"I like your posts so far" does mean nothing more than that I did not have any concerns about their posts so far: No indication that they weren't trying to hunt scum(as opposed to faking that), explanations...In post 299, Porkens wrote:Why don't you care? I'm asking why he is townreading you and not scumreading you. If you drop the adjective, I'm asking him "why are you townreading him?" Isn't that exactly the kind of explanation you've been so adamant about getting out of people?In post 297, Not Known 15 wrote:While I definitely do not careIn post 296, Porkens wrote:Could you link that experience please?In post 286, acidphoenix wrote:@porkens the fact that he cares infinitely more about whether people are read-explainy than things that are actually significantly more likely to make people one alignment than the other
partially biased because of having prior games with him and knowing he essentially mostly just sticks to that
Also, why does the above make him incompetent town rather than incompetent scrum?
Like I wrote before, that post was forced. It seemed to me you felt pressure to post, and that you were reaching to say "anything" about each player. I've felt that kind of pressure more as scum than as town.Porkens, I am not seeing "outstanding scuminess" there. That post does have one useless comment about siteflak, and you leaning lynchbait says leaning, not "is lynchbait", that's something else. But that could be a misunderstanding?
Secondly, there is at least one player who you give a total pass: "I like your posts so far", but you don't explain why.
Thirdly, your commanding/imperative tone rings false to me.
About that forced thing: I would have liked to do that later, but um... you know... it doesn't get better when you have to catch up more.
Picking everyone seems forced to you? Well, it was deliberately made that way it was- to include everyone to
1. affirm everyone that these are my reads
2. serve as fallback if I want to re-read
3. most importantly, they will show you where I came from; my first impressions. When I somehow die that can help you understand my thoughts and ideas better than me(because I cannot explain them anymore)
4. I get to write everything down and make sure that I don't forget to read someone correctly