In post 315, vettrock wrote:Interesting game. I've been watching/lurking on this for a while. I thought mastin was scum, but I wouldn't have guessed Titus. I do think the odds are a lot more in the scum's favor for this game. I'm not sure if town would have had 5 tries if they could have got it. Mastin would be confirmed scum after the 4th mission, but the other one could be anyone.
5 tries is plenty for town. I only got on the last mission. Town cannot have so many missions where they win by PoE.
Mastina was not confirmed scum. BB and Mist or Foil were possible. BB only sat out one mission.
I guess you are right. Either Mastin, and anyone, or BB and Mist, or BB and Foil. With 5 players there are 10 possible combinations and only one that is correct. I don't think increasing it to 5 tries is that bad for scum. I think scum is still 50% or better for chance to win.
Foilist also began to look like the boy who cried wolf considering his early stated position and never following through with it. Also given me being conftown to Mastina helped a fair amount.
In post 315, vettrock wrote:Interesting game. I've been watching/lurking on this for a while. I thought mastin was scum, but I wouldn't have guessed Titus.
That was pretty much the opposite of what everyone was seeing, so I do want to ask you why. I thought (from my fairly biased view) Titus played a very blatantly scum-driven earlygame (albeit she did do better later), and that I was playing a fairly strong scumgame. (Hey, I did get taken on literally every single mission! And was the only player to do so!)
In post 315, vettrock wrote:Interesting game. I've been watching/lurking on this for a while. I thought mastin was scum, but I wouldn't have guessed Titus.
That was pretty much the opposite of what everyone was seeing, so I do want to ask you why. I thought (from my fairly biased view) Titus played a very blatantly scum-driven earlygame (albeit she did do better later), and that I was playing a fairly strong scumgame. (Hey, I did get taken on literally every single mission! And was the only player to do so!)
I didn't really think you were scum until the last day. The message you wrote about how even though Titus was confirmed town to you, you still didn't trust her seemed like contrived scum post. That and you being on every mission and every mission failing, sort of seemed that way to me as well, even though it was certainly possible for you to be town.
.
