Mafiascum.net

I haven't calculated hard statistics, but over the past half dozen games or so maybe 75% of the people I think aren't scumhunting turn up scum, regardless of who it is or situation. That's a hell of a lot better than random.

In post 1023, davesaz wrote:

In post 1015, Creature wrote:Actually idk why Maki is above you

You didn't notice that it's just the player list?

No, I thought it was an actual readslist.

Posting a readslist ordering players in scale of scumminess would already be more content than half this playerlist has done this game.

In post 1024, davesaz wrote:Going through d1 with an unexplained read on exactly 1 person is scummy no matter who it is.

Who is it in that case?

In post 1025, davesaz wrote:I haven't calculated hard statistics, but over the past half dozen games or so maybe 75% of the people I think aren't scumhunting turn up scum, regardless of who it is or situation. That's a hell of a lot better than random.

Yeah, and they usually claim they've been posting a lot too.

In post 992, Kaito Momota wrote:

In post 969, Lady Angel wrote:The Maki vote was pure bandwagon

How does that make me scum?

In post 969, Lady Angel wrote:as was his next vote on Wisdom.

How does that make me scum?

In post 969, Lady Angel wrote:Then he defends Maki from Wisdom despite having just voted her.

How does that make me scum?

In post 969, Lady Angel wrote:and it seemed more brought on by frustration than anything.

So? What's your point?

In post 969, Lady Angel wrote:The wisdom vote also seemed quite random at the end of the iso.

How does that make me scum?

In post 969, Lady Angel wrote:Overall there isn't much to work with here

In post 969, Lady Angel wrote:and what there is is pinging me enough to suspect him.

This is the same reason people were just voting you - it's not a good one, which you said in the same post

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Kaito

This is the scummiest post by far this game and we've had Elsa just messing around half the game. Kaito is a strong scumread.

I don't think you're hitting actual scumtells, but whatever.

In post 1019, Alchemist21 wrote:I seriously doubt Maki flips scum here.

based on what?

In post 1032, Wisdom wrote:

In post 1019, Alchemist21 wrote:I seriously doubt Maki flips scum here.

based on what?

Based on how that wagon came about. It was too easy and felt like scum were just hopping onto that one.

oh so bs, ok

Give me one good reason to think Maki is scum.

dunn feels obvious town

someone try to sell me

Who is this "Dunn" you speak of? No such person is in the game. Neither is there a "Maria". Clearly your confusing Kaito and Maki for someone elsa.

In post 1036, sheepsaysmeep wrote:dunn feels obvious town

someone try to sell me

I don’t see why Town would dance around the Chara vote like he did. He was expressing a strong read on the slot, so why would he sheep onto two other wagons without voting Chara?

In post 1019, Alchemist21 wrote:How do y’all feel about a Wisdom lynch then? I seriously doubt Maki flips scum here.

why are you townreading her?

In post 1038, Alchemist21 wrote:

In post 1036, sheepsaysmeep wrote:dunn feels obvious town

someone try to sell me

I don’t see why Town would dance around the Chara vote like he did. He was expressing a strong read on the slot, so why would he sheep onto two other wagons without voting Chara?

sheep, both Alchemist and i have gone into the read here. maybe tell us why Kaito is obvious town?

also i missed Alch's answer about Maria when i made that post. Alch, i don't like her wagon being a reason she's town. who are the scum who jumped on her wagon? it's not something you should be vague about. sure, Kaito was voting her, but not for long at all, so i'm not considering that. if she was really a mislynch that scum Kaito wanted (and i know you think he's scum) then why does he hop off, and who are the scum that stayed/joined and made the wagon feel too easy to you?

992 does remind me of scum Kaito, and is making me want the lynch more aggressively again. it doesn't need to be explained why jumping on bandwagon lynches is scummy. nor why the Maki defense that he's only explained now as being null on her, is scummy. it's blatant in being a discredit.
but let me go over the town possibility so i can see if it's valid or if i should discard it.

In post 1028, Creature wrote:

In post 1024, davesaz wrote:Going through d1 with an unexplained read on exactly 1 person is scummy no matter who it is.

Who is it in that case?

I think you should know who I'm talking about. Who is repeating over and over that a given individual is scum without saying why or commenting on the alignment of anyone else?

In post 1044, davesaz wrote:

In post 1028, Creature wrote:

In post 1024, davesaz wrote:Going through d1 with an unexplained read on exactly 1 person is scummy no matter who it is.

Who is it in that case?

I think you should know who I'm talking about. Who is repeating over and over that a given individual is scum without saying why or commenting on the alignment of anyone else?

Nikk?

In post 1042, Chara wrote:who are the scum who jumped on her wagon?

Wisdom.

That answer is for Creature too.

I'm absolutely never voting Maki unless Wisdom gives an actual reason.

In post 1046, davesaz wrote:

In post 1042, Chara wrote:who are the scum who jumped on her wagon?

Wisdom.

i was asking Alchemist, not you. Alch doesn't scumread Wisdom as far as i can tell.