@Thor:
Well, I went into the night phase assuming that was the plan, except when I saw SC's card I knew it was a failure. Ok.. we did not "agree", but I "assumed" that was the notion.
Anyway, SC seemed to be pushing KC more, but I'd have to consider the possibility both ARE Cops, in which case SC would -of course- want to lynch the Town/Not Town Cop over the Chaos/Not Chaos one bc he was Mafia not Chaos. Heat was no threat to him anyway even if he was indeed a Cop.
Now it does hit me. Both Heat & MoI can find Chaos (either/or actually. If Chaos are a team then Heat can. If they're a 3rd party then MoI can). neither of them was killed, so it's not a Chaos kill (I'm assuming Chaos does exist by that name). In fact, if there were any 3rd party (by whatever name) capable of killing last night it would've been MoI most likely (he did have an attempt on his life last day phase, right?). unless -of course- they intend to take him out by broad day light today.
So, once again it boils down to "Is there a Chaos? And if there is, are they a team or a single 3rd party?"
My mind keeps playing a trick on me, leading me to contradicting outcomes. KC is the most likely Mafia target. She's not dead. However, she did already did catch one of them, so she can't be one of them herself. Maybe they knew she would be roleblocked last night anyway, so decided she could kill her later? Or maybe they are counting on us to lynch her still? Or maybe she IS one of them, and bussed DS for town!cred?? And if the latter, then why BRO over Wisdom (the other person who proved they could catch Mafia)??
WAIT! BRO was a double-voter AND a vote stealer (Double voter on Goalies). To my knowledge he was the last claimed striker.
I'll check his ISO.
OK, in 1043 he suggested BB/MoI might be town, and in #1597 he restates not wanting to lynch Molla/MoI.
In #1981 he outs his vote stealing ability makes him unlynchable in the final stages of the game, and in subsequent posts he goes on to explain how it works.
He had really bad reads though at the start of the game, but they improved much later on. His first serious vote was on Spiff (#1046). I say "serious bc everything prior to that was class fishing with his double-vote ability.
His second vote was on EII (#1596). His third was spot on though (#1921, voting DS). His vote was moved off DS and put on him (by TWIE??) and he revoted DS on #2099 but it didn't work.
On D2 he straight up voted Max on #2673. On D3 he voted EP (#3227), but unvotes on #3717 pending Heat's response to his question (about Chaos being a faction or an individual). In the following post (#3718) he says he wants to lynch Heat.
On #4021 he was one of the earliest people to suspect SC and even casted a vote on him, but he went back to EP on #4148.
On D4 he went back to his SC push, and he confessed to have redirected EII to investigate Skrew/SC. In #4780 he votes KC, switches to random in #4940, then back on SC in #5014.
OK, so BRO had random (a defender/goalie) in his vision. It makes sense that random would be the one to shoot BRO, given that BRO pursues his previous cases (as shown in his SC case).
It makes sense that random would feel threatened with the double voting ability + 2 remaining vote stealing shots, totaling BRO's voting ability on him to 4 votes (L-2).
VOTE: randomidget
Now let's see: MoI was most suspicious of random. Heat had him as null. Wisdom wants him lynched. KC's reads I have no recollection of, but she did vote him to save her neck. Finally, SC put him as a scum lean but not his top scum read. In fact, SC wanted to imply BRO, Heat & KC were the scum.
Wait. let me rephrase my case (in addition to the above reasoning which suggests he might've shot BRO):
Check his responses in
727
Also in
266 and
751 he explicitly points out multiball, and with 6 investigative claims I cannot think of another role that could also imply that except for a framer who can make people look guilty.
His votes on D1 were on EP, EII, BRO, Heat, DDO/Thor & ZZZX.
On D2 he voted he only voted Max, and only when it became apparent Max was going down.
On D3 he voted only EP and stayed on him until the end.
On D4 he voted SC, KC
In
4083 he suggested the vigging of TWIE (who, according to Wisdom is town)
Upon SC's lynch, SC never voted random eventhough he knew his voted would counted for TWO and he could've saved himself. I take it that he knew he was scum read by many investigatives though so he didn't want to take down his scum buddy. Random did vote SC and I take it that was for town cred, bc even after that SC specified Heat, KC & BRO for scum and didn't mention random. The wagon did include RJ (obv!town), Wisdom (obv!town), TWIE (conf!town according to Wisdom investigation) and Nahdia (obv!town) so he could not have included any of them.
The one and only problem is still why he favoured the kill of BRO over investigatives? Wisdom's role is unclear. MoI is looking for 3rd party, so can't catch Mafia. Heat is looking for Chaos, so can't catch Mafia. KC is the only one who can catch Mafia and she was blocked anyway. So, even if we chose to believe all investigative claims to be true, BRO's potential 4-votes ability would've been the most threatening element in the immediate time.
Well, that might be true. I don't know that though. It's my first game with you. However, I did play many games with RC and I know he can make a push out of thin air, and he usually is spot on too (I don't recall ever playing with scum!RC though, so maybe that's why, but from what I've learned from him he also busses hard as scum).
