Win, Lose, or Banana (Game Over!)

[RedCoyote]

milkshake, Antihero, and implosion... don't start hating on me because I'm the banana and you're not.

Zodiark and vez know that the real banana wouldn't be so eager to claim the banana. They'd act casual about it, because they know they're golden.

[milkshake]

Nah, I happen to know that my reaction to being banana would be like

[implosion]

milkshake, Antihero, and implosion... don't start hating on me because I'm the banana and you're not.

Zodiark and vez know that the real banana wouldn't be so eager to claim the banana. They'd act casual about it, because they know they're golden.

This is a WIFOM strategy. You're saying this because then you're going to act casual, which will make them think it's you based on your reasoning. In reality, since the real bananas have the same win condition as the losers, they are likely to act similarly. So essentially, it is a popularity contest.

PICK ME!

Also, as of now I suspect milkshake is the other real banana (along with me). No, me saying this doesn't do anything for me, but I'm just putting it out there.

[vezokpiraka]

Ah????.

I have no idea what to do.
I'll let zodiark choose first.

[RedCoyote]

vez, look, don't fret. I've got a real easy strategy for you. Just pick me as the banana, and don't worry about what the others are saying. Listen, implosion is trying to make it look like if you pick anyone but him it's a popularity contest. Pay him no mind. I think when you take a close look at all your options here, you'll clearly see that I'm the banana you seek.

[vezokpiraka]

I might pick you.

Give me a reason why I shouldn't pick you?

[milkshake]

Hm, should I reciprocate Implosion's correct positive evaluation of my banananess? Nah, that would be needless nicery. Instead: I disagree!! This game isn't a popularity contest! It's a weird banana-hunting, uh, banana contest?

[implosion]

vez, look, don't fret. I've got a real easy strategy for you. Just pick me as the banana, and don't worry about what the others are saying. Listen, implosion is trying to make it look like if you pick

anyone but him

it's a popularity contest. Pay him no mind. I think when you take a close look at all your options here, you'll clearly see that I'm the banana you seek.

Blatant lies and slander. It's a popularity contest if I get picked as well. In fact, since the winners were announced in-thread, you three (other non-winners) could have theoretically just come into the thread without looking at your role PM.

RedCoyote: trying too hard.
Me: possibly trying too hard, but willing to admit it.
milkshake: looking like a banana.
Antihero: lurking because he's sad he isn't a banana.

[Antihero]

^lol, isn't it funny when losers buddy up?

[implosion]

Hm. So you claim to have absolute knowledge about who the other banana is from your point of view (you imply it's redcoyote)? And even if losers knew each other, why would they buddy up?

By the way - I think this game would work well as an iterated, which I assume is why it says "Phase 1" on the topic title.

Also I'm still a banana.

[milkshake]

Oh yeah what are the phases of this game by the way?

So despite the buddyishness of this statement I actually do think implosion is more likely to be a banana than a loser.

[Kitoari]

Oh yeah what are the phases of this game by the way?

Total nonsense.

PHASE 2 BEGINS NOW.

[implosion]

Shit just got real.

[RedCoyote]

Give me a reason why I shouldn't pick you?

If you wanted to give the banana to the loser perhaps. Like to cheer them up. Or if you want to let Zodiark pick me and get all the glory, I guess there's that too.

You can tell by the way implosion is overanalyzing that he is most assuredly

not

a banana. I'm still unsure on the other two.

[vezokpiraka]

Pick RC

Hopefully I was right..

[Zodiark13]

Sorry for my absence, bookmarking topics somtimes works, and other times, you just forget.

Being the first one to suggest someone else is a banana, weather right or wrong, is picking material in books. Just hope you're not rotten implosion.

Pick implosion

[Antihero]

this game sucks

[implosion]

Well, Zodiark wins :3. IDK about vezok.

[Kitoari]

Vezokpiraka...

has failed! RC was a devious loser!

Zodiark...

has won, along with implosion!

Antihero and Milkshake have lost by default.

Antihero - Loser
Milkshake - Banana
implosion - Banana
RedCoyote - Loser

Thank you for playing! Slow game though

[implosion]

Called it.
:3.

[RedCoyote]

Good work, vez!

[Zodiark13]

Woo. Sorry, slow pace was my bad.

[vezokpiraka]

Cool game.

RC was too convincing.

[Kcdaspot]

mod start this again plz... this looks way too fun