Clue (Game over, gauging interest in new game with new mod)

[StrangerCoug]

Here goes nothing.

I accuse Plum, with a Revolver, in the Kitchen.

That is correct

[Datisi]

PINE

YOUR LAST SUGGESTION GAVE ME THE LAST PIECES OF INFO I NEEDED

I LOVE YOU

[lilith2013]

Please count me as /in for next game if you plan to run another!

[Datisi]

is this correct?

[StrangerCoug]

I'll think about it It will probably be another thread, though.

[StrangerCoug]

is this correct?

Yep

[inspiratieloos]

First time I actually managed to get the answer before the game ended as a spectator.

GE was probably right to take a shot at it, though what he guessed was impossible. I figured it out after Pine's last guess, so Pine, skitter and Nancy could all have won.

[Datisi]

Agh, i spent like an hour going through the thread again and remaking my notes to check if my logic was correct... good game! I'm definitely /in if there's another run.

[Pine]

PINE

YOUR LAST SUGGESTION GAVE ME THE LAST PIECES OF INFO I NEEDED

I LOVE YOU

I had everything but the room

[Pine]

Spoiler:

[Pine]

I see you're making assumptions based on what people are asking, though, and that's dangerous.

[Datisi]

Hm? there were no assumptions made. The question marks next to three cards are "this is probably the cards they have, but it doesn't matter if i figure them out because I know the solution already".

[Pine]

That's fair

The room was my Achilles heel this game. I had presumptive positives on Plum and Revolver ages ago, but the process of elimination on the rooms was prohibitive. No one guessed Hall at all (though now as I look back at my spreadsheet, I'd eliminated everything from Mena's column except Peacock and Hall, should have had that) and not the Kitchen until Nancy at the end. I couldn't positively eliminate Study either.

I sat there analyzing the spreadsheet for twenty minutes before passing, but couldn't justify a YOLO guess. Pity. If I had noticed the Hall connection, I'd have had a 50/50 shot, and Kitchen was a tighter guess.

Damn. Good game.

This might be better as a live game.

[Datisi]

Until your last suggestion I didn't know the room. However, once your guess confirmed to me that Formerfish (or whoever replaced him, i kept using original names) does not have Plum (and thus Plum is the solution), i realized he must have Scarlet.

I still had 3 rooms possible, but - i knew I didn't have Kitchen. Neither Xtoxm nor Mena had Kitchen because of an earlier guess. I knew all of skitt's and Pine's cards, and they didn't have it either. I knew 2 of FF's cards. Once I realized his last one is Scarlet, that meant he couldn't have Kitchen either. And he was the last possible candidate for it.

[Xtoxm]

gg datisi
i put a fair amount of effort keeping people away from my rooms, but didnt help i guess

[Gamma Emerald]

First time I actually managed to get the answer before the game ended as a spectator.

GE was probably right to take a shot at it, though what he guessed was impossible. I figured it out after Pine's last guess, so Pine, skitter and Nancy could all have won.

I had assume FFish was guessing his own cards on his first based on his following actions but idk what he wasn’t thinking now

[Pine]

I'm eager to play again. This felt more like a warmup

[Datisi]

I'd love to play again too, but is there a way for this to be a marathon? The fact this game lasted over 3 months is kinda annoying.

[Pine]

Especially given that every round necessitates 18 actions - guess, response, accusation/pass times six

[Gamma Emerald]

I'd love to play again too, but is there a way for this to be a marathon? The fact this game lasted over 3 months is kinda annoying.

That would probably work

[inspiratieloos]

First time I actually managed to get the answer before the game ended as a spectator.

GE was probably right to take a shot at it, though what he guessed was impossible. I figured it out after Pine's last guess, so Pine, skitter and Nancy could all have won.

I had assume FFish was guessing his own cards on his first based on his following actions but idk what he wasn’t thinking now

FF/Nancy had the Lounge and the Knife and each player has only 3 cards. So if you assume they have Plum then they can't have any other card, no one else had the Kitchen, so if FF/Nancy has Plum the Kitchen would have been in the envelope.

[Gamma Emerald]

That was a mistype but I got it wrong even if I typed what I meant

[Nancy Drew 39]

Congrats Datisi.

[enomis]

Any Chance of a second round for this?

Would be interested in playing.

[StrangerCoug]

Not in this thread, but anyone who's interested in running another game in another thread is free to.