The First Mafia: Game Over

[implosion]

I question how townsided this setup was solely because of how obfuscated everything was. It's not like town got a free town-aligned kill every night in addition to the lynch; we had to work for it (by electing a town leader) after which the fact that it happens at night gives a lot less information (I was never really sure about what happened on n2) but I guess that's partially Katsuki's fault for being really just very opaque about everything in this game.

Not that scum didn't deserve this. Scum played, I would say, exceptionally well. Town played terribly. Katsuki continuing to boast in this postgame is just sad... he contributed a ton towards this loss by tunneling bulbazak and then shooting his townread in errantparabola for no apparent reason, and then going afk after doing all this sketchy shit. He basically killed three townies on his own, and now just takes the postgame to boast about how one of his scumreads was right... like seriously, take SOME ownership over your mistakes :/.

I played wholly mediocrely. I really ultimately probably shouldn't have signed up for this game to begin with but I knew that when I joined so meh. I don't think I'm really capable of reading any of the players who were scum in the end accurately. This game was just an onslaught of big names on MS.

[petroleumjelly]

Sorry about the politician, in that case.

Eh, I don't think there's a reason to be sorry. I just don't happen to like the role. I think it demotivates players from posting after their vote is stolen, and so seems anti-activity and therefore pro-scum; not to mention the hidden nature of the stolen vote, which makes the role itself seem further scummy. The design space is there and you shouldn't feel bad at least experimenting with it, but it definitely does not strike me as a role that is particularly pro-Town.

[Errantparabola]

This game was just an onslaught of big names on MS.

There might have been big names in MS
but you implosion, are the biggest name in my heart

[lalaladucks]

</3 eppp

[camn]

Is DGB scum every single game nowadays?

[Untrod Tripod]