Haunted House - Game Ended

[Cheery Dog]

Pagetops /in

[Cheery Dog]

Ohai I have arrived to confirm

[Cheery Dog]

It's only going to be obvious is we end up with someone being separated or something.

In any case, i think i want inside that suit of armour.

[Cheery Dog]

but the good ghost would be able to help protect more of us with the same strategy.

[Cheery Dog]

I don't think I'm going to feel safe in any of these places

[Cheery Dog]

When only one of us is winning, I'm not seeing the point in any claims.

Setup speculation and trying to break games like this are why i stopped playing Mafia.
If there was a rule of identify the bad and good ghosts and you can escape and win earlier, I'd actually see a point in us progressing with claims and what have you. But since it's not, I'll just continue to be scared and have no idea what is happening

[Cheery Dog]

Isn't that exactly what Charles for trying to have us do yesterday?

I still don't believe that's the spirit of the game and i will continue hiding wherever I choose.
It will probably lead myself to my death, but that's what i get.

[Cheery Dog]

If I wanted to play games where the goal was to just narrow down information instead of trying to have fun, I'd still be playing mafia.

[Cheery Dog]

Don't leave me with all these crazies Equinox!

I guess at the very least we're not as bad as the other thread with how they're breaking the game.
I hope we're not going to get to that level

[Cheery Dog]

I disagree with it still.
because I don't feel like working something out in that manner is worthwhile

I'll probably end up following it because I am still here to win, but I disagree with doing it in that manner all the same.

[Cheery Dog]

Just because it's going to be kind obvious when i don't die here.

I'm one of the ghosts.
My submission was under the table unless all the villagers were following the plan.

[Cheery Dog]

I wanted to try and protect the people that weren't doing the stupid plan.
Aka people that actually

want

to play

[Cheery Dog]

I have choices I can attempt to make of who I'd like to see win with me, that is correct.

[Cheery Dog]

Those games are boring though!

can't we do that other two instead because when i fail at them it's funnier than a flipped table?

[Cheery Dog]

How are you all feeling about the game? It certainly seems terribly broken but I don't want to make any changes without all sides approving them. Let me know what I can do to make this enjoyable!

I think the premise behind the game is great, but I think that we have a breaking strategy here by limiting the options for the bad ghost.

That fact you're okay with going it ahead kind of proves it ain't actually broken yet.

based on the other thread, the only thing that probably needs changed to fix the breakage is the removal of the rule of if all visitors and the good ghost are in the same location the bad ghost also appears in the same location.
The rest is strategy that doesn't even make sense for people's plans.

[Cheery Dog]

There's nothing wrong with how you handled it Chevre.

My message of combining the ghosts into one I sent with my submission should still maybe work.
Probably more like Mafia as it's just an extended 3p lylo and no lynches, but interesting maybe