In post 460, Hiraki wrote:This is a bad vote but it's RVS so whatever.
In post 19, Creature wrote:(fun fact: my RVS votes tend to be slightly serious if the player I vote already posted)
Then I really don't like your vote.
In post 22, Human Sequencer wrote:No, it was a gambit. Based on your question that I baited you into asking, you are scum, and Human has been acting really towny while at l-1. I also buy their claim.
VOTE: Vedith
Die scum die.
Small townpoints.
In post 36, Creature wrote:What are the other reasonings to put someone at L-1 without warning?
I hope this is the D1 flip. If not, work needs to be done.
If I was new, I would do the same thing that my predecessor did. I don't agree with it but I understand where he is coming from.
You're taking these two too seriously.
In post 100, PsychoticDave wrote:I'm getting the feeling that Creature is Mafia and knows who the Chosen Townies are, so he's trying to act like he doesn't know.
I hope you explain this.
Tenshii's vote in 111 is fantastic and is probably the best post of the game thusfar.
Mewtaph is pretty townie from 131. :^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^))))))
In post 158, shaddowez wrote:Asks Misa for reads in 113, then sheeps a vote on her in 131 before she answers.
I was quite OK with my predecessor's vote and that's coming from someone who tries to usually say the opposite. What's wrong with a bit of pressure?
In post 167, Vedith wrote:I understood that he is Creature but why can't they be scum together? Your post indicates that Human is town 100%?
I buy this theory pretty hard and there's not a lot of scumslip theories that I buy.
In post 179, shaddowez wrote: In post 167, Vedith wrote:I understood that he is Creature but why can't they be scum together? Your post indicates that Human is town 100%?
My post in no way says that. Let's start with the idea they're a scum team - there's no way Creature's RVS vote happens like that. He draws way too much attention to both of them during RVS by putting Human at L-1 and then unvoting. It's RVS, he could have easily avoided the wagon entirely and it's doubtful anybody would have thought anything of it.
Now, if Creature's town like I think he is, then his behavior makes sense regardless of if Human is scum or town. Creature doesn't know, so putting an RVS wagon at L-1 is terrible. If Human is town, it allows for a derphammer/quickhammer. With 1 page into the game, I can't imagine town having a solid enough read on someone to risk that.
I either don't buy this or fully understand this.
Are you kind of guesstimating if a scum team would do something on D1 to save themselves? It's a bit too theory heavy for me with no flips.
Vedith and I rarely 100% agree but when we do, it's kind of bad. This behavior is really quite intolerable.
In post 193, Human Sequencer wrote:Unsure on shadow. Need more.
It's either 'probably town' or 'probably scum' once I work out his personality though, none of this 'kinda' bullshit.
Very faint buddying here tbh
Really? I hope this stuff doesn't continue.
In post 228, Human Sequencer wrote:Vedith is setting up mislynches, this man knows who is town and who is scum and he knows both creature and I are town.
I don't buy this - mind explaining what you mean in this post a little in depth?
Really don't get the Dave TRs.
In post 259, TTTT wrote:@dave
I think I counted 4 posts where you said anything that might be useful
too nice tbh, hopefully your posts will make Misa's mistakes look better - Misa always seems weird.
In post 264, nn30 wrote:Back it up. Link to everything you've just linked to, but this time, with an explanation for why you think I'm acting in each of those particular posts. Then tell me why you think my analysis is superficial. Then tell me how my 'acting posts' aren't just town poking and prodding in the way that I play town and are, in fact, scum motivated. Then tell me how my 'analysis' as you see it is scum motivated. Then we can begin to have a conversation.
This is fair. I don't think it's very fair to just post something without content.
oo 282 is a bad vote, I apologize for Mewtaph for being such a cuck - would've rather voted shadoweh
These are some pretty shitty scumreads (less shaddowez) tbh
In post 302, shaddowez wrote:All you do is say I'm scum for lurking/dodging, but would rather lynch somebody else first.
I don't agree with this.
In post 302, shaddowez wrote:Additionally, if you actually thought I was scum way back in 165 for a "scum slip", you would've pushed me a hell of a lot harder.
I agree with this.
Not a fan of this at all
Mod: Just in case this happens again, you have the right to enforce content-related prods.
I'm not playing with a player with such an attitude like you again.
I don't get the point of trying to figure out pairings without a flip. Can we not do that?
I don't like this - you were doing really well too.
I would much much rather lynch you than anyone else for this vote.
There's a difference for "wanting the day to end" and voting for no reason. This is /literally/ going to happen again tomorrow.
In post 449, shaddowez wrote:I'd rather a Vedith lynch, but with the slot replacing anyway I'll do this.
I really liked everything else in this post but this and this was probably the most important part.
Why does the player make a difference if your read on the slot was dependent on the slot? That might sound redundant but I hope I'm getting my point somewhat across.
In post 459, PsychoticDave wrote:I just want the day to end so we actually have evidence for these accusations rather than accusing people for not being active enough.
Please play the game. This is horrendous play regardless what role you have. The fact that this is UNANIMOUS among all players in the game should say something to you.
Here's my opinion of the current people alive (please read below before voting so quickly m8ys):
Human Sequencer - I need to re-read these posts in ISO. Vedith was very much adamant but I'm not sure if I agree with that push. I would rather Human live to D2 rather than be a D1 lynch.
PsychoticDave - Player who is ruining the game by being a baby about the game. This is an OK D1 lynch for all of the wrong reasons. I would really rather a replacement (sorry mod)
shaddowez - I'm OK with a lynch on this slot. Would give a lot of good reads and isn't very consistent in scumreads (n.b. that the reads part is moreso focusing on townreads)
Tenshii - Generally town, I would also like to ISO to confirm some of the failures in his current play (last few pages)
Grendel - I TR'd Vedith but it was very weak.
Creature - Town due to interactions not so much due to content.
TTTT - Scumread only due to Misa stuff - definitely not a D1 lynch.
nn30 - Would like to look into TTTT's claims. I will admit that if I skimmed anyone's posts the most, it was here.
Won't be voting until I finish doing some due diligence on the above. Reads are subject to change based off of that. Also note that these reads are coming out of finishing the review of the game and not taking a step back and looking at my review at a whole. It is definitely an incomplete work.