@DkKoba:
I'm just gonna parrot what most have been saying in that your style is very abrasive and antagonistic, and it's just not enjoyable to play with or be around. I play mafia for fun, and although I want to win as well, there's no value in winning for me if I don't do it while having fun. When you're so aggressive and intense it just leads to unpleasant situations. You said it yourself that you push people with fake reasons and confidence (like you did to Ico), just to get an emotional reaction from them so you can better read their alignment. Sure, that works for you, but it's just really not enjoyable for the person on the receiving end or everyone else who has to read through the resulting gamestate. Ya get me?
I feel like this is something you can definitely improve on if you try, since you're clearly capable of playing non-abrasively at times, like I was impressed with how you dealt with that situation with Don Corleone, you very incredible reasonable about it all things considered.
Sorry for not including you in the list like that, that was a bit mean.