Nomic

[ika]

aye to all

[Felissan]

Nay to 5

That hammers it.

Rule proposal 6:

Every player has a Cash counter that starts at 0 and increases by 100 once per day at midnight EST.

[Aronis]

Aye to six and four.

Rule proposal #8: The first post a player makes during the time span of 12:00 EST to 11:59 EST each day will earn them 25 dollars on the cash counter.

Aye to eight.

That way people will be encouraged to post at least once a day and vote on any proposals

[JDGA]

Nay 5, Aye 6, Aye 8

Rule Proposal #7:

Rule breaches can be assessed a fine in terms of "penalty units". One penalty unit is defined as 25 dollars subtracted from the cash counter.

Rule Proposal #9:

Rule proposals must be in numeric order. Should a player number a proposal out of order, they will be assessed a fine of two penalty units.

Rule Proposal #10:

Every player must vote on every proposal within 48 hours of the proposal's creation. Should a player fail to do so, they will be assessed a fine of one penalty unit.

Aye 7, 9, and 10

[Aronis]

aye to 7

We definitely need a system in place to penalize rule breakers

nay to 9

I dont see how that will really help anything, plus I'm bound to fall victim to that.

Gonna think about ten for a bit.

[ForWhomTheJellyRolls]

Aye to 6 7 8 9

Not sure about 10.

[Felissan]

Aye to 6

, because I'm a derp and I forgot to vote for it.

Aye to 8

, activity is gooood.

Aye to 7 and 9

, because there's no reason not to.

Nay to 10

, because as "gooood" as activity is, 48 hours is still pretty harsh.

So, 6, 7 and 8 are in, 9 is at 3-1 and 10 at 2-0.

(Also, I may or may not be mispelled in OP.)

[ika]

aye to all but 10

[Aronis]

Rule Proposal #11: If you propose a rule you will be automatically counted as voting in favor of that rule unless you state otherwise.
Aye to 11

[JDGA]

Aye to 11

[ika]

aye

[Drench]

RP #12:

The mod will maintain a list of current rule proposals at all times, in an easily accessible and central location.

aye 12

[Drench]

RP #13:

The mod will maintain a summary of votes for and against on all proposals at all times, in an easily accessible and central location.

aye 13

[Drench]

nay to 6
nay to 8
nay to 7
nay to 9
nay to 10
aye to 11

[rolls eyes] cash

[JDGA]

Nay 12, 13

I don't think we want to enforce a 24/7 presence on anyone

[Drench]

okay mr letter of the law

[Felissan]

VOTE: Aye to 11 just for the sake of it even though it has already reached majority and holy cow that's a long vote
VOTE: Nay to 12-13

Rule proposal 14:

A player may give anything they own to another player at any time without needing anyone's consent.

[Drench]

Rule Proposal #14

: At least once every 24 hours, the mod should update a list of current rule proposals and their vote status.

are you fucks happy

Rule Proposal #15

: A player may suggest amendments to a current rule proposal at any time; if they are agreeable to the proposer, they will be added to the rule and voting will recommence.

so that shit doesnt die because of wording again

[JDGA]

Have you ever played Nomic before? This entire

game

is all about the letter of the law. Everyone fools around and does whatever for a while, then someone finds some crazy series of loopholes to give themselves an instant win and everyone debates for a week over whether or not what they did is legal
And no, we're not happy, you doubled up on number 14.
VOTE: Nay Feli's 14 - need a definition on ownership first, and not having the recipient's consent will probably break things
VOTE: Yay Drench's 14
VOTE: Nay 15 - the votes don't reset?

[Aronis]

Aye 12
Aye 13
Aye Drench's 14

The mod needs to quit slacking and get to work

[Drench]

Have you ever played Nomic before? This entire

game

is all about the letter of the law. Everyone fools around and does whatever for a while, then someone finds some crazy series of loopholes to give themselves an instant win and everyone debates for a week over whether or not what they did is legal
And no, we're not happy, you doubled up on number 14.
VOTE: Nay Feli's 14 - need a definition on ownership first, and not having the recipient's consent will probably break things
VOTE: Yay Drench's 14
VOTE: Nay 15 - the votes don't reset?

can we do that..................after we got a basic admin structure in place

[Aronis]

The rules don't say anything about the moderator being unchangeable. And our moderator has failed to login since Sunday, so

Rule Proposal #16:

The current moderator, Burning_Earth, will be replaced effective immediately and a public vote will be held to elect a new moderator who upon receiving a plurality of votes will assume the position immediately.

Aye to 16

[JDGA]

VOTE: Nay 16 - Good idea, but that wording is super weird (with no specified end other than someone receiving a "plurality", wouldn't the first vote technically decide it?)

[Aronis]

Plurality was meant to prevent a deadlock from occuring with no real majority ever forming, if I changed it to majority would you support the rule?

[JDGA]

I'd support it if it set a specific end time at which point plurality is checked