Greatest Idea VIII - Game Over

[insomnia]

If you truly are sk, you should probably aim for a maf tonight

[Vedith]

Does your role tell you if you turn someone to VT?
I didn't read the posts earlier about it.

[Vedith]

I think Wisdom was last Mafia.
And there's WW out there.

[Vedith]

Who do you think is factional Scum though?

[insomnia]

Does your role tell you if you turn someone to VT?
I didn't read the posts earlier about it.

No

[Vedith]

Oh. Well still come visit me.
I am making soup tonight that is to die for.

[NotMySpamAccount]

I'd love to see dave dead tonight. If he's not, I want to lynch him tomorrow.

pedit: badum tsh

[Vedith]

I'm not visiting a claimed PGO
Not that I can visit of course, but if I could.

[insomnia]

What’s a PGO

[Vedith]

He can activate and kill anyone who visits him.

[Vedith]

Irrel might be WW actually given that Pintu did actually heal there.

[Vedith]

ofrhz TTTT and Insomnia should all be town and not argued.
Dave I still think is town.
Irrel only if NMSA

\o/

[insomnia]

Who’s sk for you vedith?

[Vedith]

None of the players in 2186

[insomnia]

Take a wild guess

[Vedith]

I'm not sure how else I can say this.
The following players in this game are not SK

TTTT
ofrhz
davesaz
NotMySpamAccount
Irrelephant11

There is guaranteed an SK in the following (100% sure that SK is here)
Insomnia
Vedith
Trekie
Micc

[NotMySpamAccount]

I'm not sure how else I can say this.
The following players in this game are not SK

TTTT
ofrhz
davesaz
NotMySpamAccount
Irrelephant11

There is guaranteed an SK in the following (100% sure that SK is here)
Insomnia

Vedith

Trekie
Micc

I think this is enough evidence for vedith to be sk

[Vedith]

Maybe it's Micc

[Micc]

Votecount 4.03

Trekkie99 (5) -

NotMySpamAccount, insomnia, TTTT, davesaz, Irrelephant11

Not Voting (3) -

ofrhz, Trekkie99, Vedith

With 8 players alive it takes 5 votes to lynch.

A lynch has been achieved.

[Micc]

Trekkie99 has been lynched Day 4. He was a

Cult Black Goo

.

It is now Night 4. The deadline for Night 4 is in (expired on 2019-04-03 17:10:00).

[Micc]

I've had some requests for an accelerated night phase. If all players PM me explicitly asking for it I will end the night phase early.

[Micc]

TTTT has been killed Night 4. They were a

Town One-Shot Dayvig

.
Irrelephant11 has been killed Night 4. He was a

Werewolf

.

The Town has achieved it's win condition.

Vedith

, a

Serial Killer Supersaint

turned

Vanilla Tonwie

, survived and wins.

ofrhz

, a

Two-Shot Bulletproof Serial Killer

turned

Vanilla Townie

, survived and wins.

davesaz

, a

Town One-Shot Paranoid Gun Owner

, survived and wins.

NotMySpamAccount

, a

Vanilla Townie

, survived and wins.

insomnia

, a

Town Psychiatrist

, survived and wins.

TTTT

,

Almost50

,

Jingle

,

DoubtingThomas

,

Alchemist21

,

Performer

,

TemporalLich

,

Chemist1422

,

Sakura Hana

, and

Xtoxm

all win posthumously.

Congratulations to the Town for winning Greatest Idea VIII!

[Micc]

Mod Thread
Mafia Thread
Werewolf Thread
Mason Thread
Dead Thread

Spoiler: Role List

Players:

TTTT

-

Town One-Shot Dayvig

Almost50

Allomancer -

Town Mason

Vedith

-

Serial Killer Supersaint

turned

Vanilla Townie

ofrhz

-

Two-Shot Bulletproof Serial Killer

turned

Vanilla Townie

Jingle

brassherald -

Town Cop-of-all-Trades

davesaz

-

Town One-Shot Paranoid Gun Owner

NotMySpamAccount

-

Vanilla Townie

Elsa Jay

-

Mafia Cupid

DoubtingThomas

-

Town Cop

pinturicchio

-

Werewolf Mason Doctor

Alchemist21

-

Town Mason

Performer

-

Town Fruit Vendor

insomnia

Gamma Emerald -

Town Psychiatrist

Shadowlesscloud

-

Town Tracker

turned

Cult Tracker

TemporalLich

-

Town Seer

Trekkie99

Blooper -

Cult Black Goo

Wisdom

JunkoChan -

Mafia Compulsive Childkiller

Chemist1422

-

Town Jack-of-all-Trades

Sakura Hana

-

Town Tracker

Irrelephant11

-

Werewolf

Xtoxm

-

Town Conspiracy Theorist

Spoiler: Night actions

Night 1:

davesaz doesn't activate PGO
Chemist1422 roleblocks TTTT - TTTT is roleblocked
pinturicchio protects Irrelephant11 - Irrelephant11 is protected
TemporalLich investigates davesaz -

davesaz is NOT GUILTY

Jingle (cop) investigates DoubtingThomas -

DoubtingThomas is NOT GUILTY

DoubtingThomas investigates Sakura Hana -

Sakura Hana is NOT GUILTY

Xtoxm investigates Sakura Hana -

Sakura Hana is NOT GUILTY

Performer gives fruit to davesaz -

davesaz receives fruit

Vedith shoots Sakura Hana -

Sakura Hana flips Town Tracker

ofrhz shoots Almost50 -

Almost50 flips Town Mason

Wisdom uses mafia nightkill on Alchemist21 -

Alchemist21 flips Town Mason

Irrelephant11 uses werewolf nightkill on Jingle -

Jingle flips Town Cop-of-all-Trades

Gamma Emerald doesn't submit an action
Shadowlesscloud tracks Performer -

Performer visited davesaz

Sakura Hana tracks Wisdom -

Wisdom visited Alchemist21

Night 2:

davesaz doesn't activate PGO
Chemist1422 protects davesaz - davesaz is protected
pinturicchio protects Irrelephant11 - Irrelephant11 is protected
DoubtingThomas investigates Irrelephant11 -

Irrelephant11 is NOT GUILTY

Xtoxm investigates Wisdom -

Wisdom is NOT GUILTY

Vedith shoots Irrelephant11 - Fails due protection
ofrhz shoots Chemist1422 -

Chemist1422 flips Town Jack-of-all-Trades

Wisdom uses mafia nightkill on Irrelephant11 - Fails due to protection
Irrelephant11 uses werewolf nightkill on Xtoxm -

Xtoxm flips Town Conspiracy Theorist

Gamma Emerald converts pinturicchio - Fails since pinturicchio isn't serial killer
Shadowlesscloud tracks Trekkie99 -

Trekkie99 visited NO ONE

/

Shadowlesscloud is converted to Cult Tracker

Night 3:

davesaz does/doesn't activate
DoubtingThomas investigates insomnia -

insomnia is NOT GUILTY

Vedith shoots Shadowlesscloud -

Shadowlesscloud flips Town Tracker turned Cult Tracker

ofrhz shoots Shadowlesscloud -

Shadowlesscloud flips Town Tracker turned Cult Tracker

Wisdom uses mafia nightkill on DoubtingThomas -

DoubtingThomas flips Town Cop

Irrelephant11 uses werewolf nightkill on Wisdom -

Wisdom flips Mafia Compulsive Childkiller

insomnia converts ofrhz -

ofrhz becomes a Vanilla Townie

Shadowlesscloud tracks NotMySpamAccount -

NotMySpamAccount visited NO ONE.

Night 4:

davesaz doesn't activate PGO
Vedith shoots Irrelephant11 - Irrelephant11 flips Werewolf
Irrelephant11 uses werewolf nightkill on TTTT - TTTT flips Town One-Shot Dayvig
insomnia converts Vedith - Vedith becomes a Vanilla Townie

Spoiler: Card Choices - Setup C

Player Name	Alignment Card	Ability Card	Role Name
TTTT	Vanilla Townie	One-Shot Dayvig	Town One-Shot Dayvig
Allomancer	Vanilla Cop	Survivor Mason	Town Mason
Vedith	Serial Killer (Mafia immune)	Supersaint	Serial Killer Supersaint
ofrhz	Serial Killer (Alien immune)	Serial Killer (Two-Shot Bulletproof)	Two-Shot Bulletproof Serial Killer
brassherald	Seer	Cop-of-all-Trades	Town Cop-of-all-Trades
davesaz	Doctor	One-Shot Paranoid Gun Owner	Town One-Shot Paranoid Gun Owner
NotMySpamAccount	Watcher	Vanilla Townie	Vanilla Tonwie
Elsa Jay	Mafia Goon	Mafia Cupid	Mafia Cupid
DoubtingThomas	Bodyguard	Werewolf Cop	Town Cop
pinturicchio	Werewolf One-Shot Bulletproof	Mason Doctor	Werewolf Mason Doctor
Alchemist21	Reloader	Mason	Town Mason
Performer	Retired Marine	Mafia Fruit Vendor	Town Fruit Vendor
Gamma Emerald	Tourist	Psychiatrist	Town Psychiatrist
Shadowlesscloud	Hero	Tracker	Town Tracker
TemporalLich	Tracker	Mafia Seer	Town Seer
Blooper	Cult One-Shot Goomaker	Black Goo	Cult Black Goo
JunkoChan	Mafia Compulsive Hider	Compulsive Childkiller	Mafia Compulsive Childkiller
Chemist1422	One-Shot Vigilante	Jack-of-all-Trades	Town Jack-of-all-Trades
Sakura Hana	Wrong Place at the Wrong Time Tonwie	Mafia Tracker	Town Tracker
Irrelephant11	Werewolf	Judas	Werewolf
Xtoxm	Ascetic Townie	Conspiracy Theorist	Town Conspiracy Theorist

[Micc]

Thanks to everyone for playing this crazy game. This setup proved to be increasingly bastard with a larger playerlist and my choice of Setup C seemed to accelerate that. I thought the scum to town balance for the other two setup options was a little bit off and that Setup C provided the best balance between scum factions. I knew the high quantity of different factions would likely lead to a wild multiball game which would meet the expectation for a large Greatest Idea setup. I'm more than happy to hear feedback from the players with regards to my choice between setups.

The game itself proved to be quite the challenge. I interpreted the One-Shot PGO differently than the wiki article describes which presumably affected davesaz's game. The setup doesn't define how a Cult works all that well. I made a reasonable effort to hash things out before the game, but it still proved to be pretty messy. I discussed a couple other things I wasn't happy with in the dead thread. Overall, I hope everyone thought the game was playable. I don't plan to run this again without some kind of refinement to reduce some of the problems. I liked the suggestion to crowd source that through the Open Setups Discussion forum. I'll probably kick that off some time in the not so distant future.

Threads are now all public. Thanks again for playing. I hope everyone enjoyed the game!

[Xtoxm]

holy shit town actually won this scum stacked setup!
well played guys
especially vedith and insomnia
hero psychiatrist play
gg!