Hi I'm popping in really quick the reason I don't think Luv is prob town is because of impoe's role
She can only mason town and assuming me and luv are both town along with her she has a 1/3 chance of fucking up her mason and making her useless it's...weird
The longer you stare at something the more out of focus it becomes
a lot of roles seem to have the potential to be nullified, and maybe i was expected to wait and use my power later. that would also explain not being able to use it n1...
In post 2180, Impoetic wrote:if gerry is scum and you're town, you'll probably be dead tomorrow or else the game will be practically solved by your action, no??
if scum can kill and scum isn't osuka (who I'm blocking) then I'll be dead. 2 big ifs.
I still scum read Jae’s slot for reasons I won’t get into for the rest of the game. I’ve been trying to look past those reasons but I don’t get Maria having a bit of a more heightened focus on setup speculation and using it as a reason to scum read me. I know she probably hasn’t read any of the game but I would like for her to read when I claimed and tell me why I did so as scum.
I don’t buy scum using a janitor or a janitor like ability on Math in order for Gerry to look better. Gerry had to have known that regardless of whatever he and his partner did, he was most likely going down after fake claiming public alignment cop.
Don’t get any of the town reads on Nahdia. None of her emotions feel genuine to me and she just seems to playing the town doesn’t fake claim X role card the hardest right now after I already pointed out Gerry was willing to be honest about his result.
Gerry was shown to have still targeted me at the start of Night 2 and there hasn’t been a single night kill so I’m still questioning whether Eddie is actually a split jailkeeper. The only thing I’m seeing from Eddie now that I feel holds weight is that it wasn’t town to have sheep the result that turned out to a cry from Nahdia. I can’t really give a rebuttal to that but if the belief from both heads were that Gerry is an awful player, why is it so hard to believe that he possibly fucked up as town here?
osuka remains an unknown for me as I assume everyone else.
Then there’s the night skip and no explanation for it.
—
Eddie please understand I’m not trying to game throw. I can show examples of me actually doing that and while I was fucking around shortly before this for a little bit, I realized that’s pretty shitty to do to and I’m going to actually try to play the game again.
Things just aren’t making sense and I’m not where you’re at with Jae’s slot and Nahdia. Gerry just being a flavour cop in order to give scum a confirmable action still seems very weak to me and then there is Impo’s result and the fact that it seems like you’re strongly trying to get everyone to ignore Occam’s razor when it comes to that.
I still scum read Jae’s slot for reasons I won’t get into for the rest of the game. I’ve been trying to look past those reasons but I don’t get Maria having a bit of a more heightened focus on setup speculation and using it as a reason to scum read me. I know she probably hasn’t read any of the game but I would like for her to read when I claimed and tell me why I did so as scum.
I don’t buy scum using a janitor or a janitor like ability on Math in order for Gerry to look better. Gerry had to have known that regardless of whatever he and his partner did, he was most likely going down after fake claiming public alignment cop.
Don’t get any of the town reads on Nahdia. None of her emotions feel genuine to me and she just seems to playing the town doesn’t fake claim X role card the hardest right now after I already pointed out Gerry was willing to be honest about his result.
Gerry was shown to have still targeted me at the start of Night 2 and there hasn’t been a single night kill so I’m still questioning whether Eddie is actually a split jailkeeper. The only thing I’m seeing from Eddie now that I feel holds weight is that it wasn’t town to have sheep the result that turned out to a cry from Nahdia. I can’t really give a rebuttal to that but if the belief from both heads were that Gerry is an awful player, why is it so hard to believe that he possibly fucked up as town here?
osuka remains an unknown for me as I assume everyone else.
Then there’s the night skip and no explanation for it.
—
Eddie please understand I’m not trying to game throw. I can show examples of me actually doing that and while I was fucking around shortly before this for a little bit, I realized that’s pretty shitty to do to and I’m going to actually try to play the game again.
Things just aren’t making sense and I’m not where you’re at with Jae’s slot and Nahdia. Gerry just being a flavour cop in order to give scum a confirmable action still seems very weak to me and then there is Impo’s result and the fact that it seems like you’re strongly trying to get everyone to ignore Occam’s razor when it comes to that.
role cop is probably factional, that's why its public. that, or only part of a role. osuka isn't an unknown mystery because on meta they lurk out as scum. jae's slot is a meta read from mastina, who's gone, so i can't really comment on it. nahdia, t he emotion is genuine, and i think they would've been less aggressive with preventing my lynch at day open from the fake guilty. i don't give a fuck about occam's razor, impo and nahdia are town and if we lynch osuka + gerry and don't hit both scum then and ONLY then will I deal with a potential scum!nahdia. still not entertaining scum!impo. scum have a way to deal with it, i don't know what but i never understand why nobody gets basic setup spec. alisae games aren't solved on roles, and unblockable double inno getter in a 9p game is a game solving role.
Something tells me it isn’t a factional ability though. It serves no real use to scum unless osuka is town and is Jill. Other than providing them with a confirmable action, I don’t see it as nearly enough to compensate for the lack of a night kill or for them to coast on.
mastina town reading Jae doesn’t surprise me and doesn’t hold much weight for me. We disagree on Nahdia and agree on Impo.
i don't think its necessarily compensation. maybe they need to know who a player is to kill or target a role with something or something? this game is confusing role wise man.
That player would have to be Jill though. I believe everyone has claimed flavour except osuka so if his replacement isn’t Jill then I’m very skeptical.