treated as such.

[redFF]

Oh, and before I forget: My vote on Goomba was a random vote. I was aware that he wasn't actually claiming scum, and it was as good (or bad) a reason as any to RV.

Just to clear things up.

honestly this didn't really need clearing up. scummy post.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: lupus vega

[redFF]

hahaha

[redFF]

we could always just lynch the miller claim. It's a fairly simple way of resolving things and removes a very complicated/wifomy role which could cause huge amounts of trouble later in the game.

or it lynches scum.

[redFF]

Just did an ISO of redFF, and I'm not liking what I see. He's had a few fluff posts, and voted me for a post he thought sounded scummy (which I won't exactly dispute). The only real post he's put down is this:

we could always just lynch the miller claim. It's a fairly simple way of resolving things and removes a very complicated/wifomy role which could cause huge amounts of trouble later in the game.

or it lynches scum.

So...he suggests a miller lynch, but doesn't follow through with a vote? It seems to me that he's waiting for someone else to start the voting, so he can clear himself later.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: redFF

nice omgus. and it was a suggestion for something we could possibly do, not a LYNCHLYNCHLYNCH post

[redFF]

I'm not seeing killer scum right now.. I'm liking what izak said about Cobbler.

VOTE: Cobbler

what do you like about it. need more to work with dude.

[redFF]

sup panda i had a scumread on lupus so i'll see how you do. not unvoting yet.

[redFF]

millers are bad and there is nobody else that screams scum enough to lynch imo, maybe plenty.

for now
VOTE: ghostwriter

[redFF]

millers are bad and there is nobody else that screams scum enough to lynch imo, maybe plenty.

for now
VOTE: ghostwriter

What happened to Lupus>Replacement being scum? >__>;

reads change

[redFF]

im tired ill post tommorow.

[redFF]

Plenty, what do you think about Jakalope?

Most of his posts seem fairly neutral to me,

but I don't understand why he didn't share his other reasons for voting Cobbler if he's a townie. There was no night zero so, unless he and Cobbler are siblings, it can't be power role related, and surely if they were siblings he would just claim.

VOTE: Jakalope

Jakalope, can you explain what these reasons were and why you didn't state them when you voted Cobbler please?

this is a weird post. why did you need to vote, can't you just ask him. and if you didn't have a scum read on him why vote him in the first place?

[redFF]

i also noticed plenty talked about the miller claim a lot but never actually gave his opinion about ghost's alignment. He was just trying to look like contributing by posting general statements.

VOTE: plenty i encourage everyone to iso him.

[redFF]

well have you decided?

[redFF]

hi ill post later

[redFF]

we need a wagon and from iso'ing both of them jakalope is the better lynch

VOTE: jakalope

[redFF]

i don't understand. If you thought lurconis is scum why didn't you build a coherent case on him and try to get him lynched instead of using one of your 2 shots night 1 on the town doctor...

[redFF]

xanatos is useless every game i've been in with him, and in those hes flipped town.

[redFF]

regardless of how dumb it was, i believe meran's claim.

David xanatos on the other hand. dat hammer???

VOTE: davidxanatos

[redFF]

dx's first mention of jakalope was his hammer without letting him claim lol

[redFF]

HMMMM

WHY NOT DAVID XANATOS?

[redFF]

no its fine
UNVOTE:

[redFF]

im afraid that this could be just town v town. i've had a situation where i've counterclaimed another townie before and lynched him and all that happened then was 2 dead blues.

[redFF]

since every experienced player here thinks that the 2 claims are impossible, a 1for1 trade seems good.

for people saying why not just let them shoot each other? consider this-scum blocks the townie and scum shoot someone else.

VOTE: davidxanatos

[redFF]

erm i can't really think of how you would have a scumread on me from meta but nice case i get?

[redFF]

since every experienced player here thinks that the 2 claims are impossible, a 1for1 trade seems good.

for people saying why not just let them shoot each other? consider this-scum blocks the townie and scum shoot someone else.

VOTE: davidxanatos

thats why

[redFF]

I'm not claiming my role
If you believe I would claim Patrick from Spongebob as scum... jeez, that would be bad

wait what

[redFF]

i dunno what we're gonna do about the 2 vig claims, i guess we'll see what tommorow brings?

vote: thejakalope

bandwagoned day 1

plus everything already said

furcolow scum

VOTE: furcolow

L-1

[redFF]

Just checked, I have one shot remaining of two apparently, so yeah, lost a shot..

And it can't be a redirect or my flavour would have been apparent.. so there's either a mafia assassin, or another vig. :/

or you're lying?

[redFF]

so are we just giving davidxanatos the benefit of the doubt? What happens when/if his other shot disappears into the nether?

[redFF]

IM RIGHT HERE.

plenty against redpanda isnt town v town and im inclined to think plenty is the scum, but im fairly sure we have a 1 for 1 trade regardless.

VOTE: plenty

[redFF]

WIFOM YO

[redFF]

CAN WE GET SOME PROD/REPLACEMENTS UP IN HERE

[redFF]

???

[redFF]

hi kuribo!

[redFF]

kuribo is the fucking man

[redFF]

gonna need pics of kuribo's sister.

[redFF]

I'd like a claim

[redFF]

although i dont think any claim is going to sway my vote.

[redFF]

plenty did you crumb at all?

[redFF]

ah

[redFF]

Simple VT here i have no role claim

Also i still dont know why you guys dont insist on lynching ghostwriter.....

this is a game where you picked your role..., who are you?

[redFF]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: killer

fairly certain thats l-1 but if its the hammer then fuck the police

[redFF]

My suspects are Plenty, Kuribo, Deas. But not necessarily as a team. (Yes, I said Deas rubbed me as town, but that only moved him from being my primary suspect.)

My gut tells me there's at least one scum in the lower profile players, Ghostwriter and PeregrineV, who haven't made much impression on me.

what the fuck is this shit?

your suspects are everyone except you, killer, Xanatos, and Panda?

It kind of depends on flips, I'm still thinking it through and rereading. If Killer is scum you're obviously town. If you're scum, I think Peregrine is probably town because of his vote on Dummy before you replaced in. If Ghostwriter is scum you're town because of Dummy and vice-versa. If Killer is scum his wanting to lynch the claimed miller is also probably indicative of Ghostwriter being town.

Killer's a good enough lynch for today, if he flips scum he effectively clears

at least

two people for me. Xanatos' last comment on his target was to either shoot Plenty or Piggy, so I'm happy with that at least.

[redFF]

sounds hot

[redFF]

cobbler "knowing" that there are 3 scum looks like a slip

I hope Killer flips scum, because otherwise we don't have a mislynch for me tomorrow, and I have a feeling I will be lynched

looks like a slip

cobbler hasn't done anything all game, i believe plenty's claim. I still think we should lynch plenty but i'd be willing to lynch cobbler.

[redFF]

*still think we should lynch killer

[redFF]

his play has been scummier, cobbler could just be really really stupid.