The Third Fortnight (Game Over [Bonus Round])

[Antihero]

VOTE: muffin

pCygnusxatjsHDjhdBfHDjbgakidejTVghguhdh

[Antihero]

...how did you know that

i never said zmuff was my partner pre-reroll

i voted him but

.........hm

theres only one explanation

he rolled scum again and then blabbed to kat that he was sad bc he waz so ready to pwnz all the townz with you

gg no re

[Antihero]

waiting for snarky to post a little more so i can mislynch him

how about u?

[Antihero]

my picks would be:
i) quilford
ii) johnnyfarrar
iii) marquis

i'm not one of your three
the list is automatically garbage

[Antihero]

ur a bitch

[Antihero]

cheet you're not going to force me to have to outright tell you i'm trolling are you?

[Antihero]

let me wear my tryhard pants and try to impress all of the cool people in this game anti.
will you make a list and make me happy? <3

pffft planning for night 1 is the loser mentality

(srs business i dont have any READS reads yet. i have a couple maybe scumreads and a couple maybe townreads. none worth talking about yet.)

[Antihero]

can u talk ab them w/ me while im here cuz like.....after work tomorrow it's just 100% hearthstone till i pass out 2mw night

i should make you guess 'em

that'll teach you

[Antihero]

i'll give whoever guesses one of my secret crushes a kiss

[Antihero]

bad dog

i know

i'm such an asshole

[Antihero]

ur
just
jelly

[Antihero]

i'll give whoever guesses one of my secret crushes a kiss

fine then

no smootches for any of you

[Antihero]

/kisses johnny

[Antihero]

well now i blew my load

thanks

VOTE: the bulge

[Antihero]

oh wow i meant on the scumread

that came out SO much dirtier than i intended wow i apologize

[Antihero]

im gonna go puke now and curl up in the bathroom and cry

[Antihero]

im filthy and disgusting and awful

DONT EVEN LOOK AT ME

[Antihero]

muffinman

can you be the hero this game deserves and tell everyone who my other scumread is?

[Antihero]

fine but dont complain if someone else steals your kiss before you get back

[Antihero]

goooooooooooooooooooork

come on

don't be a bad sport

who's my other scumread?

[Antihero]

no

and no

[Antihero]

oh, you are so bad

SOMEBODY SAVE ME

[Antihero]

I feel like people don't realize we only get two weeks to find one of two scum out of 16. Not bandwagonning at this stage is tantamount to collaborating with the enemy.

Unvote, vote: Kuroi

theres a bulge wagon

what are you even talking about?

[Antihero]

discomforting!

elaborate

[Antihero]

if it's a wagon speed argument that's... awful

and if it's a wagon composition thing that's... also awful

you thought it was important enough to pooh-pooh so what was it that you were pooh-poohing?

[Antihero]

oh ok, yeah you're right. that doesn't make any sense.

[Antihero]

how is that rude?

you said something. YOU posted it in the thread and now i'm not allowed to talk about it or call it nonsense if i think it's nonsense?

come on, now

[Antihero]

if you think i'm condescending to you then we are on two different planets. i have no idea where you're getting that im condescending to you and how youre taking anything i say personally is beyond me because you should know by now that's not how i work (ESPECIALLY in mafia games)

we're not in a game full of vi's. there's no threat of a quicklynch AND there's a votecount, right there. as for wagon speed arguments, i hate those with a visceral passion because they are so meaningless but so many people on this site seems to think they mean something (not to mention they're even MORE stupid given the insanely high ratio of town:scum here)

i also happen to think that wagon pooh-poohing/devils advocate is pretty scummy because it's one of those go-to, low-content things to post. so yeah i'm going to ask about it.

[Antihero]

ur so edgy, dav

[Antihero]

nothing in there has anything to do with my point about the threat of wagons being empty.

yeah i have no idea what you're talking about there

[Antihero]

ok well i guess i'll drop it

who knew i just loved being a dick for the sake of it?

[Antihero]

this playerlist is the last one i thought i would need to tiptoe around

i assumed gork was talking about something specific to the bulge wagon but i guess not so now i really dont have any will to follow up on it.

[Antihero]

5/23 completed games if you want the exact statistic

that's not rarely

[Antihero]

idk i'll just shut the fuck up now since apparently everything i say is something contentious and offensive and demeaning

[Antihero]

i hope it's not anything i said.

really if you think i think you're stupid or i don't like you or whatever you have it all wrong.

[Antihero]

idk i'll just shut the fuck up now since apparently everything i say is something contentious and offensive and demeaning

Nah, it just seemed like a bizarre, unnecessary and irrelevant comment to make.

>20% seems like a high-ish mislynch rate. someone who's better at statistics than me can run a test (binomial? fuck i don't know i took stats in college 4 years ago and i haven't used it since, i don't remember much) and compare it to random

it's not an insult

it is what is

[Antihero]

i think you're pretty lynchbait-y, dav

[Antihero]

Can't you guys just kiss and make up?

@Anticheety

WHAT DID I DO?

i'm not mad. what is there to make up for?

[Antihero]

i only do that drunk. you have to wait until tonight

[Antihero]

i think you're pretty lynchbait-y, dav

And I disagree. Lynchbait implies consistently being mislynched or scummy in your play. With a lynch rate of around 22%, that is clearly not true.

not getting sucked in

[Antihero]

Seems quite bizarre for you to start a discussion with a predictable conclusion and sequence of events and then decide that you don't want to take part.

you and i obviously have two different definitions of lynchbait

also your pot shots are fucking annoying. stop that.

[Antihero]

it's not a "discussion." it's my opinion, take it or leave it. you want to leave it? fine.

[Antihero]

my other scumread was hiplop in case anyone cared (prob not)

wont be here tonight so i guess ill see you tomorrow. hope im in a better mood then.

[Antihero]

my other scumread was hiplop in case anyone cared (prob not)

i probably wouldn't have guessed that but you're also right that i didn't care so kudos

[Antihero]

why am I a scumread!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

i didnt care for going after reck's post
also didnt care for your absence from the thread last night

[Antihero]

Actually if we could be serious for a moment, let's get a few real votes on Kuroi.

y ?

Guess what everyone I really do think tBonone is scum

y ?

But yeah, Bulge is right

One of the scum has a flee. Leaving someone at L-1 will not end well. L-2 is fine, fear L-1 until we come to a final conclusion.

what is your read on bulge.

Kinda questioning

Got wagoned, little to no reaction even when (they thought) they had reached L-1

etc etc

what does this even mean and how does this lead to you voting bulge?

your question to davsto is kind of already answered b/c he said himself he voted for shits and giggles:

Spoiler:

Did anyone on the Bulge wagon act like it wasn't crap

Because I know I joined it because it was pretty explicitly a silly wagon for giggles and reactions

you're interested in all these other things but you gave my hiplop scumread a i-dont-give-a-shit?
were you making fun of me for being salty or bad or what?

[Antihero]

k fair enough

[Antihero]

why am I a scumread!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

i didnt care for going after reck's post
also didnt care for your absence from the thread last night

when was I absent

late monday night ~p5 to p10

[Antihero]

early game wagoning is scummy?

this is news to me.

[Antihero]

You're requesting a complete read list from me or are you just talking about the wagon? Either way, I'm not interested in creating a list at this time.

i'll settle for why you're throwing shade at the bulge wagon at all

[Antihero]

...and.......?

[Antihero]

you're still not saying why the wagon, or any of its particular occupants, are SCUMMY

you're just spitting out QUICKLYNCH BAD
which.. nobody's arguing.

[Antihero]

ok

now i want you to talk about why ces in particular is scummy here

[Antihero]

ok

now i want you to talk about why ces in particular is scummy here

i don't really think ces has done anything particularly "scummy" per se

but he hasn't said or done anything that looks town

i don't think it's much of a stretch to say he looks the worst among the bulge voters (though i personally think davsto's posts are the worst among the bulge voters)

#answeringquestionsnotdirectedatme

yeah that didn't really speak to what i care about

which is the underlying philosophy of hunting from the bulge wagon in the first place

[Antihero]

i could vote muffin

[Antihero]

VOTE: zmuffinman

oh dear... looks like ive done it...

[Antihero]

VOTE: zmuffinman

oh dear... looks like ive done it...

realistically speaking, what do you think is going to come of this?

not really thinking about that rn

so /shrug

[Antihero]

no idea
it's assuming i'm doing things thinking they'll "come of" something rn

impulsivity is a personality trait and not alignment indicative so it's not a scumhunting question

so... yeah i'm just jerking myself off now. what was the point of that exercise?

[Antihero]

cheet can you please come back? things were a lot better when you were posting. i'm sorry i hurt you. :'(

[Antihero]

also hiplop can you start doing things plz?

[Antihero]

gorkington = cheetory

so you'll hear me call gork "cheet" from time to time

[Antihero]

Obviously from the post below yours, someone is arguing, but you completely missed the point where it's scummy. Because quick lynches gives town a substantially reduced time to find scum, town is unlikely to do their job in finding scum. Something anti-town is inherently pro-scum. Actions that are pro-scum is scummy.

no

to pretty much all of this

but now i dont think you're as scummy as i did before so theres that

[Antihero]

and you understand i really dont care right?

[Antihero]

gork, i'm going back to being crotchety and awful. plz advise.

[Antihero]

NO

ESCALATE

[Antihero]

His early posting rang true with the idea that he's setting himself up to flee.

??????

[Antihero]

update:

tbone
kuroi
gork
kats
zmuff
snarky
johnny
anti

'kay, i'm (mostly) there

could i ask about: tbone, kats, and muffin.

[Antihero]

actually you can do tbone or not. still, kats and muffin i'm curious about.

[Antihero]

viewtopic.php?f=83&t=65526
There ya go.

/sees it's a radja game
/closes out tab

yep, that's a radja game.

[Antihero]

i am so glad this conversation is happening rn

[Antihero]

actually you can do tbone or not. still, kats and muffin i'm curious about.

What's there to be curious about?

why he thinks you're town

[Antihero]

It's just such an unconfident-sounding and ambiguity-filled attempt at scumhunting that I think town would never have made it.

i stopped reading the post there
this sentence is absurd

[Antihero]

because i am a moron.
deal with it.

Maybe in like a 90 page game that's been going on for over a month and there have been several unexpected flips it would look a bit more in place, but on page 3 of a game that's less than 36 hours new it is completely out of place.

I really hope you don't work in any field that requires any sort of depth of analysis or critical thinking, because dropping out of someone's argument because you don't like their introduction, well before you even get to the body of evidence, is generally a sign that you're pretty fucking blinkered.

The last game I was in with Reck we were literally masons together so I feel pretty okay with the arguments I'm making for what Reck is unlikely to do as town if you would care to actually fucking read them

Not to mention the time before that where I knew he had a town PM and was in his team during Team Mafia

Have you and Reck literally ever shared an alignment in a game you played to completion Antihero?

that's the worst kind of meta imo, it's been used on me in this manner, and it's super fucking annoying by people that think they know me when they don't know a goddamn thing. "antihero isn't doing x, he ALWAYS does x as town, OMGZ ROPEZ HIM NOWZ DIE SCUM DIE." people's approaches change over time and sometimes depend on extraneous shit like mood and out of game factors that are impossible to predict or account for. trying to read people off that (ESPECIALLY from one early-game post) is just bad.

i certainly don't think it's inappropriate to not have confident reads on page 3. so yeah, i still don't think that point has much merit.

your point about him being too heavy-handed on the marquis townread might have something to it, but i was thinking the same thing at the time so ... meh. maybe i'm a sucker, but that opening seems pretty ballsy for him to make as scum (and i don't think of marquis as particularly ballsy scum. compare: steven universe where he diddly fucked around in claiming he picked scum.)

[Antihero]

this conversation is productive (enough)

for example, i'm learning that quil probably thinks i'm an idiot and also that i probably actually am an idiot because i'm not articulating what i'm thinking very well or in a way that isn't off-putting

[Antihero]

/sigh

so this is what it feels like to still be sober at 10 at night.

this sucks.

[Antihero]

anti i get the impression you don't feel very confident yourself. what's happening with your reads?

update:

tbone
kuroi
gork
kats
zmuff
snarky
johnny
anti

'kay, i'm (mostly) there

could i ask about: tbone, kats, and muffin.

marquis' townreads minus the ones i'm questioning here are my townreads. (snarky's a marginal case, but i'm throwing him in the townpile rn to preserve sanity and maybe make the game a little easier and give my townhunting a little momentum)

got a few maybe-scumreads bouncing around (way too many considering number of scum): muffin, hippy, bins, bulge. these are all malformed and blegghghghgghghgg

[Antihero]

huh

it's not my birthday for another 3 months

[Antihero]

workin' on it

[Antihero]

isn't bulge+bins a thing?

send her after him

[Antihero]

fantastic mr fox was better than... whatever the hell that thing is.

[Antihero]

it is

this toffee beer is pretty good and its giving me a pleasant mild buzz and lulling me to sleep

[Antihero]

also i dont think traditional scum hunting works in this game unless scum are really bad players and i think the odds of hitting scum with a lynch d1 are (perhaps coincidentally!) the same odds as the least charismatic player in the game rolling scum

really, i don't know if there's anyone who can't fake "scum hunting" for 14 days

maybe if we were in a game where everyone was active and sharing opinions on everything, it'd be harder for scum to hide and/or more likely for them to fuck up somehow, but when has that ever happened in any game ever

was there a point to this?

[Antihero]

town-looking and scummy are subjective and relative terms so 548 means pretty much nothing to me

[Antihero]

you could make 548 and paste it into practically any game on this site just because people in general have fucked up and laughably wrong ideas about what is scummy

[Antihero]

so... don't lazily townread someone just for efforting and being charismatic...?

this is something you should be doing anyway. what is it that we're all trying to psych ourselves out about?

...or is the fatalistic outlook actually helping anything b/c i actually think it's a pretty big drag...

[Antihero]

so playing like you are, i.e. actually not doing anything remotely town but making people think you're town because you put more effort in than other players, is exactly how scum should play this, whereas in another setup, scum may not want to be in the middle of things for one or more reasons

yes, i'm MAKING people do something...?

vote stays

[Antihero]

oh ok i missed the optimal town strategy: don't do anything, bitch and moan about the setup, and... continue to do nothing and go LOLZ DICE ROLLZ at the end

[Antihero]

i'm not sure whether i'm more concerned about zmuff not IDing anti as town, or about anti not being quite as town as i've come to expect

oh goody, i was starting to think the people with annoying expectations about me would EVER arrive

[Antihero]

go away, antihero

even if i gave a shit about your vote on me, i don't really give a flying fuck about your opinion on what i'm saying right now

yeah i know b/c you think you're all that and a bag of chips

[Antihero]

/salty enough to kill a slug

[Antihero]

which is why the way you should be playing the game is going "hey dude what's your opinion on x and why" and having them go "oh hey yeah this is why i think z what about you bro?" and then them going "don't call me bro and also this is why i think a, b and c" and then when we fuck up d1 at least there's something to go on rather than "oh, well, this player actually didn't give a single opinion on like half the game and like half the game didn't give a single opinion on him... great!" but that doesn't work when half the player list is active (and i don't pretend i'm playing optimally right now, either)

that's what we're doing

what are you being such a pill about?

[Antihero]

update:

tbone
kuroi
gork
kats
zmuff
snarky
johnny
anti

'kay, i'm (mostly) there

could i ask about: tbone, kats, and muffin.

actually you can do tbone or not. still, kats and muffin i'm curious about.

here's me

not asking about anything

[Antihero]

this was such a fucking mistake

[Antihero]

as loudly as i bitch and moan about people misreading me, the only thing bothering me is your smarmy bullshit

so over it

[Antihero]

feeling's mutual

happy to oblige

[Antihero]

VOTE: hiplop

[Antihero]

alalalala why can no one seem to get along?

The statement that people nowadays can't seem to get along with anyone with viewpoints that oppose their own appears to be solidly demonstrated in this game...

youre not really helping w the personality conflict

[Antihero]

I'm getting wagonned? Lol?

This happened last time too. I voted scum and everyone piled on me

huh?

[Antihero]

scum in Quil, Dav, CES? Probably only one.

why only one?

[Antihero]

I'm getting wagonned? Lol?

This happened last time too. I voted scum and everyone piled on me

huh?

last fortnite

you voted ces back a while ago way before the wagon built so how is your vote correlated to the wagon?

[Antihero]

I haven't been lynched as scum in like 2 years. Get lynched as town semi often.

Is that clue enough that you guys are seriously off base

i was there for hope+1. this appeal is meaningless.

[Antihero]

The game I was everyone's top town read until I was confscum by setup is a prengood example yea you're right

the brand of aggression i saw in the early game is what initially piqued my suspicion b/c it was reminiscent of hope+1.

i've learned.

why is only one of the pool you named scum? where did you come up with that?

[Antihero]

why does your phone keep correcting "pretty" to "pren"?

what's "pren"?

[Antihero]

Anti is reminding me of TWD. Could be in the other group. Lemme see with that

haha, what?

first off, we've been in two walking deads. from the context, i'm assuming you're taking a swipe at me by saying this is my scum meta, and i'd like to see you justify that

[Antihero]

especially given this post

Marquis I figured out the scumtean literally five minutes afrer zor sent out the p.'s. It wasn't hard. That's why he corrected it so soon, all town members got a PM that was cc'd to each other only names missing were you and muffin.

Anti is probably vably town

[Antihero]

what reminds you of walking dead?

[Antihero]

Hyper aggressive

...

what?

[Antihero]

you were in: butterfly mafia, steven universe prequel, hope+1....

yeah, that's not gonna' fly w/ me.

[Antihero]

Oh yea I forgot butterfly

>_> Okay, revised: not power role related things haven't been lynched in a while as scum (both those were guilties)

but who cares. I'm not scum here. This isn't remotely like my scumgame

i was referring to the fact that using "hyper aggressive" as a scumtell for me is fucking absurd

you can actually add evolution to that list now that that clusterfuck of misery is over.

[Antihero]

i'm waiting for a legit read from you, hippy.

i have yet to see it.

[Antihero]

can whoever the backup mod is please prod snarkysnowman?

he hasn't posted in here since tuesday, but it's not that he's just been not on the site so i'm getting a little weirded out @ that

[Antihero]

hm.... UNVOTE:

let's see another snarky post

[Antihero]

I figured that, being a large game that only lasts two weeks, I'd be struggling to keep up. That doesn't seem to be the case at all.

the fact that you made this post and then disappeared COMPLETELY is really pinging me. if you already knew and acknowledged it would take some effort why would you do that?

[Antihero]

it's not nitpicking

it's an attempt to understand where the appeal is coming from because it doesn't really make that much sense

[Antihero]

/eyeroll at pretty much everything on p33 and 34

[Antihero]

I think both hiplop and dav go in my town pile.

why?

[Antihero]

this is my sunday post

snarky's latest posts displease me very much and i hope he has (a lot) more to accompany them

[Antihero]

still have a few issues w/ hiplop:

1) i have a a very hard time believing he thinks aggression is a scumtell for me AND this game doesn't really bear any resemblance to walking dead 2
2) i hate that he completely dropped the angle once i unvoted him
3) i hate that he's appealing to "gimme' space" when he's had pages and pages of space before the wagon came to be and he was sitting on his ass
4) snarky's departure from the wagon is really sketchy

[Antihero]

Taking a look at Dav/hiplop - I think both are actually feeling townie, but I want to check on that a bit more.

I think both hiplop and dav go in my town pile.

VOTE: quilford

a couple half-assed town reads on two people who just happen to be posting at the time + a quilford vote (????). there's no attempt to actually catch up what's happened in the

4 days

he was gone.

and i dont remember lurking being part of the routine in machina.

[Antihero]

you were not gone and a simple search will tell you that

[Antihero]

Just the certain nature of it. I still am thinking it?

doesn't make the thought any less shitty

and you're not still pushing it. you used it to retaliate and then you dropped it when it didn't serve you any more.

[Antihero]

mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

bullshit

[Antihero]

if you can say "gut" you can outline how this game is similar to walking dead 2 AND how it's dissimilar from walking dead 3 / butterfly / steven universe / whatever else

[Antihero]

VOTE: anti

Town you would understand.

'kay

VOTE: hiplop

[Antihero]

This is exactly the style of aggressiveness from TWD

you're talking out your ass

[Antihero]

Town you wouldn't push this angle, sorry.

back this up

or i'm lynching you

[Antihero]

Butterfly Tammy got a guilty on me? I kept her alive to be nice
Steven universe, setup mechanics proved me as only candidate for scum.
Hope plus one, open game that eventually became an autolose. I asked to forfeit because of the nature of that game

These are irrelevant, but

how is this post germane to anything?

those were all towngames of mine where i'm pretty sure i was "hyperaggressive."

bring this meta read in here

now

[Antihero]

Town you wouldn't push this angle, sorry.

this PROVES you're talking out your ass

it's non-informative and it's shit

[Antihero]

no, i knew you were town b/c you posted legit reads

you're not doing that here

[Antihero]

It is in spurts and he gets disinterested

...ok... you're kneecapping your own point...

[Antihero]

oh ok, i don't think trying to get to the bottom of a read is something outside the bounds of the game, but... alright, i guess that is what it is

[Antihero]

and it doesn't even have to increase the length if you just made ONE quality post about where exactly the meta read is coming from.

right now, what we're doing IS padding the game length b/c the conversation is going like this:

hippy: this is like twd
me: what, how?
hippy: gut
me: nuh uh
hippy: yeah huh
me: nuh uh
hippy: yeah huh

and now we're reeling off umpteen posts when this conversation could have taken place over the course of 3 posts. all you're giving are non-descriptive, curt answers (because somehow, i'm supposed to KNOW something). yeah, i'm not expecting perfection with you reading me (i was there for walking dead 3) but when you just throw out that kind of vague meta read and not elaborate on it, my first thought is that you're doing it just to discredit me.

[Antihero]

VOTE: snarky

the thread avoidance is real

[Antihero]

how are johnny and kuroi still unread?

[Antihero]

and what's the difference between null and unread...?

[Antihero]

that's a pretty ridiculous thing to say

[Antihero]

ok well i'm gonna go stick a pine cone up my ass and go to sleep now

see ya tomorrow afternoon

still waiting on some good stuff from snarky.

[Antihero]

I've just been skimming the last few pages but the issue came up briefly of Snarky's activity

And well

It's pretty null as far as I know. I've modded two games with Snarky

In Werewolves of Miller's Hollow, he was one of two players which required prodding throughout the course of the game, 9th highest number of posts out of 13 players.
SCP Foundation Mafia, required two prods in the first day, was then treestumped and then his activity levels were so low that I ended up prodding him and replacing him despite originally planning not to do that to the treestump. As in, two softprods (PMs telling him without actually counting as prod), the second of which came with a warning that if he didn't post for 3 days he would be prodded and replaced.

Yes, he was town in both of those games.

lurking by itself is null.
lurking while being active elsewhere is not.

further, how is he keeping up with the thread enough to have townreads on davsto and hiplop but nothing on anyone else AND how did bulge make it onto the readslist while johnny and kuroi are still "unread" and what does that even mean?

[Antihero]

Coggy I don't like you anymore.

you don't?

why not?

[Antihero]

if snarky's not scum, i'd probably pick kat as my shot

[Antihero]

Are we doing a Snarky vote then? I'm down.

i am

[Antihero]

annoying antihero

ah, come on man YOU broke up with ME. you can't do that and then say shit like this

[Antihero]

this thread needs more snarky and pv

[Antihero]

and if anyone brings up how lynchbaity snarky is again, i will fucking hate your guts. i'm very well aware (and even joked about it at the beginning of this game) and that's the reason i'm not 100% sold. but in machina, he at least made some attempt at analysis and i thought what he said was pretty reasonable and townish in that game. i don't think he's just bad (if i did, i'd just write him off and shut the hell up). the few things he's posted this game (esp. recently) is just weird and leaves me scratching my nuts.

[Antihero]

i think it was probably more a response to the mod prod

i'm more interested in making sense of his reads list and how he's parsing out nulls from unreads and how he arrived at certain reads.

[Antihero]

/wednesday post

[Antihero]

Well, I'm not going to vote Snarky but I can tell you what I think. There are definitely aspects of his play that are worrying (not antagonizing anyone seems like a good way of avoiding too much scrutiny D1) but on the whole he's really not putting in enough effort to be non-fleeing scum and he doesn't read like he's setting up to flee either, so I'd say he's probably town despite that.

On a related note, Quilford, why have you been ignoring Snarky's vote on you and why did you have him as weak town in #557?

i don't like this post

[Antihero]

i will have you know
that my face is perfectly ok

[Antihero]

ur such a mean girl

[Antihero]

well katsuki never did anything town in the first place so if that's what you're referring to that could account for a good chunk of it

[Antihero]

bins and bulge are really creeping me out

[Antihero]

i could go back to hiplop

everyone stopped breathing down his neck and he's still been doing all of jack shit

[Antihero]

ok what's going on in this hellhole?

[Antihero]

i really just want to get in bed and not leave

for the whole weekend

so we're just limpin to the barn with a pv lynch or what?

[Antihero]

invoking my credential as the guy who read snarky correctly in machina,

i don't think it's good to handwave that off as "the guy who always gets mislynched"

[Antihero]

anti to make a case on snarky.

i can dig up what i already said...?

Spoiler:

this is my sunday post

snarky's latest posts displease me very much and i hope he has (a lot) more to accompany them

still have a few issues w/ hiplop:

1) i have a a very hard time believing he thinks aggression is a scumtell for me AND this game doesn't really bear any resemblance to walking dead 2
2) i hate that he completely dropped the angle once i unvoted him
3) i hate that he's appealing to "gimme' space" when he's had pages and pages of space before the wagon came to be and he was sitting on his ass
4) snarky's departure from the wagon is really sketchy

Taking a look at Dav/hiplop - I think both are actually feeling townie, but I want to check on that a bit more.

I think both hiplop and dav go in my town pile.

VOTE: quilford

a couple half-assed town reads on two people who just happen to be posting at the time + a quilford vote (????). there's no attempt to actually catch up what's happened in the

4 days

he was gone.

and i dont remember lurking being part of the routine in machina.

VOTE: snarky

the thread avoidance is real

ok well i'm gonna go stick a pine cone up my ass and go to sleep now

see ya tomorrow afternoon

still waiting on some good stuff from snarky.

and if anyone brings up how lynchbaity snarky is again, i will fucking hate your guts. i'm very well aware (and even joked about it at the beginning of this game) and that's the reason i'm not 100% sold. but in machina, he at least made some attempt at analysis and i thought what he said was pretty reasonable and townish in that game. i don't think he's just bad (if i did, i'd just write him off and shut the hell up). the few things he's posted this game (esp. recently) is just weird and leaves me scratching my nuts.

i think it was probably more a response to the mod prod

i'm more interested in making sense of his reads list and how he's parsing out nulls from unreads and how he arrived at certain reads.

no, there's not a "case." there's a gut feeling from calling hiplop/davsto tvt and then... nothing since then. it's not clearly defined, but i think anyone not picking up on any weirdness there is pretty oblivious.

and... you know... LURKING WORKED. no one voted him when he disappeared, he never reappeared, but HE'S TOTALLY NOT GOING TO FLEE. i forgot who declared that so authoritatively, but that was fucking dumb.

[Antihero]

probably my next pick after that would be bins.

the bulge read is too clubfooted, next to that (and taking into account the large # of town) the lack of townreads seems faked

[Antihero]

It would be weird for lurkerscum to pull a random ass case on someone like quilford this close to deadline. Snarky can be town.

why?

i'm getting less freaked out by snarky himself and more freaked out by the people townreading him.

[Antihero]

if he's getting ready to flee and wants to leave a bogus evidence trail...?

doesn't take sherlock holmes to think of that

[Antihero]

so vote him

[Antihero]

VOTE: peregrine

[Antihero]

Spoiler:

[Antihero]

my guess is probably wrong but it would be sweet if it was right

[Antihero]

ok that's what i get for being inactive

way to ruin it for everyone

[Antihero]

ARGH I PICKED HIM AND THEN I CHANGED IT BECAUSE I THOUGHT MARQUIS' POST WAS AN ADMISSION

[Antihero]

More votes on PV, please.

why tho? have you made a case? It's hard for me to remember your actions.

While we're at it:

Nos, hip reminds you of half a different town v town in a different game, so he's more likely town than a lurker? Can't necessarily argue that but holy shit if hip flees off this

Kats, what about PV's push was scummy?

Muffy, I dunno, you just don't acknowledge any of the points against hip? or you're just apathetic to everything?

this