In post 5314, DrewVa wrote:Creature is your scum pool limited to Gamma and Thanos? If so can you maybe expand more on your read of Thanos? If not who else is scum? -d
I think they’re all town. Well, more confident on Creature, Gamma but I tr Auro half of that hydra. \_0_/
In post 5244, PenguinPower wrote:D3 - PP asks TLK if he liked the gift PP gave him; TLK says he got Sticky Fruit. PP/Profii did not send Sticky Fruit to TLK
..and this should be all that matters.
Scum!TLK tried to be quick on their feet, and guessed wrong what to fakeclaim.
It definitely doesn’t look good but it’s still a dumb fakeclaim anyway.
These are the kinda posts that are gonna get you lynched because it looks so....lamist I guess.
You're a claimed VT and very much lynchable...why would cheeky NK you?
I've been getting the same feelings about MCs posting the last few pages. They feel very... manufactured? Like the multiple posts he had about being flustered when pressured, and then talking about his ban. People get banned here all the time. I check out the ban list now and then, hell I've been warned a few times for channeling my inner Kuribo in games.
There's also something like a false bravado in his most recent posts where he is lashing out at CD. I don't know if this is scumMc puffing up his chest to a townCD threat, scum theater, or townMc staying up to scumCD...
By tone, play, being on Flippy and I think I might have a mechanical clear on him and McQueen.
Boon said that D2+, scum has the OPTION of being Day rep, so no way of telling on D2+, however on D1, Boon picked the reps and since Flippy was scum, that probably confitowns both McQueen and Xtoxm.
I could easily scumread every person on the ramcius wagon. Guess we just bob until there's less people. Come at us.
~ C
Scum is more likely to be early than late, so that looks good for N & M and Daveaz, I think. If McQueen is mechanically clear and I think he is, I think scum is most likely to be in SS, Elsa and TLK. Probably not all 5 on the same wagon.
However if Elsa is town, he should be willing to hammer TLK and his claim really doesn’t make sense as scum, unless he doesn’t back it up,
Btw day people don’t end the day until this is cleared up
Just want to point out something: I think profii is absolutely capable of doing something as bold as this when scum.
Just because they claim to have spread inventions around, shouldn't townlock them as hard as they apparently have been. (?)
Or is there anything else to absolutely cement them as town?
Something is definitely weird about the Profil/TLK thing. If TLK did get the sticky fruit, than that could explain why he never received Penguin gift but if both Profil and TLK were telling the truth, then that points to a possible redirect.
Posted: Sat Jan 19, 2019 4:06 am
by DrewVa
In post 5324, UnaBombaH wrote:Like...so many things suggest to me that Creature is scum here.
But since no one is listening, I guess I'll have to be more dramatic soon.
@Creature - did you here me "Quack" last night?
Okay, Una is implying Loud something wrt to Creature.
Posted: Sat Jan 19, 2019 4:06 am
by RCEnigma
If Profii was redirected then it's 100% scums role.
Posted: Sat Jan 19, 2019 4:07 am
by DrewVa
In post 5326, Cheeky Dancer wrote:I could go profii if TLK flips town. But I'm not feeling that possibility tbh.
Him not wanting to prematurely end the day until stickygate is resolved, reads townie.
Posted: Sat Jan 19, 2019 4:08 am
by RCEnigma
We always Lynch within Ram's wagon today and it should always be TLK with one of the Ram voters placing the hammer. Though truth be told I kind of like Nev today. So Elsa or SS.
Posted: Sat Jan 19, 2019 4:08 am
by RCEnigma
Redirect also confirms Profii town btw.
Posted: Sat Jan 19, 2019 4:10 am
by RCEnigma
Actually scratch that if Profii was redirected his loyal modifier would have been redirected too.
In post 5323, Cheeky Dancer wrote:Was it? Great analysis. Are you clearing every person on the Ramcius wagon?
Nope.
Out of the lynch I'd currently hunch something like:
BrightEyedFish
[12/31, 19:35],
Mcqueen
[1/1, 07:52],
Something_Smart
[1/13, 09:50]
Elsa Jay
[1/13, 17:16],
DrewVa
[1/13, 22:25],
The Last Knight
[1/13, 23:02],
UnaBombah
[1/14, 02:22],
Nev and Max
[1/14, 12:23],
Davesaz
[1/14, 16:23]
I think I noted TLK as potential scum during my catchup once I had seen the first flips, BUT TOOK A 180 TURN, because I felt so certain about scum!Ramcius+scum!Karmeleon.
Now that I know I was wrong about Ramcius, it's not impossible for scum!Creature to have been on scum!TLK.
I’ve actually rolled scum with Creature in Heroes and he didn’t bus, unless he was directed to do so. Scum!Creature, is probably hands down the most loyal scummate you could evet ask for, so no, I don’t see him hardbussing TLK. Scum!TLK flip, townspews Creature.
While S_S is something close to a perfect 50/50 to me, I'm really getting some gutvibes for scum!dave.
I've seen plenty of town!Dave, and I've been scum WITH dave, so I'm thinking my gut might just be correct..
How is scum!Dave different from town!Dave? I’ve only played once with Dave as town, in OK 2.
While S_S is something close to a perfect 50/50 to me, I'm really getting some gutvibes for scum!dave.
I've seen plenty of town!Dave, and I've been scum WITH dave, so I'm thinking my gut might just be correct..
I'm the opposite, Dave seems ok but in my gut im like he always seems ok but S_S really bugs me and id be looking closely there if there wasnt other priorities rn
Mindmelding with you here. Dave doesn’t really seem any different here, than in OK 2. SS has been my strongest sr for quite some time.
Posted: Sat Jan 19, 2019 4:23 am
by DrewVa
In post 5347, BrightEyedFish wrote:I am assuming that if scum got a hold of the sticky fruit they would pass it around among themselves since they would be immune to all actions, i.e. cop etc.
And they would probably keep it under wraps that they received it. Maybe thats why TLK didn't announce he received the fruit until pushed. Profii on the other hand immediately announced he got the fruit at the start of D2, this makes him town for me.
+1
I’m actually mindmelding with BEF, is this a sign of the apocalypse?
Something to do with TLK stating he got fruit, profi stating he gave TLK nothing, pp stating he gave TLK something but not fruit. I'm ok with TLK's lynch.
Also, pp & TLK still have each other as scumreads since d2 iirc so there's that.
Something I've been wondering is that what if his super saint part is somehow true? Then dave's idea made sense if he was scum super saint...which isn't the first time I've heard of that role implemented like that.
Considering the low level of powers for us that we've seen this far, scum super saint makes some sense.
For some reason I don't really think we had more than one scum day 1 representative.
I dont know how we can tell if there is at least 1 scum in the d1 rep. It makes some sense in terms of having at least 1 scum in the 4 but I'd rather focus on other things to scumhunt off of. I havent heard of a reliable enough method to determine that there is at least 1 scum in the day reps.
The claims so far that I can tell:
inventor, vt (and flipped vts), duck, (basically) vigilante, super saint
~ P
Usually dont get stuck up on things like this, but who is us? How would scum super saint make sense if town had few powers? Are you scum?
In DnD mafia, we had a scum vengeful PGO.
Posted: Sat Jan 19, 2019 4:30 am
by DrewVa
In post 5358, RCEnigma wrote:Super Saint is supposed to be town only. I already don't trust FL but scum supersaint would be the frosting on the cake.