In post 1102, Elsa Jay wrote:By the way, hypothetically, if I had a gun, who would be opposed if I shot Nero Cain?
I am no longer opposed.
Also, I disagree with outing your role so early. I think it would've been fine if you kept it secret because now scum has that info.
~ P
In one game, I counterclaim a literal Daycop claim for shits and giggles as scum day 1.
In another, I claim Neutral Doctor with the ascetic modifier, later on saying I'm a 1 shot BP day 1. I was a neutral Hider.
In yet another game, I claim day 1 to be a Ninja Lawyer. I was a town ninja lawyer.
Claiming day 1 as any alignment seems to be my specialty.
Who should I shoot then?
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 11:31 am
by Cheeky Dancer
In post 1145, Karmeleon wrote:Checked Thanos' ISO. Should I be worried when only one head is posting?
In post 1147, Karmeleon wrote:Only Auro seems to be actually posting though, maybe not even Auro.
I think it's only been auro too. I have experience with lames and she is somewhat difficult to read, and has an odd playstyle. Problem for that head is I have them at null in here , and auro was also difficult to read in the newbie game we finished.
Feel free to give this guy a lot of crap in game. He’s my noob friend. (He’s pretty good at mafia, just never played forum mafia.
In order to teach the ways of Forum Mafia to Mister Boon's friend, clearly the best course of action is to lynch him day 1 as a lesson in what NOT to do here.
In post 1145, Karmeleon wrote:Checked Thanos' ISO. Should I be worried when only one head is posting?
In post 1147, Karmeleon wrote:Only Auro seems to be actually posting though, maybe not even Auro.
I think it's only been auro too. I have experience with lames and she is somewhat difficult to read, and has an odd playstyle. Problem for that head is I have them at null in here , and auro was also difficult to read in the newbie game we finished.
In post 1145, Karmeleon wrote:Checked Thanos' ISO. Should I be worried when only one head is posting?
In post 1147, Karmeleon wrote:Only Auro seems to be actually posting though, maybe not even Auro.
I think it's only been auro too. I have experience with lames and she is somewhat difficult to read, and has an odd playstyle. Problem for that head is I have them at null in here , and auro was also difficult to read in the newbie game we finished.
In post 1145, Karmeleon wrote:Checked Thanos' ISO. Should I be worried when only one head is posting?
In post 1147, Karmeleon wrote:Only Auro seems to be actually posting though, maybe not even Auro.
I think it's only been auro too. I have experience with lames and she is somewhat difficult to read, and has an odd playstyle. Problem for that head is I have them at null in here , and auro was also difficult to read in the newbie game we finished.
In post 1303, Nero Cain wrote:Someone is going to have to explain the Drewva and TLK hate. I asked Elsa earlier but they ignored me.
We’re hated? I thought that was just Alonzo. Can someone tell me, why he’s town here? Like, I understand he has this troll meta but I don’t necessarily see why that should be an excuse to townread him here.
i don't see any indication of town. he's either playing in a anti-town way or scum openly pushing a scum agenda
Agreed. He wanted to lynch me for giving him an FOS for his extremely suspicious end the day vote.
In post 1292, Xtoxm wrote:I'm going to have to wade in here. If your clear use of vote tags should be disregarded as a joke, at what point do you draw the line between assuming a vote is a joke and a vote is real? The most sensible course of action is to take literal votes at face value, and you told us that you're voting yourself. If you don't want that in the artificial VC, go ahead and change it.
Oh, I don't think he should have assumed it was a joke. I think he should have asked rather than assuming ANYTHING, because it was meant to cause some confusion about whether it was an actual vote or not.
In post 1293, DrewVa wrote:@Something_Smart, who are you voting for, in your ACTUAL confessional?
I would hardly be right to be voting anyone when I haven't expressed any scumreads worthy of the name. I'll vote if and when I see someone who I actually think is substantially more likely scum than town. That doesn't always happen day 1, and it's even less likely to happen in a game like this. For clarity's sake, the answer right now is nobody.
I won't necessarily say when I vote someone, but if I refrain from doing so I will have a reason for not saying it. Probably that reason will be that I think the person would either clam up under pressure and be harder to read or they would get more wild and desperate and burn all their bridges as town.
In post 1296, The Last Knight wrote:I took a template and copied it, to be honest, and your name was right there at the top. I did think about taking your vote off but it also seemed like an obvious enough joke. I figured I could leave it there and change it later if/when you decided to go public. Just a sillier unknown.
I want to address the last sentence specifically though, because I don't think these VC are necessarily confessional votes. But if someone did vote here and was contradicted later, it gives some nice info on D2.
Oh, that's interesting. I thought the intent was to create an accurate picture of where people were voting. I know that's what I said I wanted to see (real votes, not mock votes), and I thought you created this in response to what I said.
You're right that it was always my prerogative to change my vote/alert you that it wasn't accurate. To be honest, I wanted to see if anyone would get the impression that I was ACTUALLY voting myself, and how they'd react to that... but it seems like nobody even mentioned it. I want to keep it on even after we've had this conversation, but at the same time I don't want to foster the idea that these votes are fake or less serious or that it's all right to have a joke vote on this that doesn't correspond to your real vote. So with that in mind: UNVOTE:
The Last Knight (4) -- RCEnigma, Elsa Jay, profii, Karmeleon
Karmeleon (1) -- Ramcius
Alonzo (2) -- Emperors New Groove, DrewVa
Ramcius (3) -- Gamma Emerald, The Last Knight, Nero Cain
BrightEyedFish (1) -- Nev and Max
RCEnigma (1) -- Theta Alpine
In post 1124, Almost Chara wrote:i'm also townreading TLK here. especially with the context of his mafia experience.
~Chara
Upon an ISO, I also tr him. But because of his vc tracking and interactions from him look like sorting.
@TLK thanks for tracking the vc btw. It's become frustrating to solve without frequent updates, because I want to work off vca too.
What does the 2nd sentence mean though?
~ P
No problem. I appreciate you saying so. That second sentence refers to the fact that this is my first forum mafia game. But I assure you all that I am as verbose and awkward irl, ask Boonskiies
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 12:00 pm
by Cheeky Dancer
@TLK you're in the bay area too? Oh man, small world.
What do you think of ENG , almost chara, dave, or alonzo?
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 12:16 pm
by The Last Knight
Let me read through some ISO's and I'll get back to you. I have some inklings about these peeps so far but I want to take a better look.
In post 1124, Almost Chara wrote:i'm also townreading TLK here. especially with the context of his mafia experience.
~Chara
Upon an ISO, I also tr him. But because of his vc tracking and interactions from him look like sorting.
@TLK thanks for tracking the vc btw. It's become frustrating to solve without frequent updates, because I want to work off vca too.
What does the 2nd sentence mean though?
~ P
No problem. I appreciate you saying so. That second sentence refers to the fact that this is my first forum mafia game. But I assure you all that I am as verbose and awkward irl, ask Boonskiies
he's correct, that's what i meant.
knowing he has mafia experience but not forum mafia experience fits in nicely with how he's been playing so far, as town.
i believe Elsa's reason for voting him is pretty bad. it's nitpicky, and you know how i feel about that.
he's tracking known votes. not tracking probablw votes. changing the not voting to unknown when prompted isn't strange, it makes sense with what TLK said he was already trying to do.
~Chara
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 1:49 pm
by Almost Chara
i'm scumreading Cheeky Dancer less. it has to do a bit with Performer's reaction to Elsa's claim, though that's weak evidence.
i just voted for Ramcius.
~Chara
In post 1145, Karmeleon wrote:Checked Thanos' ISO. Should I be worried when only one head is posting?
In post 1147, Karmeleon wrote:Only Auro seems to be actually posting though, maybe not even Auro.
I think it's only been auro too. I have experience with lames and she is somewhat difficult to read, and has an odd playstyle. Problem for that head is I have them at null in here , and auro was also difficult to read in the newbie game we finished.
In post 1303, Nero Cain wrote:Someone is going to have to explain the Drewva and TLK hate. I asked Elsa earlier but they ignored me.
We’re hated? I thought that was just Alonzo. Can someone tell me, why he’s town here? Like, I understand he has this troll meta but I don’t necessarily see why that should be an excuse to townread him here.
i don't see any indication of town. he's either playing in a anti-town way or scum openly pushing a scum agenda
Agreed. He wanted to lynch me for giving him an FOS for his extremely suspicious end the day vote.
I think I feel better about this vote. for now.
UNVOTE:
Feeling good about yourself is very important.
VOTE: Alonzo
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 2:12 pm
by Alonzo
Bored.
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 2:14 pm
by Nero Cain
As long as we are both ok with each other dying, performer.
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 2:15 pm
by Almost Chara
bored? vote Theta Alpine with us!
~Chara
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 2:15 pm
by Alonzo
who?!
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 2:19 pm
by Elsa Jay
We could just end the day and see what happens.
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 2:21 pm
by Almost Chara
why even play mafia at all? it's more fun to just vote randomly and then see who plurality decides to lynch.
~Chara
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2018 2:24 pm
by Elsa Jay
In post 1348, Almost Chara wrote:why even play mafia at all? it's more fun to just vote randomly and then see who plurality decides to lynch.
~Chara
Exactly. I think we only need 1 more person to end the day and McQueen went afk.
