Bad Idea Mafia - Game Over

[TSAGod]

Wow...

FOS: Baby Jesus

for not killing anybody yet.

Really...with no voting, this game is pretty much a game of chance, and a FOS of vote system will pretty much do nothing, as not everybody will go for it.

It'd probably be a better deal to have cops claim when they get a guilty, and then go from there.

[BabyJesus]

Wow...

FOS: Baby Jesus

for not killing anybody yet.

Really...with no voting, this game is pretty much a game of chance, and a FOS of vote system will pretty much do nothing, as not everybody will go for it.

It'd probably be a better deal to have cops claim when they get a guilty, and then go from there.

[BabyJesus]

And here I am trying to behave.....

[Yosarian2]

Really...with no voting, this game is pretty much a game of chance, and a FOS of vote system will pretty much do nothing, as not everybody will go for it.

Why do you assume that? If a stratagy will help the town, then why wouldn't all pro-town people go along with it?

I mean, there might be some extreme situation where you would be so sure person X was scum you'd be willing to ignore the system and kill someone anyway, but if you do that on your own without getting approval from the town first, you had BETTER be right.

[Muzta]

[q]If the town keeps doing stuff like that, we're not going to win, because we're not going to have any way to figure out who the scum are.
_________________[/q]

Actually Stastically I think we have an excellent chance of winning by that route

[armlx]

BabyJesus = town

Pooky = Mafia

I = dead tonight

1 cop down. The next 2 have to trade one for one with mafia

[Fritzler]

Man, I wish I could use my kill right now.

[inHimshallibe]

Kill: Pooky

Yay!

And <3 Fritzler.

[Fritzler]

<3 IN HIM

[armlx]

You dids a great jord there inhim (or something like that).

Following are not goons:
Inhim
Fritzler
BabyJesus

Therefore you other 2 cops should not investigate these people.

[BabyJesus]

You dids a great jord there inhim (or something like that).

Following are not goons:
Inhim
Fritzler
BabyJesus

Therefore you other 2 cops should not investigate these people.

[SpeedyKQ]

Pooky the goon has been daykilled by inHimshallibe.

Night falls. 72 hours for choices.

[SpeedyKQ]

You awaken to find that

armlx the cop has been shot.

20 players remain. 1 bullet to kill.

No killing for inHim or Fritzler for the next 24 hours.

[Thoth]

Wow I can actually post in this game

[VisMaior]

I know Im dead for 2 days now. but I wanted to have at least 1 post in here. Otherwise I cant relate to this game, emotionally... [/hijack]

[Thoth]

Where did armlx get it that BJ is not a goon? He has not killed yet. In his case making it more likely that he is a goon. I'd suggest letting him do the killing today.

Would be happy to get Cogito Ergo Sum. His post is a little of in my opinion.

[BabyJesus]

Where did armlx get it that BJ is not a goon? He has not killed yet. In his case making it more likely that he is a goon. I'd suggest letting him do the killing today.

Would be happy to get Cogito Ergo Sum. His post is a little of in my opinion.

he's a cop. He investigated me, and got innocent. That means I am not a goon. I could be godfather, true, but not a goon. If you REALLY need further proof, who should I kill?

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Armlx investigated BabyJesus, he came up innocent and therefore BJ isn't a goon.

[Thoth]

Ah, ok. Missed his first investigation.

[BabyJesus]

So right now we have fritzler, inHim, and BabyJesus confirmed not goon. I think someone not confirmed should do the daykill.

Further, I think the killer AND the target should be setup by one of our "confirmed"

(Confirmed in quotes because all 3 of us could still be the godfather. Just not a goon.)
Two of the reds need to be our shooter and victim.

Beaker
Cogito Ergo Sum
Coron
darquiel
d_rouge
Monty
Muzta (replacing PBug)
NanookTheWolf
RangeroftheNorth
Sineish
SinisterOverlord
the silent speaker
This is not me
Thoth
TSAGod
WindSlicer
Yosarian2

BabyJesus
Fritzler
inHimshallibe

[BabyJesus]

just based on current postings, I think TINM and Yosarian2 are clean. I'd like to see Mutza be one of the two to shoot/be shot.

[inHimshallibe]

Of course, waiting a day to see if a cop might reveal a scum to us could help too...

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

We shouldn't make the kill before we are sure no cop will reveal the identity of one of the goons, absolutely. But we might as well start discussing who will kill who today if no cop reveals himself.

I agree with BJ's suggestion to let the "confirmed" make the eventual decision on who to kill and who to let kill.

[d_rouge]

Wow, I finally get to post!

I don't know if there's a breaking strategy for this game. Up to now, I haven't been able to come up with one.

I agree that the best thing to do is to set two unconfirmed one against the other and let one shoot the other after any eventual role-claim.
I have no idea who would be a good choice but I may trust the confirmed innocents to decide that.

[This is not me]

yeah that seems like a good strategy. On side note this was the 1st time when someone said i am not scumy looking, people always think of me as scums... so thank you babyjesus