Killer: WindSlicer
I like those choices of yours, Fritz.
But then, as the town, it is better to kill those who have already killed, since according to your logic they've already killed. So if they haven't killed yet, they aren't likely until they can get a goon.Yosarian2 wrote:Not WIFOM at all. It's simply that we've been using the statagy of "let's make one of the "unconfirmed" kill another", and so if your primary goal is to not be killed (which would be the Godfather's primary goal right now) then the logical thing to do would be to quickly get yourself "confirmed" as a non-goon, probably by killing someone.TSAGod wrote: ...and WIFOM, Yosarian. WIFOM.
It's not a matter of WIFOM; it's a matter of figuring out what the logical move of the other side would be.
(shrug) It's possible my post may have changed the path of the game so that it's no longer the best stratagy for the Godfather to roam the streets blowing away random townies. If so, then, good.TSAGod wrote: But then, as the town, it is better to kill those who have already killed, since according to your logic they've already killed. So if they haven't killed yet, they aren't likely until they can get a goon.
RangeroftheNorth wrote:I'm more along the lines of just do whatever you want. You can forget the please don't kill me part. If you want to kill me go ahead. I'm going to play this game the way I want. I recognize that it will probably get me killed, but I'm going to enjoy it more. You want to look for the godfather? Day 1, Fritzler kills the first post. That, to me, is who is most likely the godfather. The reason I killed was because it was clear to me that my opinion wasn't going to be taken seriously by the (then) 2 most active players until I had. I felt that it was better for the more active players to make kills because then cops wouldn't waste investigations on them. I still think I'm right, and that I was right to make a kill when I did, if you disagree, feel free to shoot me.
I've mentioned I think Ranger is the GF before, right?Yosarian2 wrote:RangeroftheNorth wrote:I'm more along the lines of just do whatever you want. You can forget the please don't kill me part. If you want to kill me go ahead. I'm going to play this game the way I want. I recognize that it will probably get me killed, but I'm going to enjoy it more. You want to look for the godfather? Day 1, Fritzler kills the first post. That, to me, is who is most likely the godfather. The reason I killed was because it was clear to me that my opinion wasn't going to be taken seriously by the (then) 2 most active players until I had. I felt that it was better for the more active players to make kills because then cops wouldn't waste investigations on them. I still think I'm right, and that I was right to make a kill when I did, if you disagree, feel free to shoot me.
Interesting. You think Fritzler is most likely to be Godfather? If so, why did you not mention your suspicion until just now?
From reading this, it appears that the GF will appear guilty to investigations...so I don't think we need to do that until we're out of cops...but I'm not sure.Godfather Role wrote:You are the mafia godfather. The goons are x, y, and z. Each night you may talk with your team and decide who to kill. You also have the ability to post in the thread kill: player. This will immediately cause the target to die and the day to end. You win when there is only mafia left..
I've played with BJ enough to know that if he was a cop he wouldn't die without giving us some clue about who he investigated. That post appears to be the only indication of such.Cogito Ergo Sum wrote:But that one post did state "just based on their current posting", which suggests that he did not investigate them.
I agree that it is very unlikely for them to both be mafia, but I could see one of the two as being mafia. After all BJ was a pretty obvious kill for the scum. Confirmed innocent, acting a lot like a cop. I'd have considered those two as real suspects if BJ hadn't been killed.