First 10 pages:
18/
22 Early reads from Bell feel a little too premature, I know it's RVS and everything is nonsense but it feels like tossing these things out early is an atempt to get townread for early sorting rather than anything genuine.
38/
40/
42/
49 Reaction to being voted on page 2 is also pretty poor. Feels an entirely disproportionate response.
54 Didn't care for Iconeum "scumreading RQS" from mr sandman when they expressed it's part of their style but 64's suspicion of Bell matched my own thoughts at that point in time.
67 Don't much see why Tanner says giving a read then walking it back 14 minutes later is more likely to be genuine.
Like
88 from Mr Sandman, didn't feel Bell's early confidence matched the self-deprecation.
On a gut level like the energy from DGB's
97.
Bell's accusation of Dunnstral in
99 for unvoting is particularly nonsensical, don't see why unvoting there makes him scum at all and Dunn's explanation is reasonable. Have no idea why Bell is garnering townreads.
Tanner says he has less reads than he usually does in
136, but dodges actually naming any specific ones. Don't like this.
The sarcastic edge is DGB's
138 looks town to me or at least doesn't remind me of her as scum.
Akarin asking Uncrowned how POE factors into his reads in
143 on page 6 doesn't make sense or feel like a natural though process. Would anyone believe in working off POE from such an early point in the game? Why ask that?
147 also looks like busywork, don't see any reason to be drawing a connection between ABR and DGB other than his comment on their join dates, ABR gives a one word answer and Akarin never follows up.
On the other hand, I find
149 where Tanner openly admits he feels uninspired townish because he was facing no pressure at that point in time.
Don't like Akarin's
177 - is stretchy reasoning scummy coming from a new player? I feel as though a newbie is more likely to try to force arguments.
I'm biased by hindsight but don't care for DGB voting Rosé for roleplaying in
184.
188/
189/
190 from Mr Sandman give strong newbtown vibes.
Why was Akarin going out of her way to defend Rosé? It's not like she couldn't have done it herself.
Like the way Hiraki is interrogating Akarin on page 9.
Gamma Emerald's entrance toward the bottom of page 10 is fine.
Dunn is toward the filler side, looking back on him since nothing stuck out to me, and maybe slightly scummy but I'm wary from having misread him in the past.
Town reads:
Mr Sandman, Hiraki, Tanner, DrippingGoofball
Null:
Gamma Emerald, Iconeum, JohnnyFarrar
Scum reads:
Bell, Akarin, Dunnstral