Gamma Emerald :
RedFlavour :
Jodaxq :
NicoRobin was lynched
They were
Night 4 (expired on 2018-02-13 11:46:28)
Thats such aIn post 255, Gamma Emerald wrote:did I just end up killing myself
Sorry, but this game was not only horribly swingy, it was also clearly bastard. The mod did not do their job properly:In post 569, ZZZX wrote:Bastard?: No, Ninjas and redirectors can exist however
Let me go through this part by part. Because yes, the setup was a bit too much, But this happens often with Upicks.In post 264, Not Known 15 wrote:Sorry, but this game was not only horribly swingy, it was also clearly bastard. The mod did not do their job properly:
There was an extremely swingy minigame: It could result in the removal of all mafia(which it did) or in an extra town death.
With a Day 1 mislynch and the extra town death:
Day 2 possibly:3v2v1. That should not happen. Worse, with a Night 1 vig against the reflector: 2v2v1. The town should not, ever, be held hostage by Day 1 and night actions to lose. WITH THE FAKE KILL EVEN 1v2v1(with one revive next day)
reflector is just a fancy name for a modified PGO which is not bastardIn post 264, Not Known 15 wrote:There was a clear bastard role(in a game announced as not bastard): The reflector.
both the town and the scum had abilities which disable that effect, Additionally I'd say the reflector role is UNDERPOWERED as you have a third-party which basically has no nightkill. Infact the town would've lost much earlier if the 3rd party had a nightkill there.In post 264, Not Known 15 wrote:It punished the town and the mafia for normally correct night actions. A bomb or PGO punishes Mafia and vigs, too... but they at least get rid of the enemy as a 1v1(a trade). A mafia PGO exposes themselves when breadcrumbs exist. Here the normally correct play resulted in a selfkill and nothing else!
The vig shot scum, and that's why town lost. Does this sound like a good thing?
If mafia ever shot the competing scum that would make them unable to win without the help of the town. Does that all sound like non-bastard?
That's wrong.In post 266, ZZZX wrote:reflector is just a fancy name for a modified PGO which is not bastard