Undertale Mafia: Friends & Corpses [GAME OVER]

[House]

Slysly, I don't think that makes any sense, you're not considering a lot of possibilities that can absolutely lead to me having a grapevine to hear things from as town.

You're not presenting any, either.

Neighborhoods, having friends to talk to via PMs, mixing up other large thread themes where people discuss someone's alt status...

I think listing those possibilities could lead to people deducing things they shouldn't, but since you asked.

You think scum wouldn't already deduce such things from the fact they already know you're not in their PT?

You think town wouldn't already consider a neighborhood an option is they consider a scum PT an option?

VOTE: Giggles

You're smart than this.

[Not Chara]

hello, everyone. i don't think i've ever seen serious votes happen so quickly. c=
VOTE: House

SlySly, i can't tell if you're being facetious or not.

[SlySly]

Neighborhoods, having friends to talk to via PMs

Did you just claim neighbor?

[House]

Slysly, I don't think that makes any sense, you're not considering a lot of possibilities that can absolutely lead to me having a grapevine to hear things from as town.

Here's what I'm considering.

1. My role PM has no mention of ANY grapevines.

If yours does have something about "grapevine(s)" my initial thought is you are scum.

Please for the love of mafia gods tell me you're trolling.

[gigabyteTroubadour]

Slysly, I don't think that makes any sense, you're not considering a lot of possibilities that can absolutely lead to me having a grapevine to hear things from as town.

Here's what I'm considering.

1. My role PM has no mention of ANY grapevines.

If yours does have something about "grapevine(s)" my initial thought is you are scum.

If you have a scumread on someone, why the lack of a vote?

Why does mention of a grapevine have to come from a PM, anyway? Do you have flavor knowledge?

Slysly, I don't think that makes any sense, you're not considering a lot of possibilities that can absolutely lead to me having a grapevine to hear things from as town.

You're not presenting any, either.

Neighborhoods, having friends to talk to via PMs, mixing up other large thread themes where people discuss someone's alt status...

I think listing those possibilities could lead to people deducing things they shouldn't, but since you asked.

You think scum wouldn't already deduce such things from the fact they already know you're not in their PT?

You think town wouldn't already consider a neighborhood an option is they consider a scum PT an option?

VOTE: Giggles

You're smart than this.

He openly admitted to thinking PT = scum, so I'm pretty sure I was on the right track?

And, no, I didn't claim.

[Creature]

I feel like we could flavor this game.

[Not Chara]

from his last post, i'm wondering if he actually isn't... Sly, gigabyte was obviously speaking in hypotheticals.

[gigabyteTroubadour]

I feel like we could flavor this game.

let's

not

:S

[Not Chara]

Creature: do you know the flavour? in my opinion, flavouring this would be nearly impossible. there are multiple endings.

[House]

VOTE: SlySly

Unless he's trolling, he's terribad scum.

[Creature]

I watched Pacifist and Genocide, is that enough?

[Not Chara]

I feel like we could flavor this game.

let's

not

:S

[Not Chara]

I watched Pacifist and Genocide, is that enough?

you know basically all of the plot. the problem is there are so many differing motivations in Undertale (plus, at least three different neutral endings) that it would be difficult.
plus, i think flavour claiming is just a bad idea when scum surely have fakeclaims. i oppose this as a rule unless we're in lylo.

[zakk]

Creature, if you like my posts, why is your vote on me?

Because I was voting you before.

UNVOTE:

Who do you think is scummy? Why?

[Not Chara]

VOTE: SlySly

Unless he's trolling, he's terribad scum.

why not terribad town? he would probably be like this as town as well.
unless something indicates to you that he's faking ignorance, but you haven't mentioned anything like that.

[Creature]

Creature, if you like my posts, why is your vote on me?

Because I was voting you before.

UNVOTE:

Who do you think is scummy? Why?

Too early to ask that, not?

[Not Chara]

weird question there, zakk. we've barely started and creature has done more hunting than you. what are you scumreads?

pedit: exactly.

[SlySly]

If you have a scumread on someone, why the lack of a vote?

When someone that I have a scum read on is in need of a hammer, you'll see my vote!

Why does mention of a grapevine have to come from a PM, anyway? Do you have flavor knowledge?

If you are able to chat with other players (grapevine), I'm sure there's a mention of it in your role PM. I have no flavor knowledge in this game. I bought the game for my kid, but I tuned it out while he played and explained it to me.

[Creature]

What's grapevine?

[House]

VOTE: SlySly

Unless he's trolling, he's terribad scum.

why not terribad town? he would probably be like this as town as well.
unless something indicates to you that he's faking ignorance, but you haven't mentioned anything like that.

I think he's hardcore fishing in a way even bad town wouldn't right out of the gate.

Sure, I asked for alternatives to a scum PT for the grapevine (sorta), but it was an open ended request that left options for not forcing a claim.

Sly straight up pushed for a neighbor claim on top of casting shade over a commonly used term for rumor mill.

[Not Chara]

a grapevine just means 'heard it from somewhere'. why does it have to be from this game, Sly?

i don't want to encourage flavour claiming/hinting. i say table flavour discussion until it becomes relevant.

[Not Chara]

VOTE: SlySly

Unless he's trolling, he's terribad scum.

why not terribad town? he would probably be like this as town as well.
unless something indicates to you that he's faking ignorance, but you haven't mentioned anything like that.

I think he's hardcore fishing in a way even bad town wouldn't right out of the gate.

Sure, I asked for alternatives to a scum PT for the grapevine (sorta), but it was an open ended request that left options for not forcing a claim.

Sly straight up pushed for a neighbor claim on top of casting shade over a commonly used term for rumor mill.

you have a point there.

[Blade Dancer]

VOTE: SlySly for having a scummy avatar. Better no avatar at all than a scummy one.

I agree, but have you seen McMenno's avatar, it's as muddy as his RVS vote.

VOTE: McMenno

[SlySly]

NC, only talk about this game I have is in this thread. Where else would it come from? You know the discussing on going games rule, right?

House, read my tagline, I earned it.

[gigabyteTroubadour]

OK, so that scratches out a few theories of mine...

Just out of curiosity, why do you think the topic of someone's alt status would be brought up in any PT?

also

VOTE: Slysly

i'm really bad at telling when i'm being manipulated but i'm pretty sure that house is right that that line of questioning was kind of leading