Star Trek Deep Space Nine Season 1 Mafia(game over!)

[davesaz]

In all fairness, D1 reads are usually terrible anyway. Rarely you can peg someone in a smaller game but in larges it seems to usually be luck at best.

[Klingoncelt]

True dat.

[LicketyQuickety]

In all fairness, D1 reads are usually terrible anyway. Rarely you can peg someone in a smaller game but in larges it seems to usually be luck at best.

This is going to sound crazy, but I pride myself on having decent reads day 1. I strive for having good scum reads as early as within the first day. If I have the attitude that "oh, its only the first day, reads shouldn't be good" then that is a huge demotivator for me. Basically my thinking is aim for perfection, accept nothing but excellence. IDK, Maybe I'm crazy, but I want to be the guy that has crazy good reads really early on. *shrug*

[davesaz]

Don't get me wrong, I want to be that guy too.

[LicketyQuickety]

Don't get me wrong, I want to be that guy too.

We all do. This might sound arrogant or whatever but I think I have an edge because I don't read people based on logic. based on logic, yeah, reads are going to suck day 1, but if you read between the lines a bit and and just try to get deeper than what is actually said and try to delve into the character of the posts and not just the dichotomy, I believe it is possible to read scum not just by what they say, but how they present information -the feel of the post so to speak.

[LicketyQuickety]

OK so the reads I got wrong are:
Kling
CDB
Dave
Narn
HI
RIP
LG

Reads I got right:
marcrell
Zabing12
Saint
PB
MP
TAL (1/2 right)
PereV
Nero
Jamierus

Inconclusive is:
Senator
Millar
Titus
Sinsun1

(this is more for my record than anyone elses)

So 8 1/2 were correct reads, 7 were completely wrong and 4 that I couldn't say one way or another.

[LicketyQuickety]

OK rechecked and can't give myself credit for the Jamierus read being correct but am going to say that's an inconclusive. I'm still giving myself credit for the PreV read.

So that's 7 wrong, 7 1/2 correct and 5 that were inconclusive. Meh, I can do better next time in season 2.

[PeregrineV]

Oracles generally get to ask "yes" or "no" questions. When I saw that I was not limited to that, and I couldn't ask about players, I figured I'd ask about roles to see if RIP was scum. Since there was a scum tracker, I suspected RIP, but I really REALLY read Max's last post as hiding behind CDB.

And i didn't expect to die, but if I did, I crumbed the whole scumteam that next day. I think only Dave mentioned it, and I expected to die the next night since he pointed it out, but I guess I lived. I didn;t bother "outing" the town team since I pretty much did that in the thread.

@Monkey-

Fn game, thanks for letting me play, and thanks for modding it!!

[Thor665]

Agreed, the removal of y/n language really boosted the power of that role.

[Psyche]

sorry about the bad luck monkey

[Klingoncelt]

sorry about the bad luck monkey

2nd.