Gameshow Mafia (Reroll): Game Over

[Taly]

ive taken so many Ls on this site in this year particularly

but i feel like if i return to a mafia game, whether its on MS or another site, im going to have a pretty refined mentality

i like playing mafia for the investigative aspect and playing with cool people, but the time-consumption, effort, and frustration that accompanies it is a lot and its best i just commentate or view at leisure

[Titus]

ive taken so many Ls on this site in this year particularly

but i feel like if i return to a mafia game, whether its on MS or another site, im going to have a pretty refined mentality

i like playing mafia for the investigative aspect and playing with cool people, but the time-consumption, effort, and frustration that accompanies it is a lot and its best i just commentate or view at leisure

Yeah being competitive here sucks. Play for some other purpose.

[BrightEyedFish]

I knew there was something wrong with the NF/RC dynamic. The way people followed NF's reads without much thought should have been a clear indication that they were either powerwolves or being pocketed to do scum's bidding.

The scumteam manipulated the game state perfectly. Lynching obv town PB and Titus was very clever.

I was surprised Creature was scum tbh I have not seen him play this way as scum.

Maybe next time don’t sr a slot and get all mad and defensive when people ask you to back up that read. Calling Maria scum w/o ever attempting to case her looked like flat out open wolfing to me. And omgussing everyone who sr you, also didn’t help matters.

You should have recognized from LotV, that this was 100% my towngame and not misread me.

You were not playing at all similar here to that game.

Yes, scum pocketed me but both you and TD acted super scummy, although TD eventually obvtowned with baezu AtE.

As for Chenn, I was overly paranoid about him being potential mislynchbait. Both BEF, Tohru and especially Ank recognized he was scum.

@BEF, really sorry I contributed in mislynching you but you get the town MVB prize for correctly identifying scum!Chenn the earliest. You really made up for LNT in THIS game and I wouldn’t want your contribution to go unnoticed.

Thanks, I was slow to get started in this game and once I got going I got lynched.

I had fun though, I love games like this and LNT.

[Firebringer]

Mbaki had been thoroughly discredited since D1 and was always gonna be a mislynch

Taly slot ended up eating a nightkill anyway

I forget, was Taly townreading Ank?

i want to see how you do on a site with better players, not autopilot like ms is

Hey man I see you posting this often and it kind of looks like an ego projection thing of saying RC isn’t as good as he thinks he is? I really don’t see the need of continually only bringing this up when RC is around and nowhere else or why you want to play here if you are going to keep doing that.

If you genuinely just think MS sucks it might be better to coach or mentor players on how to improve instead of doing this because it looks rather childish when you post these kinds of things

[chennisden]

Are you saying that problem is equivalent to something like, "Pick two random from 11+4 and find the probability of both being town"? That would be wrong. I haven't seen any easy reduction yet.

Not quite as scum always kills town

But scum always kills the highest ranked players so just rank them

[chennisden]

Lynch

- Okay

1of4

- Should be disabled if there's only one scum left

8-ball

- Okay, but maybe make it easier for town to hit the 8ball?

Arena

- Okay

Call a Friend

- Can only call one player and if that player doesn't give anything no message will be displayed

Coalition

- Allow scum to nightkill

Dance

- After dance, undo dance pairs and allow scum to kill

Popcorn

- Okay

Protect

- Okay I guess

Quiz

- Have no idea tbh

Rank

- Okay

Reveal

- Okay

Treestump

- Okay

Vengeful

- Should allow scum to nightkill if town is the one to venge

Veto

- idk

Also thought about a mafia 1-shot repicker

Lol Quiz is fine. Although you could catch scum at the cost of 5 towns

[chennisden]

3 towns

Wait Quiz is lowkey OP and Ive been telling you that all along. Its a weaker Reveal and Protect put together. You should always guess town

[chennisden]

It drags out deepwolves or confirms leaders as town

Like, that is lowkey OP if we quizzed NF.

[chennisden]

I shut up about it because it was that good for town.

[Creature]

Can't scum just choose a weaker player though?

[Nancy Drew 39]

I knew there was something wrong with the NF/RC dynamic. The way people followed NF's reads without much thought should have been a clear indication that they were either powerwolves or being pocketed to do scum's bidding.

The scumteam manipulated the game state perfectly. Lynching obv town PB and Titus was very clever.

I was surprised Creature was scum tbh I have not seen him play this way as scum.

Maybe next time don’t sr a slot and get all mad and defensive when people ask you to back up that read. Calling Maria scum w/o ever attempting to case her looked like flat out open wolfing to me. And omgussing everyone who sr you, also didn’t help matters.

You should have recognized from LotV, that this was 100% my towngame and not misread me.

You were not playing at all similar here to that game.

Yes, scum pocketed me but both you and TD acted super scummy, although TD eventually obvtowned with baezu AtE.

As for Chenn, I was overly paranoid about him being potential mislynchbait. Both BEF, Tohru and especially Ank recognized he was scum.

@BEF, really sorry I contributed in mislynching you but you get the town MVB prize for correctly identifying scum!Chenn the earliest. You really made up for LNT in THIS game and I wouldn’t want your contribution to go unnoticed.

Thanks, I was slow to get started in this game and once I got going I got lynched.

I had fun though, I love games like this and LNT.

Yeah, LNT was my favourite Boon game by far.

[chennisden]

Oh wait scum chooses.

Still.

[mhsmith0]

As the person who ultimately approved this, please feel free to direct balance complaints to my way I guess. It’s been like 3-4 months since I reviewed it tho so i probably won’t have any real thoughts available quickly though.

[RadiantCowbells]

smith ur shit

[RadiantCowbells]

mhshit0

[Pink Ball]

hmmshit

[chennisden]

Your intentions are defined by how things went because they never would've gone well

[RadiantCowbells]

Let's all watch the godfather

[themilkcartonkid]

Back from self-imposed exile to say vindicated. Kthanxbye

[Dannflor]

didn’t u push the coalitions

[OkaPoka]

w h e r e a r e t h e p t s

[chennisden]

go iso bnl

i think we released maf pt too

[OkaPoka]

I WANT SCUM PT I NO SEE SCUM PT I WANT SCUM PT I NO SEE SCUM PT

also super secret mbaki pt

[chennisden]

i thought we already all agreed to release it

[volxen]

i thought we already all agreed to release it

No, the Mafia PT hasn't been released.