all millers should claim asap - its like having a red cop result - it will prevent redundant checks and help the game
all millers must die before lylo. I don't care that includes me
as someone who always try to endgame and very rarely gets lynched and usually can carry scumteams to victory - I would never ever fake claim miller
about alchemist I don't know why would a scum them fake claim miller and I'm not sure if they are bold enough scum player to do that.
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 5:02 am
by Elsa Jay
Lynching a strong townie just because their role is a Miller is stupid. Lynching someone who actually tries to claim Miller for towncred and to discredit the real one is a great deal.
Miller = Innocent Child in some situations. Just in a back around way.
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 5:03 am
by Frozen Angel
In post 15, Elsa Jay wrote:Lynching someone who actually tries to claim Miller for towncred and to discredit the real one is a great deal.
but how are you sure there are not 2 millers in the game?
and how do you trust me this much to say he is discrediting me?
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 5:11 am
by sheepsaysmeep
claiming first miller as wolf would be ballsy
counterclaiming miller as wolf is lol
but i think what fa's doing here feels real-miller-y too yeah
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 5:15 am
by Elsa Jay
This is me trying to pocket a buddy for later on that seems trustworthy from a first glance. I'm naturally suspicious, so I like having support.
Second: I refuse to believe Gamma would put 2 Millers in. That's more me thinking on what Gamma likes and the natural way he claimed Miller as well after you.
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 6:09 am
by Alchemist21
I’m not even discrediting the Miller claim. I’ve been in a game with 2 Millers before and was just making sure it’s not impossible in this game. If I was trying to discredit it I wouldn’t have said I’m
also
a Miller, I would have counterclaimed and voted FA. Also claiming Miller as scum in the first place is just bad because Millers need to be dealt with before Lylo and there’s no way I’d do it after someone already claimed it.
I think Elsa knows FA and I are both Town and wants 2 easy lynches by saying “well we were wrong on the first, must be the other that was faking,” and didn’t stop to think about how Town needs to feal with both Millers anyway.
VOTE: Elsa Jay
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 6:19 am
by Pink Ball
Wow, dense game from the start. Not even one comment about ly glorious first post
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 6:32 am
by Elsa Jay
Well I guess you ARE sticking with the miller claim. Well then. Why are you literally already trying to paint me in a bad light just because you claimed miller right after someone elsa? Not everyone here has played every game on the site, and I sure as heck haven't read them all. If double Miller is common, I'd like more verification then just you.
Few questions tho: How many people were in that game with 2 millers? How many investigatives did they have in that game as a counterbalance? And was there another mechanic like Multiball or something in play?
In post 10, Elsa Jay wrote:Claiming miller right off of page 1? Fun! I'm only going to take Frozen's Miller claim here seriously so Alchemist gets a vote for lying in page 1.
VOTE: Alchemist
Call me when scum don't try and discredit townies page 1. I want a harder game next time.
Who is descriting FA?
Posted: Mon Dec 31, 2018 6:41 am
by Firebringer
VOTE: Frozen Angel
I want to sort Frozen San first