Posted: Mon Jun 26, 2017 12:02 pm
In a vacuum:
Face-to-Face Mafia > Real-Time Mafia > Forum Mafia
EM was great. People would argue over when that was, but you're kidding yourself if you deny that playing the game in real-time isn't more exciting and necessarily more true to the origins of the game itself. I think EM can be a more fulfilling version of Mafia. It's all about the people though. I'd take my chances (and have for the past ~9 years) with a random person at MS before I would at EM.
That said, I've never had more fun playing Mafia than I did during the best times at EM. Even my most memorable games here don't measure up. I have to do a meetup one of these days and see if face-to-face surpasses it (which I think it would), but I'll never forget the fun I had at EM many years ago.
Face-to-Face Mafia > Real-Time Mafia > Forum Mafia
EM was great. People would argue over when that was, but you're kidding yourself if you deny that playing the game in real-time isn't more exciting and necessarily more true to the origins of the game itself. I think EM can be a more fulfilling version of Mafia. It's all about the people though. I'd take my chances (and have for the past ~9 years) with a random person at MS before I would at EM.
That said, I've never had more fun playing Mafia than I did during the best times at EM. Even my most memorable games here don't measure up. I have to do a meetup one of these days and see if face-to-face surpasses it (which I think it would), but I'll never forget the fun I had at EM many years ago.