Post
Post #1905 (isolation #600) » Wed Jul 22, 2020 2:57 pm
Postby Alisae »
i forced 2 flips in a row because i'm stubborn and couldn't agree to anything else
and now the more i think about it, the more i am starting to talk myself into porkens being scum with pk
but honestly idunno idc anymore i don't deserve to win this game
Post
Post #1907 (isolation #601) » Wed Jul 22, 2020 3:01 pm
Postby Alisae »
im only talking myself into it because Hiraki asked me about it and the more serious thought i give it it makes sense but I don't know.
only thing i know is i don't deserve to win so...
Post
Post #1959 (isolation #618) » Thu Jul 23, 2020 1:49 am
Postby Alisae »
In post 1957, CreativeMod1 wrote:At least if we get Ali out now then whoever out of Porkens or Hiraki is alive tomorrow can help me decide between you and PK
Post
Post #1969 (isolation #625) » Thu Jul 23, 2020 2:10 am
Postby Alisae »
Like why would he need to claim if he's a town doctor?
He didn't save the kill. He knows that I proved myself as the jailkeeper if he really is a doctor.
I don't see the reason for him to claim
Post
Post #1971 (isolation #626) » Thu Jul 23, 2020 2:15 am
Postby Alisae »
CM1, what is more realistic
- Me fakeclaiming Jailkeeper without any knowledge of what power roles exist in the game outside of 1 protective role
- Porkens fakeclaiming Doctor in response to him seeing his kill fail and me saying i jailkept Porkens
I don't see a CM1 and Hiraki team making these galaxy brain plays
given the context of Porken’s claim (There was a no kill n2 and after I immediately claimed that I jailkept Porkens, Porkens claimed doc 2 mins later) it is possible that Porkens is scum fakeclaiming doc.
Post
Post #2087 (isolation #631) » Thu Jul 23, 2020 5:25 pm
Postby Alisae »
In post 2082, Not_Mafia wrote:Oh yeah this set-up has that extra VT thing. So couldn't you be fakeclaiming aswell?
I mean technically yes but for me to be fakeclaiming I needed to have rolecopped Porkens N1 and hope that the real Jailkeeper doesn’t CC me or there isn’t a cop in the setup. I think thats the only realistic way my jailkeep claim is fakeclaimable with the least amount of risk possible, and that scenario I don’t think exists considering I would always shoot Porkens N2 in that scenario
Post
Post #2093 (isolation #632) » Thu Jul 23, 2020 5:29 pm
Postby Alisae »
Idunno NM
Do you think I fakeclaim JK in a situation that makes it very risky to get CC’d.
I can’t claim Jailkeeper if I rolecopped a cop
I can’t claim Jailkeeper if I rolecopped a Jailkeeper
I can claim Jailkeeper if I rolecopped a Doc or VT but the setup could be Doc + Cop or Doc + Jailkeeper and I get CC’d by a jailkeeper or if the setup is Doc + Cop, then its confirmed that one of the PRs has scum in it and I don’t rly want to be in that situation either tbh.
Like if I fakeclaim jailkeeper here I lucked out basically
Post
Post #2102 (isolation #634) » Thu Jul 23, 2020 5:33 pm
Postby Alisae »
The biggest question I have atm is would a town!doctor immediately claim after hearing that I jailkept them and there was no kill
And atm I am leaning towards no
In post 2090, Porkens wrote:Day 2 there was no kill so alisae scum would know there was a protective. She got peta to admit he was not a PR, and the scum also have an RB. I think that’s good enough odds for her to fake it.
This seems weirdly out of place and tinfoil discredity
I didn’t believe ems Jk claim. Ems posts day 1 and day 2 seemed to be from a “I’ll show these boobs how fucking great scum I am I’m going to explain how I play as scum and then do exactly that”. Like e’s just having a big fucking giggle at us being on every town wagon, faking JK to get nexus killed, now the coup de grace is exiling the doctor.
I wouldn’t want to drag out the game for as long as possible though. I would flip Nexus, shoot someone (probs you) and the flip some other townie for game. When you fakeclaim, the longer the game goes on the more your fakeclaim is at risk of getting exposed.
Post
Post #2128 (isolation #638) » Thu Jul 23, 2020 5:48 pm
Postby Alisae »
It’s the same reason i don’t bus unless I have to or think its an actual + winrate play, I would rather just end the game as soon as possible, even if my partner is dead weight. My scumplay gets worse and worse as I get later into the and I would rather just win the game as soon as possible. The times where I’ve had to win by myself are very few. Yes I got all the way to the end of the game by myself, but winning from there is just completely different.
Post
Post #2145 (isolation #642) » Thu Jul 23, 2020 6:02 pm
Postby Alisae »
In post 2141, petapan wrote:kept trying to explain how literally everyone had voted him and there was no way he was p[aired with anyone and you kept trying to just badger me into voting him and ignoring what i said
if I decided to turn on my brain, I see the Hiraki vote and question myself if thats a scum indicative play. I don’t think anything you said would change my mind because the way I solve I basically form a mini map of everyone’s stances on each other and use flips to try and understand the gamestate. If anything, you defending him made me want to flip him more because the stakes were really high.
Post
Post #2151 (isolation #644) » Thu Jul 23, 2020 6:15 pm
Postby Alisae »
Btw Porkens if you want a secret tip for re-reading, what you can do, is you can use this link viewtopic.php?f=83&ppp=200&t=83575
And it increases teh amount of posts from 25 to 200 per page
Post
Post #2207 (isolation #650) » Fri Jul 24, 2020 6:34 pm
Postby Alisae »
In post 2205, CreativeMod1 wrote:I'd see which cancel would be the easiest and get that through and then random luck that the night killer isn't jailed
and then you get called out for your reads not being consistent
In post 2244, CreativeMod1 wrote:Can I ask, what happens if we're in a complete deadlock? like as a town we can't decide on someone to cancel and so don't cancel anyone and then if Mafia refuse to kill in the night? like what happens if that cycle continues over and over? this is probably a
@MOD
question but yeah
Different mods would probably have different ways of handling this situation (it doesn't come up very often).
Personally, I'm a big fan of "Rocks fall, everyone dies."
More seriously, in the case of a true deadlock (Town no-cancels, then scum no-kills, or vice-versa), I would put the onus to end the deadlock on whichever faction started it.
So if town no-canceled first, then scum no-killed, the next day phase would not end until a cancel was achieved.
If scum no-killed first, then town no-canceled, then scum would be required to submit a kill the next night.
Post
Post #2643 (isolation #660) » Thu Jul 30, 2020 4:43 pm
Postby Alisae »
on d3 i considered replacing out but then deleted the pm because i figured that the slot was pratically doomed and no one deserved to feel obligated to dig themselves out of the hole that was the slot