Amnesiac Mafia: The Very First Edition (Game Over Already?)

[Firebringer]

I am lynch immune.

Specifically first lynch on me fails.
Not sure if it resets the vote count or if night starts

Tbone hasn't gotten back to me

[Firebringer]

I'd totally be willing to lynch myself if it doesn't end day, just waiting to hear from tbone

[Firebringer]

VOTE: T-Bone

[Firebringer]

At the conclusion of the first Day Phase, players who have post counts that are significantly variable from the median post count will be punished by being given the Hated modifier for the following Day Phase. I will be using Median Absolute Deviation to calculate this.

Rip alisae

[Firebringer]

We don't want town targetting us with night actions.
Usually, a commuter claim screams "Don't target me."

Why did you ask why we claimed?
-Ali

Bad question

[Firebringer]

Maria doesn't say hi to me?
Rudeness.

Can someone give me a day vig to use on her?

[Firebringer]

I am lynch immune.

Specifically first lynch on me fails.
Not sure if it resets the vote count or if night starts

Tbone hasn't gotten back to me

Has he gotten back to you yet?

I actually just lied, I don't have that role at all.

Didn't really get any useful reactions besides Ircher, who I kind of enjoyed pushing his buttons a bit.

[Firebringer]

is horrible at hiding his win condition everyone sees his hand clearly:

Jester: You win when the Party goers lynch you.

[Firebringer]

Town so far are Ircher and Podoboq.

[Firebringer]

After doing a re read I don't know how I feel about fire's gambit I feel if it was anyone else I'd have voted him but it being fire I can see him doing it as town or scum what I don't get is why pod auto tr's it want to hear more from him given I just dislike that entrance post a lot. RR feels town while I disagree with a few of his statements I think he's trying to solve the game and believe what he say's Dreal worries me just for the simple fact I don't want to PL him yet, KidAmn's tone sadly feels like town the person I want to look at though is Klazam in his 9 posts he's just asking questions with a few shade posts I also feel the need of "Oh I was away for so long so this is why I'm asking" is overly explained because it doesn't really need to be there so with that.

VOTE: Klazam

Is this the elusive town mariar?

WHERE IS MY OLD ANTI TOWN MARIAR!
WHAT DID YOU DO WITH HER!?!?!?!?!?

[Firebringer]

is horrible at hiding his win condition everyone sees his hand clearly:

Jester: You win when the Party goers lynch you.

Are you claiming Jester?

If so, are you Jester alignment, or are you town with an Amnesiac Jester role card until the beginning of day two?

Also, what?

No, that was really a joke.
I can't tell if you are being serious with this question tbh.

[Firebringer]

WHAT DO YOU MEAN ANTI TOWN MARIA YOU ASS....

don't yell at me for the truth.
i also kind of feel you tried to hard in that post, but you know. Still think it's a bit townie.

[Firebringer]

Now I can't try hard early in a game hm?
Pedit: How do you feel about my meta read on you dreal you don't seem bothered and that seems a bit OOC for you.

You can totally try hard early, I said I townread you for it, and just noted how its "different than usual", which can be good or bad.

What if I told you that I am scum and I know you are town so I am buddying you?

[Firebringer]

I'd believe you why?

Just wondering what you would think. Your reaction still feels townie? Not certain.
I should really ask more questions in which I know how you would react if you were town or scum instead of just questions just to see if i can get a natural reaction. I don't know what a natural reaction from you is that much...

those not familiar with Fb so much, he often does this "I'm scum" repetitious shit, as either alignment, right now he has me leaning scum at him for it, a little more over-the-top for how early the game is, like he REALLY wants to be TR for claiming scum

Am I that predictable?

Fine ill claim town for the rest of the game, that is so boring though.

I am Town.

Hardclaim

[Firebringer]

I mean I did put in big letters, green color, and centered that I was town.
So, yeah. It was pretty "LOOK AT ME I AM SO TOWN".

Thank you for pointing that out, it was what i was going for.

I am TOWN

bolded and underlined.

[Firebringer]

Town (Ircher, Podohoq)
Lean Town (MariaR, WhemeStar)
Scum Lean (Drealmerz)
Not really scum but i scumread them all the time so i have to put them in this scum bracket (Alisae)

[Firebringer]

Stop fixing my shit LUV.
I am putting you in the exclusive bracket "IS THE ANNOYING TECH SUPPORT GUY (LUV)"

[Firebringer]

Town (Ircher, Podohoq)
Lean Town (MariaR, WhemeStar)
Scum Lean (Drealmerz)
Not really scum but i scumread them all the time so i have to put them in this scum bracket (Alisae)

Why those tr's? Both haven't been towny to me at all and in fact I sr Pod enlighten me

I have experienced podo play recently, this doesn't feel scummy at all from him.
Ircher I think believes what I did is scummy and is hammering me for it.

Wheme speaks seems to be speaking his mind without constraint which i townread.

As for you! You feel townie. All I got for you.

[Firebringer]

Maria isn't my scumbuddy, but sure lets lynch Drealmerz:

VOTE: Drealmerz

[Firebringer]

I know, I am town just like I claimed.

[Firebringer]

it's not like I'll be lynched D2 if I live until D2 anyway, so having hated on D2 won't really hurt me methinks, so I'm not worrying about it, and trying to make more content for more ppl to post more and feel comfortable making some more posts, but, participation is likely to die off shortly if ppl don't get their butts in gear, I can't do all the work all of the time, damnit

You think you will be night killed this game or that you will get lynched?
And why?

[Firebringer]

hows life been for you klazam?

[Firebringer]

@Klazam Thats good to hear, i think last time i played with you i was living in another state. What you been up to?

[Firebringer]

I don't know in what specifically you are talking when you say "stuff", if you mean fake claiming, then claiming scum, then hard claiming town. Thats all stuff I do when I am bored and trying to entertain myself.

If you think I am doing it to benefit my win condition I don't see why you think it would benefit me either way?

[Firebringer]

yo thinkbig, your slot is townie. don't let it down.

also drealmerz is scummy, you should vote him.

[Firebringer]

I don't know in what specifically you are talking when you say "stuff", if you mean fake claiming, then claiming scum, then hard claiming town. Thats all stuff I do when I am bored and trying to entertain myself.

something something boy who cried wolf. stahp.

vote dreal

shameless remove-the-deadwood vote

Fite me big boy

[Firebringer]

Actually dreal, I've played with ya twice iirc. And probably lurked other games too.

Road Kamelot is my alt

. I'm bringing the Puckett back is all.

:O
:O
:O
:O
:O
:O
:O
:O
:O

[Firebringer]

I feel so lied to.....
how many games have you been in mine by secret?!?!?!

[Firebringer]

And Fire. So many games. So many.

WHY!?!?!??!?!?!?!?!

[Firebringer]

Fire: Actually no, I totally did! It's just I didn't remember bc we only really got to know each other once I was Road. No hard feelings

I kind of have hard feelings tbh.

[Firebringer]

gonna ignore firebringer/other lynchbait because otherwise ill just get distracted and tunnel

There was about three different responses I had for this specific post, but then I deleted them all. And I decided to put in something trolly instead:

Come at me bro!

[Firebringer]

Spoiler: not game related

Fire, don't tell me you're serious.

I mean I am upset because idk, I thought we were friends and you have like all these past games with me and idk, kind of feels weird now.

Maybe I am being stupid. But I am definitely feel like you could have told me about this earlier?
I don't know why you had to tell me about it, but not sure why you didn't either.

fjalkdjflkasfjlksadhglaksjdglasdj;gasdjlkfsad

is how i feel.

[Firebringer]

I don't like a pod wagon anymore I liked his answers to my questions they made since given his other posts, The reason I asked you about klaz is he is my biggest scumread at the moment for things already explained...That people seemed to ignore you dicks ;~:

Why is only one eye crying?

WHO HURT YOU MARIA!!!!
I WILL FIND THEM!

[Firebringer]

I claim Budweiser

I prefer a corona but budweiser is still pretty good, just not any of that bud light shit.

[Firebringer]

I can be your sound board this game UT

[Firebringer]

I can be your sound board this game UT

okay cool you can be a good Titus sub for the moment

so what do you think about this weird Firebringer gambit bullshit?

oh wait

It's stupid, we should policy lynch him

[Firebringer]

Is LUV going to share any of that popcorn.

[Firebringer]

correct me if I'm wrong but MC voted you and I don't remember you hardcore going for MC before he did vote you did you even read the post game after?

This is what happened.

[Firebringer]

Dreal I just think your scum, if it makes you feel better

[Firebringer]

I either have to think you're horrible or scum, maria, I don't think you're this horrible actually, so I go with scum

Fb, why do you think I'm scum?

Your behavior up until Maria seemed fake and not geniune. I think you and Maria thing was also NAI

[Firebringer]

LUV is probably town

[Firebringer]

Alisae why is Titus townreading me?

[Firebringer]

Alisae why is Titus townreading me?

[Firebringer]

I have a 90% confidence that dramonic is town.
Good feels.

Dramonic, why you think I am scum?

[Firebringer]

I don't have enough scumreads.
Someone help

[Firebringer]

Maxwell want to share a PT with me?

[Firebringer]

Me too, I am townreading you two and I am scared.

[Firebringer]

lol UT is not scummy this game

[Firebringer]

I can see fire being scum too if Untrod is scum

Why only if he is scum?

[Firebringer]

Care to explain that?

This literally is just how UT plays and so far nothing from his scummy.
I'd say it's more his "I give no Fucks cause I am Town"

[Firebringer]

I can see fire being scum too if Untrod is scum

Why only if he is scum?

I mean I see you as a possible partner if he is. From my experience you hard defend your partners

I wouldn't call that hard defense right there but sure, I lately tend to hard defend allies.

[Firebringer]

How much sense does it make for someone to play like they don't care what happens but then enforce a policy lynch. Shouldn't they be the policy lynch then

No....that's not how people operate...

[Firebringer]

I have pushed stupid lynches that are viewed policy when I didn't care about the game....almost always as Town.
In fact scum aren't very likely to do policy lynches or advocate them..

Your not making much sense in your line of thinking. And I am tired

[Firebringer]

In theory they are for it, in practice they don't.

[Firebringer]

hey maria chan

[Firebringer]

hey maria chan

PUPPY <3

i want a hug friendo.

[Firebringer]

maria lets vote block today.

[Firebringer]

VOTE: Kidamn

[Firebringer]

Firebringer does an aside:
"What she doesn't realize is that I am trying to get her to buddy me. I have her eating out of my hands"

[Firebringer]

just that you are cute and that i want to hug you forever.

[Firebringer]

who would you prefer we vote for maria chan?

[Firebringer]

UT wagon is shit.

[Firebringer]

thats me on most days tbh

[Firebringer]

UT, remember when you believed i was a traitor?
Priceless

[Firebringer]

Someone give me a good reason not to replace out of this game.

[Firebringer]

V/LA till Sunday

[Firebringer]

VOTE: ThinkgBig

[Firebringer]

VOTE: ThinkBig

[Firebringer]

VOTE: T-Bone

[Firebringer]

Now considering Fire.

Please do, faster I get out of this game the faster i can quit mafia.

[Firebringer]

VOTE: Firebringer

[Firebringer]

I don't think that's going to be anytime soon. Scum hunting and playing to draw a night kill will do just that. Voting yourself according to your claim won't. Which begs the question, if you're quitting mafia, why haven't you asked to be replaced?

You ISOed me and missed the part where i retracted my claim?

Nice job LUV.

I haven't replaced out because T-Bone already had plenty of replacements. My suffering comes second to the mods.

[Firebringer]

and I could be like a Macho Cop and still the scum wouldn't night kill me so lol.

[Firebringer]

It's cool luv I missed my retraction too, and I thought my TB vote was scummy too

[Firebringer]

Don't know what that means

[Firebringer]

How is my reads bs

Have you taken a look at your Vecna case lately?

Vecna's reads are trash

You are in my head

[Firebringer]

Gary oak!
My pokemaster is here!

Help me defeat my enemies, sir!

[Firebringer]

Gary oak!
My pokemaster is here!

Help me defeat my enemies, sir!

These posts. I'm trying to play catchup and read and learn and such and then...

*An absolute shitposter appears*
*He uses "waste Fresh's fucking eyes and brain with garbage unrelated to game"*
*It's super fucking effective*

I see you embrace my insanity

[Firebringer]

game shitposting then complain about Inherent Scum Advantage - the 2017 meta.

Hmmmm u are an alt I guess

[Firebringer]

What's up fellas

[Firebringer]

No, not really tbh

[Firebringer]

Who should I vote for?
Not fedora or luv

[Firebringer]

VOTE: Kuroi

[Firebringer]

My wagon is firebringer approved

[Firebringer]

Your both wrong, the correct shot is all the scum

[Firebringer]

Your both wrong, the correct shot is all the scum

What you want do is aim the gun so it goes through all scum at same time, the last scum dies of a infection.
#Rango

[Firebringer]

I think ur overselling your likeness of death a bit

[Firebringer]

Large themes need more D1 vecna sheeping. I have a feeling im not gonna live through the night.

Guess Ill need to improve my chances by fullclaiming.

[Firebringer]

Lamist is a gross term

[Firebringer]

Why would they lie about being commuter regardless of alignment?

[Firebringer]

Wait did Titus or Alisae claim commuter?
That's important

[Firebringer]

okay thing here- if youre VT equalivent, it is actually good play to draw the nightkill. why are you concerned with living?

FB, yes fedora did.

No I mean which head claimed it....

[Firebringer]

You'll get to answer that question at a later time, if it turns out they were lying. Theres a bunch of reasons I could come up with, but its not an interesting discussion right now id say.

Lets move on again before this devolves into 10 pages of useless conversation about another fringe-claim-that-probably-wont-do-shit

I claim cop

[Firebringer]

Okay it's real.
If it was Titus I'd be less inclined to believe it

[Firebringer]

so lol i have a guilty.

[Firebringer]

@Titus, No we lynch my guilty.
@Wheme good town reaction.
@MaxWellPucket I MISSED YOU! How are you!?!

[Firebringer]

Yesterday I was a

Macho Cop!

There is zero reason for me not to out this information.

I checked Untrod Tripod

because while I thought he was townie during the day, when I looked at the fucking vote count, I knew that looked like a bussing vote. I was hoping it would just clear my suspicions, but no,

He isn't a Party Goer!

VOTE: Untrod Tripod

[Firebringer]

I feel like i trust Fedora too much, and last time they were scum i did that. but fuck it. I need to trust alisae more.

[Firebringer]

Lol so you say UT is a miller of sorts and doesn't claim it day one?

You going to tell me this is UTs first mafia game next?

[Firebringer]

Also, I dont need no wifom to keep firebringer a potential lynch for later. He was trying to stop the lynch on LUV, that is all the reason I need. Outing a guilty on someone that might not be even scum does nothing to stop any potential lynches on him in the future.

This is why I like vecna, just speaks truths

[Firebringer]

Lol so you say UT is a miller of sorts and doesn't claim it day one?

You going to tell me this is UTs first mafia game next?

This is UTs first mafia game

Should have known, thanks wheme

[Firebringer]

Can modifiers rotate as well?

[Firebringer]

Ideally considering all roles rotate, we should probably claim each day for accountability purposes, especially what our previous role was.

[Firebringer]

the macho part was a passive part of role pm and active part was cop.
my role was literally called "amnesiac macho cop"

[Firebringer]

i am kind of thinking passives and actives can pass to different people.
that means UT wasn't a miller.

My guilty is accurate.

[Firebringer]

I don't think so. Macho Cop is a standard role to prevent Follow the Cop, isn't it? What are the odds that you got that D1 by pure chance?

as far as i know the original role group wasn't randomed at all.
meaning macho + cop was originally intended to be a day 1/night 1 thing.

but that doesn't mean it was meant to stay that way.

[Firebringer]

if the scum roles don't rotate, the role cop is officially op. And you can PoE players based on what their claims are and how their roles never get rotated to anyone.
Its almost like setup making 101 not to make something breakable by claiming, so yes, scum roles have to rotate lol

[Firebringer]

Until UT comes in here to talk about his role yesterday, I feel like tabling all setup discussion

[Firebringer]

I didn't think he was scum

[Firebringer]

Thats....rather undramatic and unfun

Arent we all.

[Firebringer]

I don't know what kind of answer you expected lol

[Firebringer]

So you think this makes UT confirmed town? How?

[Firebringer]

No
You can be telling the truth and just being a major league fool
iirc Fire did that in The Thing

Jackass

[Firebringer]

I am lynching UT, lol no one forgets they have negative utility that hurts Town and doesn't announce it day one.
It sounds like his role is confirmed but I don't see it that meaning he is confirmed town.

[Firebringer]

maria, get in here so i can give you hugs!

[Firebringer]

Sent this to T-Bone and he wants an actual question with the question mark and everything. Someone make this happen for me, please.

I've seen lazy, but to lazy to ask a question?
Thats stoner level laziness.

"I have a question, teacher"
"What is your questions?"
"Ummmmm i forgot, does anyone remember what i was going to ask?!?"

[Firebringer]

@Maria

[Firebringer]

So UT is just going to continue on with "didn't read my role pm"?

[Firebringer]

That's not what it means lol

[Firebringer]

Vecna I personally think you and me probably can't just agree on stuff so like, I don't know how to progress with interacting with you.
I could go super charismatic route here, but I am super lazy right now, but I think it's better I just ignore your posts.

All they do lately is make me eye roll, and I don't mean it in insulting way, I just don't agree with stuff you say 70% of the time.

[Firebringer]

So like you do you man, and I'll just not comment cause I got nothing positive to say about it

[Firebringer]

I actually thinking about replacing out again because I am just not in the mood to actually play this game again.

My voice to be heard would require me spending long time gathering up stuff to make sure my thoughts are understood and then individually convince people to follow them.

It's just not in me.
I just want to sheep more than lead but I hate we aren't pursuing my guilty here.

When this day opened I was like "yes we will lynch UT, he flips scum. I am NK, and I can finally take my long deserved break from mafia"

Now again I am a suspect for being scum because "all too happy to reveal a fake quilty" my quilty is now "confirmed town"

Like can someone tell me why the fuck I should play this stupid game?

[Firebringer]

I don't care your suspicious of me one bit.
I care that you because you are suspicious of me I am going to be strung up to be mislynch bait at fucking day six or some shit.

If you think I am scum right now, vote me, I don't want to be in this game.
I 100% want to be out of this game before day 4.

Otherwise I will blow up, make an ass of myself, make everyone miserable.

Like this is repeat problem with me in larges.
You telling me I am suspicious and not voting to lynch me right now pisses me the fuck off.

Because you deny me being a night kill target and set me up to be a mislynch bait. Fuck that.

[Firebringer]

Also, the mechanics side of this game actually makes my inner mechanics nerd all kinds of happy. Solving these sort of puzzles is what makes mafia interesting for me. As a designer of setups yourself, id have expected a similair interest in interesting setups from you as well.

I don't do heavy setup deconstruction because as a mod I put in things to make it hard for that to be done.
It's much easier to do that in later stages and requires knowledge of mod to know how they would design it.

All of these are things I could do if I wanted but I don't prefer it from regular scum hunting.

[Firebringer]

It would be cool if people would just lie and say I was confirmed town so scum have reason to night kill me tbh.
You know as a parting gift for my last game.

If I am here day three I am replacing out.
You can call that strategic if you want, but I am not staying in to be mislynch bait.

[Firebringer]

If I didnt have a reasonably strong townread on rat id be right there alongside you trying to string up UT.

I think rat is town too.

I just think UT was a Scum Miller.
Troll role? Yes but it makes perfect sense to me

[Firebringer]

Fire your confirmed town

Thanks

[Firebringer]

So fire, if you think UT actually had the role that rat describes, is your suspicion that were all just wrongly assuming how your cop would interact with those mechanics? Because if you believe rat, and you believe that UT did have that role on D1, then shouldnt you actually assume that UT is town?

I dont think I understand your logic here where you TR rat, but not UT.

I think UT isn't a idiot.
I think UT would read his role pm.
I think UT had Miller as scum but didn't think much of claiming it because scum.
I think Rat probably is town.

[Firebringer]

I also think his vote luv was a buss

[Firebringer]

I haven't been reading his posts lately tbh

[Firebringer]

Maybe I am being stubborn on UT here.
UNVOTE:

I'll take a few day break.

V/LA till Friday

[Firebringer]

This is a terrible plan and yall should feel terrible.

i don't tho.

[Firebringer]

i hate doing this and i really wanted to play with some of you, but yeah.
I don't have energy for this game for i don't know how long it will go on for.

I am done for mafia at this time, i wish you all the best of luck.

Go town!

@Mod: Please replace me. I am sorry about this.

[Firebringer]

Titus/Alisae, I hope you both are town. Hate getting tricked by you two >.>
MaxWell, get on skype more often so we can talk!
garryoak, you smell and you don't give me enough treats
mariar, can't buddy you anymore, you will have to find a new puppy.

[Firebringer]

i will miss you maria san <3

[Firebringer]

Ohno, UT was scum and not confirmed town. Who could have predicted this course of events?

Maybe the mod