I discarded the Mafia compulsive hider card because it was the only mafia card I had and I didn't want to align myself with them nor did I want the role. To answer Stunguns's question in post 52,
"Which discard are you feeling is most likely to be town-motivated? And which one scum/independent faction-motivated?"
Kop's
discarded card is definitely the most town motivated. I don't think there's any other mafia card/combination that's more beneficial to mafia than that one. I think
Stungun's
discard choice feels town motivated, I feel like scum wouldn't care at all as long as it's not a mafia teammate.
Not_Mafia
's of Alien Sympathiser, means that if there aren't any aliens, they would be a Vanilla Townie, still Town just no ability. I can't say that it's totally town motivation here.
ManWithNoName
- Lover, NAI because that's a really risky modifier. You could be town but your lover is scum and maybe you find out your lover is someone you don't really get along with playerwise so I can see why someone would discard that.
Invisibility
- Lover ^^ see above reasons for the discard.
Fredrick A Campbel
l - Survivor, I'm getting Scum/Independent vibes because as survivor, all you have to is try to make it to the end and rely on your game skills to win with either faction, what's better than that given your choices?
ceejayvinoya
with One-Shot Commuter - That role would have been helpful if you have another ability that helps you help the town with the game. I'm feeling scum/indie vibes for the discard.
Maestro
- Lyncher, NAI because I feel like they could have gotten their lynchee target lynched but says in
16 "Micc ruled that alignment/wincon were the Lyncher part of the role, whereas the power was Vanilla. I didn’t want either of those, so I discarded it." seems decent enough on the surface as far as reasoning.