My reads list:
Note: That said, he's also kinda bad at setup spec given that he thinks there's a chance the neighborizer is scum. I didn't say his material was GOOD.
thenewearth: Gut says town but logic says that this is scum trying to get towncred like what monkey is saying. Need more data.
humaneatingmonkey: Null only because I'm being pulled in 2 directions. I like his nuance when it comes to my slot (not jumping to a townread or scumread, just commenting well on the wagon) but I don't like the "There's scum on my wagon but I'm townreading everyone". This is a predicament that more often happens to scum who knows everyone else is town. A couple other posts read a bit town though? Not sure.
GinghamDog: Null-scum. His line of questioning rubs me the wrong way on tone. This reads extremely similarly to a scum I played with (in I think Open 581). I'm happy to elaborate but I think my read on him will solidify one way or the other before I get to that anyway.
___________________________________________
1. I don't believe he's readable unless there's a lot of pressure on him.
2. I've done a lot of research on him; he lolhammers town as town and is generally unhelpful. Slightly less unhelpful as scum.
3. He, as scum, hides behind his "too scummy to be scum" meta and acts as anti-town as he wants... because he acts anti-town by default.
With him in the game, I highly recommend not putting anyone at L-1 unless you're ready for the hammer.
In the interest of actually voting people I think are scum based on their play, though:
VOTE: CultofAthena