In post 109, Otolia wrote:Can you please play along. I have something in mind and since you consider me as town, you have no reasons not to state your House Name and any kind of flavor that does not reveal your role.
You being town and you being correct are two *wildly* different concepts.
In post 110, David Xanatos wrote:
Magua > Given that SK and Otolia have/had an issue that actually arose in the signup thread, it was perfectly reasonable in my eyes that, had he drawn the role, he'd do something like that to spite Otolia. I fail to see how my reaction to the potential waste of what could have been one of our strongest assets is bad.
I've already stated the reasons that I don't think your reaction was town. Flipflop on the your reaction of the kill ending the day or not, along with the outright "you just became today's lynch" rather than waiting to see what Otolia's flip was going to be.
JDGA wrote:
2) I didn't see any reason to believe that SK's fakekill wasn't a real daykill at the time.
# of "Daykill: X" posts I have seen in, oh, the first 5 pages of a game: 6
# of *real* daykills I have seen in the first 5 pages of a game: 0
Now, given that your join date is 2007, my counterquestion to you is, "Why did you think it *was* real daykill?"
JDGA wrote:1) So your reads on David and Otolia don't really make sense, as it wasn't obvious at all that the daykill was a fake. SK's gambit wasn't exactly a gambit so much as just stupid, and obviously I disagree with your read on me due to the fact that I said I was going to make a votecount for myself.
I have no read on you. I found what you said to be odd. See also: tclawren calling SK third party.
JDGA wrote:3) Why are you so certain that the scum are traitors as opposed to a separate House altogether? It's not that difficult for them to lie about which House they are v_v
I'm not certain, hence usage of the word "suspect."
JDGA wrote:When you recall that scum can daytalk, and your apparent knowledge of "obvious" information that wasn't obvious at all (see points 2 and 3), I'm starting to very strongly doubt your alignment. My vote stays, however, as you're much less likely to be scum if SK isn't also scum.
Loyalist meaning town is obvious. Find someone other than David Xanatos who doesn't think it is. As for your calling my setup suspicions scummy, that's fine; you assuming SK's daykill was real until proven otherwise with a 2007 join date is scummy in return.