Mafiascum.net

OK so SS, mcqueen and Gamma

Anyone else?

In post 3221, Something_Smart wrote:which brings up the question to dave and Thanos, why did you stay on UL when it seemed like the consensus was if a lurker was lynched, it would be flippy?

I wasn't actually here for about the last 2 days of day 1.

Fair enough.

Alonzo, what does your list refer to?
I think I know what, but not sure.

In post 2498, Alonzo wrote:VOTE: Theta Alpine

This was AlmostCharas top SR, and upon review of their Iso overnight I think we should roll with it.

Only on page 100, but I was ready to vote for Theta's lynch on D1. So assuming things don't really change in I'll VOTE: Theta Alpine.

In post 2522, Thanos wrote:

In post 2518, mcqueen wrote:Thanos- everything you just said has been covered

I know, just stating my reason for voting. And also those prizes I leaked are important to whoever is cop or tracker out there. Just keep that in mind.

I'm liking this pro town mind set.

In post 2536, mcqueen wrote:

In post 2533, DrewVa wrote:

In post 2529, Thanos wrote:

In post 2464, DrewVa wrote:Oh wait, can confirm, there’s at least three rooms. Boon just made mention of other rooms - plural. That obviously means, at least 3.

Yes, because he fucking posted this AFTER I posted about a 2nd one. God, you must be taking scumhunting lessons from BEF.

You are so heated but I’m over here laughing my tail off

I wish I could laugh, but the cringe takes over. The beef that DrewVa has with Thanos (Lamees) and BEF has little to do with game, it seems. The hate posts and calling people stupid is pretty weak imo and I'm not a fan.

@TLK, I’m not a fan of calling people stupid here either, but it’s been shown on multiple occasions people either aren’t reading the thread or don’t understand what’s going on, which is fine, except they like to push others and come to conclusions before doing so.

Will reapond to other specific posts in a bit (@Auro, Cheeky mainly)

In post 2613, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 2579, DrewVa wrote:

In post 2577, Ramcius wrote:If we assume that there only 5 scum (maybe 6, if 5 scumteam + traitor), we have huge number advantage, so rewards in BOONus rounds being not so useful for town is something reasonable

BOONus round reminds me a bit of Heroes in that respect, except on some days, all abilities were either pro-town or scum and on others, varying degrees of mixed.

yeah this does feel similar, but with a base level of power for everyone it seems
what I'm questioning is how TLK has a passive role when the setup doesn't seem like that's something meant to be started with

You're telling me... I wish my role was cooler. But you still have to respect the ss. The basic bitch abilities are generally the strongest in most games I play.

In post 3068, mcqueen wrote:

In post 3063, Emperors New Groove wrote:I have. Try reading.

Why can’t you quote it for me? I have been reading but Don’t expect me to remember everything, especially when you’re not very active most of the time

Gonna call this not-a-SHROOP real quick

I've literally been just skimming the last 15 pages and I've turned out fine.

In post 3095, Emperors New Groove wrote:

In post 3094, mcqueen wrote:You stop being lazy.

This interaction is friggin stupid

To be fair to the penguin, I DID say to only use gifs if he is drunk. Perhaps he's still drunk?

One hopes he was drunk.

Elsa what's your read on Profii atm? Who are your biggest scumspects or townreads?

~ C

In post 3238, Elsa Jay wrote:To be fair to the penguin, I DID say to only use gifs if he is drunk. Perhaps he's still drunk?

Tipsy. Not drunk. It served a purpose.

In post 2772, BrightEyedFish wrote:

In post 2769, Emperors New Groove wrote:

In post 2767, BrightEyedFish wrote:

In post 2766, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 2749, BrightEyedFish wrote:Gamma was in Group C.

Ram wasn’t in Group C

VOTE: Ramicus

Why?

Because the winners of the BOONus rounds are the Day Reps. Also scum has a new modifier where they can pick one of themselves to be a Day Rep. And Ram wasn't in a BOONus round.

This is really good logic.

Especially with Ram trying to get killed, it almost seems like he is baiting people to tell him otherwise.

In post 3239, Cheeky Dancer wrote:One hopes he was drunk.

Elsa what's your read on Profii atm? Who are your biggest scumspects or townreads?

~ C

Townreads are at a later date, but frankly if I have my way today, Profii should go. His role is at best null for either alignment and at worst helpful to scum. Nobody ever took into account how useful it is to make one of Mafias problems Ascetic to not let them get saved by a doctor?

His play is also more scummy in general. He tried to downplay me for pointing out the scummy nature of his role, and is using it as a defense. Common Scum mistake.

Who would be your next best lynch?

I'll personally hammer TLK if nessecity necessary so town doesn't fear any backlash from his claim either. Otherwise, I feel like the majority discussion is between DrewVa and Theta. I'm wanting Theta to actually play before I make judgement, but otherwise, I'd kill them.

In post 3242, Elsa Jay wrote:Townreads are at a later date, but frankly if I have my way today, Profii should go. His role is at best null for either alignment and at worst helpful to scum. Nobody ever took into account how useful it is to make one of Mafias problems Ascetic to not let them get saved by a doctor?

It's actually way worse if a scum gets made ascetic, but it's irrelevant because if he's town he won't ever be using that.

And if by "null for either alignment" you mean not helpful, I'd contest that because of everything I said about loyal. If you mean it's not a towny claim, I seriously doubt that he fakeclaims that role as scum and I also seriously doubt that he has that role as scum.

What about that role makes it townie? In fact, having multiple abilities when appearantly everyone elsa has 1 is a dead giveaway of it. Did you think of that?

In post 3246, Elsa Jay wrote:What about that role makes it townie? In fact, having multiple abilities when appearantly everyone elsa has 1 is a dead giveaway of it. Did you think of that?

Do you have experience with boons prior games? Does he provide safe claims to scum or does he just let them feed for themselves?

Im not the person to ask here, but it's been done before. And if he outted there being 5 scum and the scum being able to choose a day rep, clearly he's also helping scum behind the scenes.

I mean either way, I think that a. If provided boon wouldn't give them something immediately identifiable as a fake, and b. Think that as scum they would fake something better.