Trouble in Minas Tirith! Game over!

[bigbenwd]

i am now in the process of confirming my role

[bigbenwd]

ya, those roles seem pretty accurat, but anyways, for the point of my post...

slightly random vote: gnome it all

because it seemed to me like he was inferreing that his vote was not random with absolutely 0 evidence to back it up...

[bigbenwd]

and if gnome it all's vote really was a random vote, but his post was worded wrong, then unvote him for me, unless that would be too much trouble, and i'll random vote later so gnome dosent have to votes (wow, that made no sense, did it?)

[bigbenwd]

unvote: gia

guess it was random after all. and ive got pretty much nothing on the posts thus far, so i think im gonna wait, not vote anybody for now

[bigbenwd]

I wonder as to the title of this game. Is Minas Tirith the setting and should we focus on happenings around that part of the book for the most part? Or did Mac just get tired of calling it LOTR mafia...

Nope, I can confirm it is IN the city of Minas Tirith, although there are things that are done outside.

what kinds of things? or is that not allowed to be told?

[bigbenwd]

vote: zoneace

his claim is wayy too convenitent, eomer is a major enough charachter to be known, so it could be easily made up, and yet it is in a way a minor chatachter (he is from Rohan, we are talking about Gondor in osgiliath) that nobody else may have so as to contradict him, while i also think that eomer being such a warrior would have some dort of vig role, overall, this claim seems extremely scummy

[bigbenwd]

kind of what i was thinking lol

[bigbenwd]

what ISNT convincing about this all?? lol

[bigbenwd]

i sent him a pm yesterday, no response yet... maybe someone else would like to mod? should we wait longer or post in the queue and then pm the new mod our roles

[bigbenwd]

ya, his last post was 2 days ago, im making a queue replacement thread

[bigbenwd]

fos: orbiting


he looks like he's lurking, but that is coming from me, to whom all of this forum are lurkers soooo ya

[bigbenwd]

i know what he's talkin about, and i think i know FD's charachter, but i cant remember his name. I wont say it though because it sounds like he dosent want me to.

[bigbenwd]

we still have the docs if someone is a good guy, even though i think that leo is a scum

fos:leonidas

[bigbenwd]

actually, we have absolutely nothin else to go on right now, so

vote:leonidas

[bigbenwd]

is anyone else here suspicious of leonidas, he hasnt posted in a while, and he was the only oher one going through a gate, and we're pretty sure BB is a good guy.

[bigbenwd]

i think fd sshould look at gate 1 as then he could see anybody who enters or exits from outside, aka the haradrim ect.

[bigbenwd]

we have nothing to go on right now, and theres like nobody else posting in here, who else herte agrees with my lynching of leo today?

[bigbenwd]

Ages*
BananaBob
BigbenWD
Coolbot (one post)
Dragon Slayer*
Flying Dutchman
Leonidas*
Mr Gnome it all*
Orbiting
Pheobus*
Riven*
Scalebane*
Talitha*
Thoth*
Tigris*
Untrod Tripod*

a star indicates people who have not posted in three days or more... COME ON PEOPLE!

[bigbenwd]

im sorry, i was in a bad mood last night, in a game i play people are being un cool, anyways...
i'm eager to lynch right now because we have nothing else to go on, all we have is fd's people who passed the gate (i think that he should patrold gate 1 as we could see people that enter and leave the city, like the haradrim would have to) and scince leo hasnt posted in forever so far as i can tell, but i see its the holidays, so i'll give him slack, and i dont think BB is bad.

[bigbenwd]

I think mr Gnome is all has a point, i think bigbenwd is too eager to kill someone. I don't think with his experience he would just say "lets kill someone coz we have nothing to go with

note: this is my second game ever lol, i dont know, leo is the only suspicious person to me right now

[bigbenwd]

lol, you too UT

(we all know whos getting some this chistmas, and it isnt me )

[bigbenwd]

ya, from the logic displayed here,

vote: leo

[bigbenwd]

i didnt understand that

[bigbenwd]

vote: riven

, lets see what he has to say

unvote:leo

[bigbenwd]

ya, i think merry would have a pro town cho0ice if he was in this, it would probly be like every night he searches for the Witch King and if he finds him, he kills him.

[bigbenwd]

vote:gia

forthe same reason that cam voted on him

[bigbenwd]

we waiting for a role from mgia?
i dont think it wise, too many role claims too early if you ask me, i think riven is supicious enough, and his rc is only kinda beleiveable, i dunno, i'll think through it later

[bigbenwd]

we dont want pippen to claim now, i dont think docs are left to protect (maybe only 1 or 2) so i think we should go easy on the role claims here. this game isnt going many places.... is it? lol

[bigbenwd]

sounds like a plan to me (searches for evil lurkers)

[bigbenwd]

vote pheobus

i hate lurkers

[bigbenwd]

toth, read the last part of cams post, there is a reason, and also, i beleive the person beforehand had a reason as well.
there, explained.

[bigbenwd]

ya, i think the FD should go on gates 1-3,
because maybe people in the gates higher up are ike the king's (or steward's) servents or something

[bigbenwd]

I too am not convinced of his innocence. But the claim can be easily contradicted later if, say, when we're down to 5 of us, it turns out that Pippen wasn't in the game. Makes for a nice easy kill.

Cam

happy mr blind man?

unvote: pheobus

FoS: pheobus

[bigbenwd]

(that was talking about gia and my vote for gia, not my vote for pheobus, my vote on pheobus was for lurking, i unvoted and fosed for reasons i cant recall right now, im too tired, ill yell u all tommorow when i remember)

oh yeah, the fos is there because im not so sure of his im not sure you guys wanna lynch me argument, so ya, thats why its only an fos, nothig really mportant

[bigbenwd]

read, it gets extended if nobody has any votes

[bigbenwd]

i'm aware, but that wasn't your wueston, your question was adressed in macros' post

[bigbenwd]

this game is at a standstill, anybody have any ideas? even semi-ideas?

[bigbenwd]

<not very well thought through semi idea>

How do the mafia communicate at night? Obviously by pm, but thats not what I mean, How do they communicate in the game world? I always assumed they phoned each other, but there aren't any phones in LOTR. What if, mafia had to go to the same place at night to communicate with each other. This would make FDs role have more use.

My pet theory then is that ZONEACE, Tigris and Thoth are scum together, and were all in the same place to communicate the first night. We know ZONEACE was scum, and i've already outlined my suspicions of Tigris, but unofortunatly for me, Thoth seems squeaky clean and seems very unlikely to be scum with ZONEACE.

</not very well thought through semi idea>

thats all we got i guess, so...

vote:tigris

[bigbenwd]

unvote tigris

he seems innocent with that last post, usually most scum ty to keep it cool, while ownies explodecuz they cant beleive it

vote: ages

getter than the crap logic, so i'm gonna follow him on this one

(i hope this dosent come bite me in the ass, which it probably will.)

[bigbenwd]

EVERYONE UNVOTE, DO NOT LYNCH ME
(hopes for u all's sake that the deadline is re-extended)
I didn't want to have to roleclam, but looks like i'm in pretty deep crap right now lol.

I am Denethor, Steward of Gondor, i posess the seeing stone palantir, everynight i can see someone.
i'm a cop, leonidas is innocent, and i investigated ZA the 1st night, but you all got him the first day w/out me, so ya

(please help me doc, i really hope theres a lot left)

[bigbenwd]

also,

unvote:ages

[bigbenwd]

did i really vote for leo?... oops lol
I may have just been voting so the scum don't see me as suspicious, I can't remember.

[bigbenwd]

w00t, i'm beleived. lol

[bigbenwd]

deadline is passed I beleive, but i think he extended it, and ya, thats probly what he'll do.

[bigbenwd]

i've never been cop, i dunno who to vete day 1 lol, anyways, what day were those votes on leo,were those today? or were they day 1?

[bigbenwd]

Ben doesn't always think before he speaks. I think we all know this. I think it's probably also true of the voting procedure in his head. I feel fairly strongly that this was a newbie mistake. The role claim is very believable.

Cam

HERE HERE! lol

vote: orbiting

i hope he isnt likie the last doc who'l protect me or something lol, that would really suck

[bigbenwd]

I've thought about it myself, i may be insane, and the point of sauron is a good one. i guess we'll never know... ti'll sauron comes out.

[bigbenwd]

I finished my last final today!!!!!!!!! *does a happy dance*

[bigbenwd]

its fine that we lynch him. we have nobody else to lynch, and we arent allowed to no lynch, so i think this is the best way to go, even though we may be lynching a townie we may also be lynching a scum. we just have to hope for the best.

[bigbenwd]

Unvote: corsato

I'll be back soon for a look through to see what happened lol

[bigbenwd]

Vote: toth

he obviously wants me lynched, even after my claim and how everyone else beleived me. I beleive we recently had suspicions on him, i forget why, and i dont know how to go back and quote more tan one thing, so, all im going to say is he's been wanting to lynch me for quite some time, even after i claimed denethor a cop, obviously beneficial top the town.

[bigbenwd]

I was suggesting a no lynch, because all we are managing to do at the moment is force what are apparently strong pro town roles into the open. We try bandwagon after bandwagon, but all we seem to get at the end is a forced claim by a roel that we would seem to not want to lose.

that just looks pretty darn scummy

vote:ages

[bigbenwd]

I can't put my finger on it exactly, but to me, that looked like you didn't want to get bandwaggoned and make up that role we dont want to lose.

[bigbenwd]

i'm actually going to

unvote:ags

and

vote:no lynch

we have pretty much no suspiciouns and we have a couple of cops and docs, i say we wait for out investingtions to come in.

[bigbenwd]

unvote

vote:ages

I can hardly call that a beleiveable claim, I cant recall the woes being at Mt either. Also, its obscure enough that it may not be in the game, thus making it a grat scum rc

[bigbenwd]

finally, the day from hell ends lol, like 20,000 roleclaims and lasting a few weeks.

[bigbenwd]

Vote: toth

He's evil, I investigated him last night.

and I knew FD was beregond, all I remember about beregond though was he was a good freind of merry (or whoevery claimed allegience to Denethore) and helped Merry through tough times.

[bigbenwd]

I know, I shouldn't have, I tried not to, but y'all bandwaggoned me, and I figured it would've been a bigger threat to the town if I lied and got lynched that day instead of just claiming.

[bigbenwd]

who ti investigate... Toth, got anny accomplices that I would know about?

[bigbenwd]

I think I was attacked but someone was protecting me

anyways with my sanity issues, I think what it really is is what can sauron do to me? I think sauron can recruit me at sometime in the game or something, you know? I dunno, just speculating. maybe Sauron too sees my results? who knows.

[bigbenwd]

knew because I knew he was gatekeeper, and rememberes this gatkeeper freind of merry/pippen's from the book, I had just forgotten his name up until then
he had a son too, maybe hes son takes over his role for him? (whoever it is, don't claim if there is one out there)

[bigbenwd]

and to further my argument... I'm good.

and I say, we lynch Toth, see if he's evil(which he is, he was also acting pretty scummy yesterday, which lead me to investigatge him in the first place.), see if hes a goodie, therefore we see if im sane (yay)

[bigbenwd]

w00t, i'm finally important in a game

[bigbenwd]

... ouch
... GO TOWN! WOOT!

[bigbenwd]

Stew? where did it say stew?
Ah, i see
Minced and ready for stewing

[bigbenwd]

... this is an evil satan thread, look Trouble in Minas Tirith! DAY

6

!!

666

Macros (6 letters)

6

745(7+4-5=6) Wed Mar (3rd day, 3rd month added is 6) 10, 2004(added is 6) 11:52 pm
Dragon Slayer (6 letters in each word)... I just saw that, and had nowhere else to post it
also: good job town with the recent killage of the scums
*dies again*

[bigbenwd]

I'll be replacing soon(i hope), have no role yet. but if someone could give a recap on the arguments of suspicion for me so i dont have to read like 20 pages that wold be great.

[bigbenwd]

vote: phoebus

after reading through his posts it seems the appropriate thing to do, and as i think i was sane earlier and leo's probly innocent and i know cam's innocent, im voting for you.

[bigbenwd]

actually,

unvote

because the role leftthat is scum is probably an orc capitan or something, and may be immune to night investigations. leo. claim your role?

[bigbenwd]

wait, I found your claim, and i saw it as beleivable, and your posts swayed me therefore

vote:phoebus

(sorry for the triple postage)

[bigbenwd]

wait, what did Pheobus mean? i didnt get it i guess we will wait for mac.

[bigbenwd]

I definately did investigate him, im 99% sure of it, but I've cleared my inbox scince then, so alas, I cannot prove it.

[bigbenwd]

alas, that too was pushed out of my sentbox as it is 100% full